5 ms·
Of course time is money, the benefit for some people though is that their time is then credited at a fairer rate of exchange than the normal employment way of c
by bryanrasmussen 6y ago
Of course time is money, the benefit for some people though is that their time is then credited at a fairer rate of exchange than the normal employment way of crediting time, at the same time that it allows them to monetize things that would otherwise be difficult to monetize.
However for someone like me whose time is credited more than most by the employment system it seems like it would be a losing proposition to do things for time credits instead of money.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoIn a functional time credit system, you should be able to play a critical role -- you should be able to consume products & services in the system in exchange for dollars in order to be allow those in the system to pay for essentials that they cannot buy with time credits.
- WilTimSon 6y agoYes, but that whole system is essentially built on the trust that everyone gets their fair share for giving time. Saying "for someone like me" runs completely counter to their ideas. Personally, it wouldn't be beneficial to me either but the catch is that this system essentially dictates you just have to give up some benefit to you in order to gain a benefit for the community. However, I really don't know how viable this scheme would be on a bigger level. Eventually, this hopeful and admirable attempt faces the problems outlined in the article: landlords don't want time credits, banks don't want them, the government doesn't want them. So it's a risk of giving up your privilege of earning well that might leave you with nothing eventually.
- antasvara 6y agoI don't think it has to be viable on a bigger level. If all the system does is keep productive, engaged community members a reason to stick in the town due to the currency they've built up, I see that as a win for the currency.
- Kinrany 6y agoStartup idea: a messenger that allows small communities to create their own currencies and provides a way to convert between them. Basically Internet, but for money. ...It'll turn into an even bigger scam than cryptocurrencies, but the idea seems interesting...
- maxwell 6y agoKey would be SEC approval.
- bsanr2 6y agoI think the whole point is that you can't convert easily.
- Kinrany 6y agoYou can't just trade them, but you could find a loop where every two consecutive traders have at least one community in common. Perhaps I don't really understand the value of not being able to convert them.
- bsanr2 6y agoThe point is to incentivize local spending, not just spending on local goods. Money that circulates within a community stimulates more local activity. Local producers are more likely to undercharge for the value of their goods and services for the sake of community vitality than large, remote businesses that want to squeeze every bit of value out of a transaction. It's essentially a way to get more work done. It doesn't work if the network is so large that people lose that incentive.
- Kinrany 6y agoRight, so this is a way to make local economy more efficient that works because people care more about local externalities. The question is, is there a way to scale this to the whole world by building a global network composed of local networks?
- bsanr2 6y agoThat limitation is supposed to be an asset, it seems. No, you can't use the currency outside the local network. That incentivizes you to use your dollars only for things outside the network, and to go inside the network whenever possible (to make the best use of your overall holdings). You might give up convenience (by going to a local store to by produce rather than ordering from Amazon or a national chain), but then you see the benefits in community vitality. In the end, this only works if you accept that investing in your local community is more important than saving a few minutes or dollars sending your work-hours-in-the-form-of-dollars to some far-flung exec's pocket. Some people are so well remunerated by the traditional system that I suppose they don't really have to care about all that.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoI didn't see any examples of how people can get anything in return for sharing their time. Unless you can convert your time credits for unpleasant work you don't want to do, it is just a gold star for charity work, and I'm not sure that quantifying and gamifying charity is a productive change.
- antasvara 6y agoI think the best way to think about this is to consider time credits a supplemental currency that incentivizes actions that benefit the community. Yes, your time could be worth more when working with traditional currency, but by that logic why would anybody volunteer? Finding a way to benefit volunteers and people that are involved in the community, while also supporting local businesses, seems like a great way to keep money moving without relying on large businesses to generate income.
- bryanrasmussen 6y ago> Yes, your time could be worth more when working with traditional currency, but by that logic why would anybody volunteer? Yeah but lots of people's times are theoretically worth more with this than with traditional currency was what I was getting at - anybody whose job is undervalued by companies but who can turn their skills to the benefit of others can earn more valuable time credits than they could earn money. For example a janitor might have the handyman skills to build some IKEA furniture for you and earn more in the way of time credits than they would in money from their normal employment, without having to go through all the work they would have to become a handyman as a job or small business.
- antasvara 6y agoI totally agree with you on that; I was more responding to the last piece of your comment which indicated that some people's time would be discredited under the system. I liked your idea about the low barrier to entry for starting a business; working with an unregulated currency would make things much easier for someone from a legal perspective (at least I'd assume it would).
- vorpalhex 6y agoWhen it comes to volunteer work, you actually don't want to offer cash rewards because it decreases the motivation of people to volunteer - and yes, I realize what I just said sounds exactly backwards from what we'd assume the case to be. When you start offering a reward, the human brain starts playing a comparative game. Instead of "I'm helping someone because I think it's the right thing to do" your brain starts doing the "I'm helping someone because I want a $25 gift card" etc. Wikipedia lists this as the Overjustificatioon effect[^1] To be fair to the original article, I think the intent wasn't to reward volunteers but to instead create a local closed market that might help an economically depressed area. [^1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overjustification_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overjustification_effect
- floatrock 6y agoYour hourly billable rate is irrelevant here because these community tokens aren't trying to compete with your salary. They're pricing something else, something orthogonal to your professional compensation. So there's a useful idea out there called the 8 Forms of Capital: https://www.google.com/search?q=8+forms+of+capital https://www.google.com/search?q=8+forms+of+capital The idea is roughly lets use the language and methodology of "capital" to look at all the non-"net-worth"-ey things that makes us human. So your "net worth" is the sum of your 1) Financial Capital (bank account) and 2) Material Capital (house and "stuff"). But that's only 2/8. When you hear about people who live in luxury highrises and work 12 hours a day at McKinsBcgBain but are too drained when they come home to do anything other than order takeout and pass out watching netflix only to pop a xanax and do it all again the next morning, that's being wealthy in Financial and Material Capital but poor in everything else. The idea of these community tokens isn't to price your time as Financial capital, but rather price it into something like 3) Social Capital (the relationships you have with others) or, maybe, 4) Cultural Capital (all the ideas and bonds that constitute a community identity). Do others interact with you purely transactionally, or do they rely on you as you rely on them? Do you feel like you're part of a neighborhood, or just renting space one 12-month lease at a time? So basically, your time can be priced in salary-dollars or it can be priced in community-bonds. Your time may command a high salary-dollar price, but what kind of social- and community-dollar price do you command?