4 ms·
Thanks for posting this - I wasn't previously aware of the delineation between a shock wave and a pressure wave that the author explained clearly. I'm curious,
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
Thanks for posting this - I wasn't previously aware of the delineation between a shock wave and a pressure wave that the author explained clearly.
I'm curious, is there something specific about "high explosives" vs "low explosives", beyond just the magnitude of energy released, that explains why some generate shock waves and others pressure waves?
- a2tech 6y agoI've been led to believe that 'high' explosives are explosives that explode/combust faster than the speed of sound. Others (like black powder) burn slower.
- hn2fast 6y agoMore than just burn, 'high' explosives detonate [0], where the pressure wave itself provides the activation energy required to sustain the reaction. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Detonation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Detonation
- erdos4d 6y agoIn a nutshell, high explosives detonate, low explosives combust. The two processes are distinctly different in how they operate at the molecular level. Basically, detonation is when a shock wave goes through the material, causing it to "blow up" on a molecular level as it passes (the molecules split as the shock passes through). Combustion happens much slower and is usually a chemical reaction involving some sort of fuel and oxidizer that is mixed and burned. I'm not an expert, but you can see the difference in a gasoline engine. As you crank up the compression ratio the air/fuel mix in the cylinder will eventually undergo a change from combusting to detonating, producing engine "knock" and rapidly destroying your engine if you let it continue. On a gas motor, around 13:1 is a good spot to see this happen. Someone will have more for you, but I think this is the basic concept seperating the two.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoAm I right in my understanding then that diesel engines work entirely on the principle of detonation, and that's why they're heavier as everything is designed to cope with what would make a petrol engine ping? Does that make any sense? Or is diesel injected in to the cylinder in a way that more or less produces a controlled combustion?
- refurb 6y agoDetonation in an engine means something different. Detonation is when the fuel starts burning from a source other than the spark plug and the two flame fronts collide.
- crubier 6y agoNo, Diesel engines are not based on detonation but also on a controlled combustion. The combustion is triggered differently that is all.
- erdos4d 6y agoDiesel engines have a very high compression ratio, like 20:1 or more, but diesel fuel has a very high octane rating in comparison with gasoline, so it still combusts, not detonates, at these high ratios. What makes a diesel different than a gas engine is that the heat generated from the compression of the air/fuel mix is what actually causes the mix to start burning in the cylinder. So, for this reason you don't see any ignition system on a diesel usually, it doesn't need it (though maybe glow plugs or a block heater in cold areas, but not an actual ignition system). But the mixture still combusts in a diesel. Detonation is incredibly destructive to any engine, even a big beefy diesel. It can destroy any engine very quickly.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoThanks all for clearing that up.
- esaym 6y ago>but diesel fuel has a very high octane rating in comparison with gasoline, "octane" is the ability of a fuel to "resist combustion" from compression. Diesel fuel is not rated in "octane" but the opposite: the ability for it to combust from compression. For some reason in the "old days", it was commonly thought by some that by adding some diesel to gasoline that it would help "lubricate" the motor (as diesel does have an oily feel). However mixing diesel with gasoline only lowers its octane rating.
- mirimir 6y agoAnd if you're "inside" an explosion that's too slow to generate a shock wave, you may not even be seriously injured.[0] At least, if the pressure spike is too low to rupture your body. And as long as objects don't get accelerated toward you. As a child, a friend and I were electrolyzing water, in an enclosed space. And so the hydrogen flashed. But the concentration was so low that the air just turned faint blue. There was no damage, to us or the building. 0) https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/114372936/how-did-anyone-survive-the-christchurch-gas-explosion https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/114372936/how-did-anyone-su...
- tacon 6y agoThe technical term for a subsonic combustion wave is deflagration.[0] A normal internal combustion engine deflagrates. If it starts pinging, that is detonation, and damages the pistons, etc. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deflagration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deflagration