4 ms·
They could even get by without the Internet if such business were all conducted on the phone. So what?
by emodendroket 6y ago
They could even get by without the Internet if such business were all conducted on the phone. So what?
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoMy point is that the kinds of CRUD and spreadsheet manipulation tasks that most people who don't work at a screen all day need to do on a screen can be done over a trivially tiny pipe if that pipe is used with at least a token amount of efficiency.
- emodendroket 6y agoBut they're not, for many reasons.
- yodelshady 6y agoI'll preface this with noting it's a little odd to act as though adding 80 MB of unnecessary JS is a popular idea on HN. They couldn't if they needed to work asynchronously. Or if they couldn't speak or hear well over the phone, the likelihood of which approaches 1 if you have so much as a different accent. Or if you don't want the other person to hear your accent. It's a bit cliche maybe, but I know people who've benefited from all of those features of IP-based communication, and they're reasons to be happy about the Internet. And since just about any telecommunications system that transmits voice can be bullied into transmitting IP packets, there's really little cost.
- emodendroket 6y agoI mean, we can all agree, I imagine, that many pages have too much JS. But then what do we cut? My idea of what's "useless" is probably different than the people cutting my checks. Saying pages don't need "unnecessary" JS is tautological but not really illuminating. I do think there is plenty of reason lots of people would benefit in their work from single-page applications, not to mention video and audio that would dwarf the JS anyways.