Yes, if we want the Second Amendment to mean anything. Now I'm certainly in favor of the argument that we should be honest with ourselves and repeal the Second

Yes, if we want the Second Amendment to mean anything. Now I'm certainly in favor of the argument that we should be honest with ourselves and repeal the Second Amendment instead of pretending that we care about it but only in useless ways. But so long as we believe that both bearing arms and traveling are human rights and not privileges, neither should be gated by IDs and background checks, and you should only lose that right in the form of a punishment under due process of law.