8 ms·
I thought it advanced the line of thought that freedom is nuanced and not binary.
by 2OEH8eoCRo0 6y ago
I thought it advanced the line of thought that freedom is nuanced and not binary.
- crocko 6y agoIt really isn't though. Unfortunately people have been conned into thinking it isn't. 1. You respect property rights 2. You are allowed to speak your mind 3. You have a right to defend yourself Everything else is nonsense.
- arp242 6y agoWhy shouldn't I have the freedom to go where I please? What gives, say, the owner a piece of land the right to deny my freedom to walk there? I'm not against property rights, but nowhere is it treated like an absolute. Even cultures with strong property rights recognizes such as the United States recognizes this trade-off (which is explicitly done so in the US constitution).
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoSo do copyright laws enhance freedom or detract from it?
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoIf you assume the GP's position then that just boils down to whether or not intellectual property is property.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoThat was my point, I should have been more explicit. Their definition of freedom was a simple one, of three parts: > 1. You respect property rights 2. You are allowed to speak your mind 3. You have a right to defend yourself This clearly doesn't give a full and objective account of what the word means, as I'm able to give an example which pits one of the parts against another, leaving us to make a judgement call.
- claudiawerner 6y ago>1. You respect property rights 2. You are allowed to speak your mind 3. You have a right to defend yourself What is the philosophical justification for these three principles, and these three principles alone?