5 ms·
It is generally not reasonable for traveling domestically. Imagine having to show ID to take the bus/metro. Sounds absurd? Well, think of the children.
by mixmastamyk 6y ago
It is generally not reasonable for traveling domestically. Imagine having to show ID to take the bus/metro. Sounds absurd? Well, think of the children.
- refurb 6y agoThe rationale is that the potential damage is higher with a flight. Bombing a bus/metro might a dozen or so people. Bombing a plane can easily kill hundreds.
- gruez 6y agoAnd how does requiring ID mitigate that danger?
- refurb 6y agoPeople who are security risks can't board.
- geofft 6y agoThat assumes you have a perfect list of who's a security risk and who's not, and the TSA is not Santa. The 9/11 hijackers boarded with their real names, and in practice there are plenty of easy ways around this, like radicalizing someone.
- refurb 6y agoWhy does it have to be perfect? It could still be effective if it stops 50% of security risks.
- geofft 6y agoBecause in a free society, a system that stops crimes half of the time and arbitrarily denies people their rights half the time is considered unjust. Would it be okay for police to stop suspicious-looking people on the streets and ask them for ID and run background checks if it caught criminals 50% of the time?
- mixmastamyk 6y agoThere’s no proof it stops even 2%. Anyone with a week’s preparation could defeat it. Yet the innocent will be punished every day. Remember the German pilot who crashed on purpose? Good thing they had ids on everyone.
- refurb 6y agoWell, we know screening luggage is useless too, as the TSA doesn’t catch 10% during tests. So we should just let anyone into a plane with no screening at all?
- compiler-guy 6y agoAs long as they have no weapons, we should let anyone on a plane that has a ticket.
- refurb 6y agoHow do you supposed we check for weapons? Seems like everything thinks current checks are "security theatre" and do absolutely nothing.
- compiler-guy 6y agoShowing your id does absolutely nothing to prevent weapons from getting on the plane. If you are so dangerous that your mere identity is enough to prevent you from getting on a plane, then you need to be arrested. Identity is extremely easy to fake. If you are planning in such a way that you have a realistic chance of hijacking a plane, getting a fake ID good enough to fool the two-second check at the TSA checkpoint is the least of your problems. There is some argument that a properly built luggage and human screening system could actually prevent weapons from making it on the plane. But ID doesn't really come into it. But even if we can't develop a system that prevents weapons from getting on planes, it doesn't follow the id checks would be a suitable alternative.
- 6y ago
- Nasrudith 6y agoThat is complete bullshit. They not only don't need to board but if they pulled a gun the TSAs would be an unwitting accomplice in letting them reinact "No Russian" with their bullshit security theater gathering hundreds into a massive shooting gallery with no cover. Really that is why there was such outrage over the level - it illustrated vividly how the TSA failed on the most basic logical level.
- thih9 6y ago> "No Russian" Context: "a controversial level in the 2009 video game Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2. In the level, the player can participate in a mass shooting at a Russian airport.". Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_Russian https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_Russian
- dudul 6y agoThis actually came up after the 2015 attacks in France. Most crowded locations became heavily protected, bags were all checked, etc. The result: a massive crowd in front of theaters, concert and sport venues, etc. Israeli consultants basically summed it up by saying that these procedures were creating massively vulnerable areas with potentially 100+ victims if a guy detonated a bomb in front of the venue. I remember seeing a documentary showing how in Israeli airport one of the main goals was to always avoid long lines and big groups of people.
- dudul 6y agoHow many terrorists have been caught before boarding a plane because they didn't have an ID?
- refurb 6y agoI have no idea. But Israel, who is clearly a major target for airline bombings hasn't had one in what? 50 years?
- mixmastamyk 6y agoThat’s due to their extensive interviews. The id is not relied on as a magic safety card.
- refurb 6y agoYou’re not getting on an Israeli flight without ID. But yes, they interview heavily.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoI don't believe there are israeli domestic flights, but if there are they are insignificant.
- ehasbrouck 6y agoFWIW, during non-pandemic times there are scheduled airline flights from Tel Aviv (TLV) and Haifa (HFA) to Eilat (ETM).
- mixmastamyk 6y agoMetro bombs have done incredible damage. And as mentioned elsewhere, it is trivial to manufacture id and so is not a solution. But, conveniently it sure does fill govt databases.
- techdragon 6y agoA large Crowded bus easily hold 72 people all of whom would likely die in a bomb attack on the bus. And that’s not counting anyone near by on the street.
- refurb 6y agoRight, dozens, versus potentially 500+.