4 ms·
I think the more correct answer to "Why Are Currently No Ads on Techdirt?" is "Because we put all of our eggs in one basket." Don't build a single point of fai
by reaperducer 6y ago
I think the more correct answer to "Why Are Currently No Ads on Techdirt?" is "Because we put all of our eggs in one basket."
Don't build a single point of failure into your revenue stream.
There are plenty of alternatives to Google that they should have been using in a smaller way that they could then move into prime position. That way, Techdirt's revenue might have been diminished, but not eliminated.
- mdoms 6y agoLiterally the last paragraph of the article is a call for help in finding these "plenty of alternatives" so instead of being snide maybe you can help out by listing some?
- phoboslab 6y agoI'm curious, what are the "plenty of alternatives" exactly? We have tried a lot of different advertising networks and sadly we have found none that's even in the same ballpark as AdSense (revenue wise). Advertising on the web is a shit show.
- celestialcheese 6y agoTripleLift, Sharethrough, AppNexus (now Xander), Rubicon Project, OpenX, GumGum, Index, Amazon A9. There are dozens of video demand partners as well. All of those have performed as well or better, from my experience. Where google has all of them beat is payment terms - net 21 is hard to beat.
- nkozyra 6y agoThere are plenty of alternatives to Adsense but none of them are comparable. They all take a huge dive in RPM, are iffy with UX and security and tend to not last long. My personal account was locked out of Adsense in the same way years back. A violation every 5 months or so, which I always "corrected." Then one day it's just off. I respond and eventually Adsense is restored. Then a few weeks later, closed and banned. And it's been that way since. No recourse. Just ... shut out. This was a site with 100% user-generated content. If Google can't handle something like that, well ...
- reaperducer 6y agoThere are plenty of alternatives to Adsense but none of them are comparable. Which is why I stated that they should be run secondary to AdSense. At least they'd be ready to go when Google decided to shut Techdirt down. Something is better than nothing.
- nkozyra 6y agoHave you done this? I've run remnant alternatives and quite honestly the RPMs almost make it pointless. I'm talking $0.01 - $0.05 CPM when Adsense was averaging ~ $3
- grumple 6y agoYou're saying you only made 5 cents after generating a thousand clicks on an ad?
- chrisparsons 6y agoIn this situation, CPM is likely based on impressions, not clicks.
- nkozyra 6y agoMost of the also-run ad networks do that, yes.
- vezycash 6y ago> There are plenty of alternatives to Adsense but none of them are comparable. There are two companies that could have helped minimize Adsense's monopoly but decided not to: Microsoft and Facebook.
- celestialcheese 6y agoFacebook had a strong display ad product for a while, Audience Network, but they shut that down Q1 this year for web traffic. Only app ads now.
- danShumway 6y agoI want to medium-to-heavy push back on this. Techdirt didn't build a single point of failure into their revenue stream, otherwise the title of this article would be, "Why is Techdirt closing down?". Their support page[0] lists 8 different revenue sources other than Google Ads. And this is precisely the type of diversity that you want. Signing up for 5 different ad networks isn't really good diversity, because: A) your different revenue streams are cannibalizing each other (there's a limit to how many different ad networks you can shove on the same page), so you can't grow your revenue as you diversify, but more importantly, B) many of the factors that affect one ad network (ad blocking, political pressures and privacy laws, fundamental inability to moderate well) will affect all of them. It's not good to have 5 different revenue streams that can all simultaneously be destroyed by the same event. In that scenario you've increased complexity, but you haven't gotten a significant gain in reliability. On the other hand, pulling in money from advertising, Patreon, merchandise, product commissions, and even Kickstarter campaigns means that no single event will ruin your site. I think it's important for people looking to diversify income streams to think about what each new income stream offers, rather than just duplicating an existing stream X times. I don't see any advantage in having 5 different frameworks for serving ads on a single site. I see a lot of advantages from setting up a Patreon on the side and selling podcast ads outside of your site. [0]: https://www.techdirt.com/pages/support.php https://www.techdirt.com/pages/support.php
- henryfjordan 6y agoYou don't add a second ad network to widen your revenue stream just like you don't have a backup ISP to double your bandwidth. You do it so that when you have a (temporary) outage with one you can quickly switch to the other and not lose operations. There are some classes of outages that might affect both ad-streams, but there are other classes (like account status issues) that are completely independent.
- danShumway 6y agoBut that depends a lot on whether or not the outage is actually temporary. From the sound of this article, it doesn't sound like it is. Sure, Techdirt is hedging its bets and saying it might turn Google Ads back on eventually. But the account issues they're talking about aren't going to go away; there's nobody you can yell at with Google to make their moderation suddenly better. I still want to push the idea that if you're diversifying your income, you should actually diversify it, not just have multiple accounts in the same field. There are independent issues that might effect one ad network and not another, sure. Those independent issues also won't affect podcast ads or product sponsorships. In other words, redundancy != diversity. Not to say redundancy is useless, of course. But it really doesn't sound like redundancy is Techdirt's problem here, it sounds like they're disillusioned with page ads in general.