3 ms·
> NAS, SAN, iSCSI, etc. existed and were commonly used way before AWS or EBS And were notorious sources of performance and reliability issues, especially iSCSI
by acdha 6y ago
> NAS, SAN, iSCSI, etc. existed and were commonly used way before AWS or EBS
And were notorious sources of performance and reliability issues, especially iSCSI. Anyone with operational experience with those was not unreasonably questioning the risk of being in the same boat with less control, and EBS had some highly-visible failures which validated that concern.
It took a number of smooth years after the big 2011 outage to get people to be more confident in it.
- tatersolid 6y agoIn my 20+ years of stoarage and ops experience, iSCSI was way more reliable, tunable, and monitor-able than anything in the FiberChannel world. “Just use TCP/IP because everything else does” is a strategy that works, and it’s the reason FC is (mostly) dead. Though nothing beat the braided differential parallel SCSI cables for cable porn supremacy. Shared-disk clusters looked like they were damn serious alien-military-grade stuff back then.
- acdha 6y agoMaybe you were lucky - I had the misfortune of supporting some iSCSI devices which were slower & less stable, and lots of places had to have the “just because it uses the same cable doesn’t mean you should share a port” talk with their network people – but I was mostly comparing it to direct-attached storage which has fewer parts to fail and, critically, doesn’t have the same correlated failures which you get with shared anything (and, of course, the trade-off or forcing you to do redundancy at a higher level). Most of the problems I remember in the last decade fell into that last category: over-commitment and reserved capacity, failures showing that redundancy wasn’t as good as the vendor promised, etc. which are quite reasonably concerns for EBS, too.
- tatersolid 6y agoI dealt mostly with LeftHand and EqualLogic gear when iSCSI was getting rolling. Both were far more reliable than the various FC gear I dealt with around the same time. You could pull any node and things kept chugging. Rolling software updates were non-events. Simplicity has its virtues I suppose. Running 4 or 8 gigabit cables to each node on dedicated switch ports likely also helped.