3 ms·
To the East, a primary source argument was protection of The West against Communism. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24078304 https://news.ycombinator.com/
by 082349872349872 6y ago
To the East, a primary source argument was protection of The West against Communism. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24078304 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24078304
- watwut 6y agoThe communist threat was factor. But living space, alias Lebensraum was the policy and reason for expansion according to historians such as Richard Evans. The comunist threat would not require the sort of policies they had in conquered teritories. They did actually had settlers and actually moved population. It is easy to Google too.
- 082349872349872 6y agoThat wasn't to say they didn't do Lebensraum[1], that was to say the way they justified[2] their actions to themselves can be heard, in certain circles, even today. ((Primary source) argument), not (primary (source argument)), sorry. See also https://remember.org/witness/babiyar https://remember.org/witness/babiyar [1] For comparison, Custer's initial move at Greasy Grass was to threaten women and children. Some of the men in his command were in the US because they had emigrated from the reactionary aftermath of the 1848 revolutions. God is an iron. [2] is man a rational animal, or a rationalising animal? One of the giveaways of totalitarian logic is that their enemies are simultaneously both inferior and an existential threat to their superiors. (Agreed, the small-c communist threat would not have required Nazi policies. The large-C Communist threat was something I think Goebbels might have claimed existed so long as a single spark of Communism existed to re-ignite that totalitarian untermensch-driven "revolution.") (Another giveaway is lack of humour: I don't know of any famous totalitarian comedy, especially any that have used self-deprecating humour, but I'd love to be proven wrong on this point. Some regimes even banned humour: Two judges meet on the way to their chambers. One is chuckling and wiping tears from his eyes. The other asks, "what just happened?" "Oy, I just heard the most hilarious Stalin joke ever. But I'm afraid I simply can't tell it to you: I just sent the last person who repeated it to Magadan.")
- watwut 6y agoHere is the thing: German nazi would not claim to "protect The West" because they never claimed to be for the west in general. They were always for German race and for Germany. The West is the cause of contemporary far right wing. But for Germans during WWII, the even the West was at max temporary ally meant to be conquered later. The "in certain circles, even today" is more of "especially today when the non-Germans adapted most of ideology to what their consider their race". Same with race. German racism did not put white race on the top, that is contemporary cause. Nazi put German race on the top. Hitler himself was talking and writing about Lebensraum publicly. Also, nazi used Communist and Jew interchangeable, so you gotta be careful when parsing what they mean. And the Germany had Communist party that did tried smaller revolution soon after WWI, so you also have to distinguish between when they talk about internal and external threats. Not sure what the poem you linked is supposed to have to do with this argument.
- 082349872349872 6y agoSometime I should compare the transcript[1] with Goebbels' recorded speech[2]. > "Die europäischen Mächte stehen hier vor ihrer entscheidenden Lebensfrage. Das Abendland ist in Gefahr. Ob ihre Regierungen und ihre Intelligenzschichten das einsehen wollen oder nicht, ist dabei gänzlich unerheblich." > "Eine zweitausendjährige Aufbauarbeit der abendländischen Menschheit ist in Gefahr." > "Die neutralen europäischen Staaten besitzen weder das Potential noch die militärischen Machtmittel noch die geistige Einstellung ihrer Völker, um dem Bolschewismus auch nur den geringsten Widerstand entgegenzusetzen." > "Die Welt hat also nicht die Wahl zwischen einem in seine alte Zersplitterung zurückfallenden und einem unter der Achsenführung sich neu ordnenden Europa, sondern nur die zwischen einem unter dem militärischen Schutz der Achse stehenden und einem bolschewistischen Europa." The poem was supposed to indicate that, just as Nazis viewed their struggle as benevolently protecting all the "superior races" (with theirs, coincidentally, on top, no matter what the protectees thought of the matter), Yevtushenko sees no reason to stand with antisemites, no matter that they may approve of his own ancestry. If pigs tell dogs the sheep are inferior to dogs, should the dogs keep the sheep in line, or should they reflect on how pigs probably view dogs? ("alternately arrogant and servile" is another tell for totalitarians. Free people neither boss around nor suck up.) [1] https://www.1000dokumente.de/index.html?c=dokument_de&dokument=0200_goe&object=translation&st=&l=de https://www.1000dokumente.de/index.html?c=dokument_de&dokume... [2] https://archive.org/details/JosephGoebbels-Sportpalastrede https://archive.org/details/JosephGoebbels-Sportpalastrede