5 ms·
This seems to pretty conclusively result in Uber drivers being employees, then. Specifically, in B. It's going to be hard for Uber to argue that driving cars is
by sudosysgen 6y ago
This seems to pretty conclusively result in Uber drivers being employees, then. Specifically, in B. It's going to be hard for Uber to argue that driving cars is outside of the usual course of Uber's business.
- tomerico 6y agoI actually don’t think that point B is the ones they failed off. They claim that they are in the business of facilitating a connection between drivers and riders, in the same way that Youtube connects creators to viewers without employing them. The main thing they failed on is that the court thinks that they exert too much control on the drivers. For example, they don’t allow users to choose their own drivers. They also don’t allow drivers to price their ride.
- sudosysgen 6y ago>They claim that they are in the business of facilitating a connection between drivers and riders, in the same way that Youtube connects creators to viewers without employing them. This doesn't stand. If YouTube hired every single YouTuber as a contractor it would be forced to reclassify them as employees. Because Uber doesn't facilitate connections between two third parties, it facilitates connections between clients and their contractors. If drivers on Uber were neither contractors nor clients and if contractual obligations were between drivers and riders then it would make sense.
- droidno9 6y ago> The main thing they failed on is that the court thinks that they exert too much control on the drivers. No, the court didn't address prong A at all because it found that Uber/Lyft could not possibly satisfy prong B of the ABC test.
- LatteLazy 6y agoUber owns no cars and has no existing employees who work as drivers though. Uber only really hires tech people, not cab drivers...
- TheGeminon 6y agoSo your argument is that since Uber was classifying them as contractors, they should always be able to? According to a quick search, they have 900,000 drivers and 27,000 employees. At most 3-ish% of the people that they pay to work for them are tech employees (and we can probably safely assume most of those 27,000 are not tech).
- LatteLazy 6y agoMy argument is actually the inverse: currently uber has no driver employees, the only way to change that under this law is to assume they do, then you can use that to argue any new driver is an employee. You need a first set of driver-employees to argue others are now employees. But there has never been a first set of driver-employees. Its actually a little confusing that that is required as it seems to allow Uber etc to skirt this definition (unless they have been taking on drivers as full employees without my knowledge?) I'd be interested to know how many creators YouTube "employs" or how many retail workers Ebay has and what their percentages are. This is where this whole thing confuses me: If Uber drivers are employees (and maybe they are?) then basically every major tech company has millions on employees they have been misclassifying. Paying them all minimum wage with benefits and taxes deducted etc will be a massive massive change for these companies.
- sudosysgen 6y ago> I'd be interested to know how many creators YouTube "employs" or how many retail workers Ebay has and what their percentages are. This is where this whole thing confuses me: If Uber drivers are employees (and maybe they are?) then basically every major tech company has millions on employees they have been misclassifying. Paying them all minimum wage with benefits and taxes deducted etc will be a massive massive change for these companies. YouTubers are not contractors of YouTube. eBay sellers are not contractors of eBay. Uber drivers are contractors of Uber. This is why Uber will be affected and not YouTube, nor eBay. Uber would also be free to have a system where drivers are not contractors nor employees of Uber (but it would not fit their business model).