2 ms·
This is a weird headline. "Regulated as a public utility" means, economically, that prices/profits are set by law -- that there's only one electricity provider
by crazygringo 6y ago
This is a weird headline.
"Regulated as a public utility" means, economically, that prices/profits are set by law -- that there's only one electricity provider but they can't jack up prices because there's no competition.
That makes no sense when applied to Google.
The type of remedy appropriate for what the author describes (Google favoring their own products in search) is relatively simple. That Google, Amazon, and others -- anybody who runs any kind of search mechanism, store, etc. -- are not allowed to give their own products preferential priority.
Public utilities are a super-weird and unhelpful analogy.
- justinclift 6y ago> "Regulated as a public utility" means, economically, that prices/profits are set by law ... That's one part of it. Another part - unfortunately not even considered by the article - is customer support. Utilities must provide customer support. For example, if a customer loses their account password. Google famously has no recourse for people locked out of an account. If Google were to be regulated as a public utility, that would need to change.
- crazygringo 6y agoBut the article is about Google as search, only, which needs no customer support, since it requires no account. Whether Google (or other companies) provide support for their free consumer accounts is a totally orthogonal issue -- and I haven't heard anyone claiming that Gmail or Docs or Drive is being anticompetitive and needs to be regulated.
- justinclift 6y agoYou're right the bulk of the article is focused on Search. However, it also has this: There are very specific kinds of businesses and business models that should be overseen. The first and most important thing is a body [that] oversees the collection of user data and privacy and identification. The "user data and privacy and identification" piece is also important. It's just not something this article really gets into.