5 ms·
For most of those functions a smart phone or a local library would suffice. I read "can't do our jobs" as being "literally cannot complete work or perform on-pa
by zdragnar 6y ago
For most of those functions a smart phone or a local library would suffice. I read "can't do our jobs" as being "literally cannot complete work or perform on-paid-time duties".
- pwinnski 6y agoA smart phone is still an internet connection at home. It's possible that some of the 70% are not considering their local library, though.
- inetknght 6y ago> A smart phone is still an internet connection at home. I don't use my personal phone for work. Anyone who does use their personal phone for work is being abused by their employer.
- Splognosticus 6y agoThis is an overly broad statement. Everywhere I've worked where I'm expected to be reachable by phone offered a stipend to pay for the service. And all of them were respectful of my personal time. An abusive employer is going to make unreasonable demands of you, regardless of whether you use your personal phone for work.
- inetknght 6y ago> Everywhere I've worked where I'm expected to be reachable by phone offered a stipend to pay for the service. Well your experience is more the exception than the rule today given my friends, family, and own anecdata. > An abusive employer is going to make unreasonable demands of you, regardless of whether you use your personal phone for work. Let me know when there's enough employers that most people without negotiating leverage can actually be employed by one that's not abusive.
- notriddle 6y agoThe argument you've parroted is against using your personal phone number for work. That's abusive, because it allows the employer to send you work when you're off the clock. Using your smartphone to log into your payroll site, or as the internet bridge to the company VPN, is not any different from using a broadband line and a laptop to do the same thing. Those systems shouldn't be able to interrupt you when you're not working, but they might still be accessed through a smartphone in lieu of a desktop or laptop.
- inetknght 6y ago> you've parroted Parroting implies blind repeating. I honestly believe my statement though. It's not parroting. > That's abusive, because it allows the employer to send you work when you're off the clock. No, it's abusive when doing work functions requires the use of my personal phone. Accessing an employer's VPN should not be done using devices or services that are wholly owned and paid for by me. Allowing my employer to notify me, while I'm off the clock, of any work that's available or scheduling changes or emergencies definitely falls under personal devices can be used. But when the employer requires you to use your personal devices and personal internet service to actually do any function of that work then that's where you and I clearly disagree. > Using your smartphone to log into your payroll site Payroll sites necessarily must be accessible from outside of the work VPN: payroll sites' reporting ability must be accessible after my employment has been terminated. > or as the internet bridge to the company VPN Using someone's personal internet service or phone service is unethical. Employers should pay for the internet bridge to the company VPN and all devices and services necessary to connect to it. > is not any different from using a broadband line and a laptop to do the same thing Nope, it isn't. Who owns it though? > Those systems shouldn't be able to interrupt you when you're not working Indeed. > but they might still be accessed through a smartphone in lieu of a desktop or laptop. Sure, but who owns it?
- mulmen 6y agoI use my personal phone number as my pager when I am oncall. That doesn't feel abusive.
- boneitis 6y agoThe entire public library network is closed out where I'm at (save for curbside pickups). Another kneejerk thought also suggests that whatever few(?) that are open might take on increased traffic, at odds with distancing guidelines/mandates.
- wsinks 6y agoHow does a library help in 2020? Going anywhere but your home is unreliable during shelter in place orders. So if you don't have an internet connection at home, you don't have an internet connection. Also, resiliency is a good thing. It is not redundancy if the two services have different business continuity profiles.
- vidanay 6y agoThat's an incredibly limited view of the subject. I could theoretically write code with a laptop from the back of a camel in the Sahara desert. That doesn't mean it qualifies as "able to do my job".
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nitwit005 6y agoI suspect the poll answers would be different if they presented more nuanced options than the three choices in the pie chart.
- mattnewton 6y agoYes, and for many people that smartphone is their home internet connection.
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoSure, but... not everywhere has a local library. Parts of Indiana do not, and if you aren't in the library's tax district, you might have to pay to use the library to get a library card, which allows you to use the computers/internet. To make matters worse, in rural areas libraries might be in the next town over and have short hours. In one city, their summer hours were basically 10-3: During the summer, they closed at 6. They had very limited hours on saturday and were always closed on Sunday. You could, quite literally, work most of the time they were open. And for more fun, they only had limited space for computers. If there was a wait, you only had 30 minutes of time.
- reaperducer 6y agoYou should see the library that serves the Las Vegas Strip. I went there to use the wifi last year. It's in a terrible neighborhood. It's smaller than my bedroom. There are four computers, and according to the librarian on duty, they're occupied from open to closing every day, so if you want to use one you have to line up before it opens. People who say, "Just use the library" are people who have never tried to just use a library.
- Nextgrid 6y agoEntering any kind of credentials or confidential information into a public computer is (or should be) a big no-no.