6 ms·
There is 100% nothing stopping the Federal government from offering a full-faith-and-credit-backed "America electronic transaction system" for electronic transa
by shadowgovt 6y ago
There is 100% nothing stopping the Federal government from offering a full-faith-and-credit-backed "America electronic transaction system" for electronic transactions, with those fees handled by taxes.
But much as there's nothing stopping the Federal government from greatly simplifying the burden and toil of tax season by issuing 90% of Americans a pre-filled-out "This is what you owe; sign this and return it or dispute it with your own filing," we won't do that because fully half of Congress is from a party that has, as a plank, that private institutions serve the public interest better than public institutions.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoFWIW the Canadian tax system is heading in this direction. With electronic filing programs most things get pre-filled now with data from Canada Revenue Agency based on the information they've received from your employer, your bank, your trading institutions, etc. Then it's more a matter of going through and verifying information and adding in any missing information (for example sale info from my stock units held in my employer's US brokerage) and looking any deductions that might apply (and the set of those is shrinking, which imho is a good thing)
- shadowgovt 6y agoIt is a good thing. Private tax accountants are a huge political lobby in the US, so it's a non-starter here. The US barely got off the ground a free option for public e-filing, and we managed to botch it up by handing it to a private company to implement, which promptly turned around and made it absolutely as impossible to access as they were allowed to by law.
- JAlexoid 6y agoUS - the cronyism dream.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoOne way or another, those free markets always turn out to be really expensive for customers and users.
- mikepurvis 6y agoCanadian here— there's definitely been a movement in recent years away from deductions in favour of direct payments throughout the year. Thinking especially of the child benefit and the carbon tax rebate, and the elimination of boutique credits like one that used to apply to the purchase of public transit passes (https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency/programs/about-canada-revenue-agency-cra/federal-government-budgets/budget-2017-building-a-strong-middle-class/public-transit-tax-credit.html https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency/programs/about-canad...). I get that politicians like the psychology of people receiving a cheque or direct deposit vs a tax deduction ("it was my money all along"), but I think it is genuinely a positive step in terms of helping people at the low end of the economy who don't have the means to save receipts or jump through whatever other hoops are necessary to nickel and dime the government at tax time.
- JAlexoid 6y agoI used to run a company in Lithuania and now am a simple employee in US. It took me about 10 minutes for monthly tax filings and 30 minutes for the annual tax filing for my company and 4 employees. I did not have an accountant - I didn't need one. It is a nightmare filing taxes in US, even paying $300 to Intuit. It takes about a week of my time... for something that is supposed to be automated. I also never manage to get the tax calculated correctly in advance, because no consumer facing tax company will bother with you before you get your annual statement(W2). I have a very variable income - RSU's and other optional income... so I get hit by underpayment fee from IRS.... and don't get me started on the fact that every state has their own tax authority...
- machello13 6y agoIt's extremely naive to think that only Republicans are responsible for that.
- shadowgovt 6y agoThey are not, alone, responsible for it, but it is still a fundamental difference in the parties; some Democrats are pro-big-business, but only one party has public-private partnership as a party plank.
- machello13 6y agoDemocrats may profess to be anti-big-business, but in practice they clearly aren't.
- kebman 6y agoThe Democratic Party is a long-standing "bankers party" and "corporatists party" (a party for big companies and organizations). In that sense, they're just as "bad" as the Republican Party, and due to how the whole democratic system is set up in the USA, Americans are in reality bereft of alternatives. Picking anyone else than those two, is effectively a blank vote. This system can at least in part explain why so many Americans choose to stay at home during the elections, because to them, for whatever reason, it doesn't really make much of a difference who is in power.
- dhosek 6y agoThis is why it's important to vote in primaries and to cultivate leaders at the local level. The Republicans became a lock-step far right party by building up infrastructure and candidates at the lowest levels and building from there. Too many progressives don't seem to pay attention to any elections below the presidential election (and then whine that things are rigged when their candidate gets less votes than someone they don't like).
- TheOtherHobbes 6y ago
- chrisco255 6y agoRight, the same government that couldn't get a healthcare website going is supposed to also power every single transaction from internal infrastructure. There are hidden costs that are much higher than 3% to giving the government full control over every transaction in society. It's a single point of failure with no redundancy or decentralization, a large attack vector, and a human rights nightmare. As a general rule, private institutions all too often do outperform public institutions. I'm pretty sure Space X has bipartisan support, for example.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- elicash 6y agoI mean, government does GPS. Sends folks to space. You mention SpaceX, but let's not pretend NASA doesn't exist. Yeah, there was once that website that had a bad launch, but there's nothing inherent in government that wouldn't allow this to work well. I do think ideally this could be done by NY or CA first. We should test out ideas in the states, where possible.
- shadowgovt 6y agoSpaceX successfully built a capsule to get people into space. They built it to the specifications that NASA enforced upon them, which were paid for in blood. And you don't have to look far in the SpaceX organization to see what risks the company is willing to take if an external authority isn't imposing regulation on them.
- _Microft 6y agoI think this mixes up low odds of success with risk, the latter rather being an expectation value than a probability (i.e. probability of success or failure times the value of the things at stake). Risk can be low even when the odds of success are not good just by nothing being really at stake. Think about their rocket landing program: the probability of landing a rocket on a boat in the first attempt might have been low but the risk was almost negligible because the launches that SpaceX practiced landing on had been paid for by a customer already. Now, if SpaceX had bet the company on reusability by paying for all these rockets out of their own pocket instead and hoping they manage to get it right before cash runs out, then this could have been called risky.
- dfxm12 6y agoBeyond that plank, it's important to note that these same politicians are often bought out by lobby money from the private institutions who stand to benefit. They stand aside and let people from private industry, like TurboTax or H&R Block, write the laws that make things harder on their constituents, and then turn to them and and go, "See, government is inefficient!" It's a complete racket! https://www.propublica.org/article/filing-taxes-could-be-free-simple-hr-block-intuit-lobbying-against-it https://www.propublica.org/article/filing-taxes-could-be-fre... https://www.propublica.org/article/inside-turbotax-20-year-fight-to-stop-americans-from-filing-their-taxes-for-free https://www.propublica.org/article/inside-turbotax-20-year-f...
- toomuchtodo 6y ago> There is 100% nothing stopping the Federal government from offering a full-faith-and-credit-backed "America electronic transaction system" for electronic transactions, with those fees handled by taxes. That is the plan, albeit the minimal fees involved paid for through users of the Fed’s system. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24103753 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24103753
- MadSudaca 6y agoI actually like this aspect of the USA. Most parts of the world, specially more socialistic-leaning countries, would have politicians eager to expand their powers and size of the state so that they have control over a bigger cut of the pie. Of course, this is supposedly for the good of the people. It seems to me that more people is socialistic-minded in the USA these days, to me that looks like a indicator of the decline of the country.
- cool_dude85 6y agoIf you want, you can mail Visa a check for 3% of your spending at the end of each month. A small price to pay for your freedom.
- JAlexoid 6y agoHm... No single conservative or Austrian economic school think tank ranks US as #1 in freedom. NONE! US is typically about #14 to #17... with these "socialist-leaning" countries being higher on the list. (CATO Institute has Estonia in lockstep with US in overall freedom) US is surprisingly intrusive, considering it's supposed to be "leader of the free world".
- MadSudaca 6y agoThere are many countries. Go live in a +70 in economic freedom and you’ll gain a lot of perspective on the freedoms the USA has.
- cycomanic 6y agoThe thing that always bothered me about this argument is that in reality the US has many more regulations that apply to regular people than most of what you call "socialistic-leaning" countries (one example look at the regulations for what you can or can't do with your house/yard in many suburbs )
- MadSudaca 6y agoSingapour usually ranks top 5 in these lists and it’s forbidden to buy chewing gum there. What baseline are you comparing against?
- Press2forEN 6y agoPeople should have feel the burden that taxation places on them. Payroll withholding already artificially dampens the strain that taxation imposes on everyone that earns a paycheck. Issuing a pre-filled out form is another step backwards. Paying taxes should be burdensome and uncomfortable.
- Nasrudith 6y agoThat is an ideology and a rather twisted one. We were over this when people were opposing anaglesia and anaesthesia. Wanting people to suffer needlessly is a bad thing.
- Press2forEN 6y agoThen stop over taxing us.
- 8note 6y agoI don't think that does what you want it to. Make taxes burdensome, and you create a market for tax filers who make them easy for you. All youve done is make taxes more expensive then, without getting better government services.
- kwhitefoot 6y ago> greatly simplifying the burden and toil of tax season by issuing 90% of Americans a pre-filled-out "This is what you owe; sign this and return it or dispute it with your own filing, All of Scandinavia does this. Has been doing it for ages. Most people need do nothing at all. And it works really well even if you do have to make some amendments (income in a foreign country for instance that the tax authorities can't see directly).
- cycomanic 6y agoIt's also one of the reason why the tax office is one of the most popular government agencies in Sweden. It just works.
- jariel 6y ago"There is 100% nothing stopping the Federal government from offering a full-faith-and-credit-backed "America electronic transaction system" for electronic transactions, with those fees handled by taxes." And there's technically nothing stopping the US from sending humans to mars either. There are many reasons that it's not done, including the most important one, which is that it's not necessary. Simply producing or supporting a standard, and then maybe having some regulations around it would be 100x easier.