21 ms·
This comment is just wrong on so many levels: "I'm afraid you're repeating Uber's favorite talking point, which is that everyone should respect the worker's de
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
This comment is just wrong on so many levels:
"I'm afraid you're repeating Uber's favorite talking point, which is that everyone should respect the worker's decision to be an employee or contractor."
I've never seen Uber argue that everyone should "respect the worker's decision to be an employee or contractor." I have seen them argue that drivers are contractors based on the flexibility in the job, but not that it should be "the worker's decision".
"Nobody disputes that Uber can have employees or contractors (or both), or that drivers should, in principle, be able to choose what status they hold."
Actually, pretty much all US employment law disputes that drivers should be able to choose what status they hold. Employee vs. contractor is not determined by what an employer says someone is, or what an employee says they are. Instead, it is determined by some key factors about the nature of the job, which (as you do point out) mainly centers around control of important aspects of the job.
But it is important to understand that you never really get to "choose" whether you're a contractor or an employee, it's determined solely as a function of the type or work you do and the nature of your relationship to the employer.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoWhat is the point of this comment? You've effectively spend a few paragraphs adding nothing of value to the conversation. You've effectively restated the grandparent's points, but tried to do so in an adversarial manner.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y ago> You've effectively spend a few paragraphs adding nothing of value to the conversation. You might want to check what you consider "adversarial" when it comes to a discussion forum. The issue is that the comment I responded to seems to be under the false notion that workers (or employers, for that matter) get to "choose" how they want to be classified, and that's what this debate is about. My point is that, when it comes to employment law, a worker or employer's preference about how they are classified does not factor in at all about how the law classifies the job.
- schemy 6y agoYes and? If I owned slaves and called them unpaid indefinite interns the law would rightly disagree. You can call the relationship whatever you like, but the law is there to keep the playing field level for everyone. That it's taken Uber so long to play by the same rules as everyone else is a travesty and should take a billion dollar law suit or two for damages to sort out.
- Gunax 6y agoUber is in a legal grey area. They are independent contractors in the sense that they can choose how much and when to work. They are employees in that they cannot negotiate rates. I don't think it's so clear cut.
- malandrew 6y agoGiven that rates are determined collectively by deciding whether or not it's worth your time to go online given the current level of surge. If enough drivers decide it's not worth it, the price will change. This is a pretty standard pricing mechanism in any market for an easily fungible good or service (read: commodity).
- lackbeard 6y ago> They are employees in that they cannot negotiate rates. Hmm... How is an Uber driver different from a plumber here? Let's say Google needs some pipes fixed at one of its offices and they tell me how much they'll pay, refusing to budge from that figure. That doesn't make me Google's employee. I can choose to do the work for that price, or I can go fix Apple's pipes instead. What am I missing?
- shrimpx 6y agoYou're not missing anything.
- nl 6y agoBecause Uber sets the rates the customer pays, and the driver gets what Uber chooses. The driver doesn't have the ability to turn up a dial and say "I'm going to charge more now". (This isn't the only distinction between an employee and contractor though of course)
- aeturnum 6y ago> "it is important to understand that you never really get to 'choose' whether you're a contractor or an employee, it's determined solely as a function of the type or work you do and the nature of your relationship to the employer" I don't understand what you're trying to say here. In my experience, on both sides of this, a good deal of thought is put into what kind of position to seek / offer. I think employers and workers think a lot about which legal arrangement would work better and there is a great deal of choice involved. For instance, I can imagine Uber offering jobs v.s. contractor positions with differing levels of support, remuneration, and expectations. That they don't do so seems like a choice to me?
- hn_throwaway_99 6y ago> I can imagine Uber offering jobs v.s. contractor positions with differing levels of support, remuneration, and expectations. Legally, in California, they can't do that. As outlined in the article, the 'ABC test' is the legal test for determining whether someone is an employee or a contractor. The 'B' part of that test is "The worker performs work that is outside the usual course of the hiring entity's business." If you are an employer, you could not have one group of drivers that you classify as employees and the other you classify as contractors, not if they're basically doing the same work. Note this is common in a lot of different businesses, and there have been many lawsuits where contractors who DID want to be classified as employees argued that they were basically doing the same work as employees. There was a fairly famous case involving Microsoft 2 decades ago: https://www.computerworld.com/article/2589538/it-personnel-microsoft-to-pay-97-million-to-settle-permatemp-case.html https://www.computerworld.com/article/2589538/it-personnel-m...
- shrimpx 6y ago> argued that they were basically doing the same work as employees I think that's case by case though. Contractors usually do finite focused projects and don't want to be employees. I myself was self-employed for 5 years doing specific contracts as a software engineer. I was "writing code" which is "the same work" as employees. Were all those companies breaking the law? > Legally, in California, they can't do that. Definitely wrong.
- birdyrooster 6y agohttps://twitter.com/tbreisacher/status/1293010691176017921?s=21 https://twitter.com/tbreisacher/status/1293010691176017921?s... Here is an example of Postmates doing it, I wouldn’t be surprised to see Uber doing the same.