6 ms·
Surely sending half a dozen ballots to the same address, for all the previous tenants from the last half decade, "enables fraud" if the person living there is s
by pc86 6y ago
Surely sending half a dozen ballots to the same address, for all the previous tenants from the last half decade, "enables fraud" if the person living there is so inclined.
- djaque 6y agoI don't think any scheme that requires people to be willing to commit felony fraud en masse is very likely. They would need to open other people's mail, forge their signature (on my ballot it clearly states that you will go to jail for this) and send it back in. They would need to risk all of that for one extra vote since they are only accidentally receiving an extra ballot. We also don't need to sit around speculating about this because the data we have on voter fraud already tells us that it's incredibly rare. What we should focus on is the 1 in 10 voters here who had a ballot rejected for primarily UX reasons that could be fixed. That's a problem which is supported by facts and could be fixed. Instead the current administration is gutting the USPS and making voting even more difficult in the middle of a pandemic. My ballot application is already taking twice as long to get in as it did last year. How is that OK?
- yostrovs 6y agoYou don't know how common voter fraud is. When it's easy to do and you can't be caught, as in other people's ballots coming to your mailbox, many will do it. They do it. I know someone who voted on behalf of another in California because ID is not necessary. There must be many more others doing the same.
- javagram 6y agoIf that happened regularly and widely it would be quite obvious because 40-50% of eligible voters vote. So there could be as much as a 40% chance that the person whose ballot you forged also tried to vote and is either turned away or submits a provisional ballot or complaint. This would create a record that could then be used to examine the signature on the ballot and charge the person with voter fraud. Note: not many states have changed their laws on vote by mail this year, so theoretical VBM fraud could have been done by submitting fraudulent ballot applications in most past elections too. The main difference this year is more voters are expected to use the no-excuse absentee ballot that was already available to them in other years.
- treeman79 6y agoFraction of an percentage is all that is needed much of the time. A few hindered ballots from a [left/right] leaning district going missing can be enough. Don’t even need to have individual fraud, just some stats on how likely one area is to vote then “wrong” way. Hell nursing homes or others could easily swing lots of votes by a single staff. I’ve dealt with plenty of high officials that have negative documents go missing. It’s just routine for many.
- yostrovs 6y agoThis being a hacker forum, would such security measures as you believe in and propose be acceptable in any computing application? In finance? Medicine? Anything really?
- javagram 6y agoThis is how the system has worked, oftentimes for decades past. No, they would not be considered acceptable in a computing application. But in computing, it’s considered acceptable to discriminate against users for the sake of security. I’m unaware of any major democracy that uses computerized voting with a username, password, and 2FA to replace the traditional ballot box, for obvious UX reasons. (Never mind that computerized results might actually be easier to forge than paper ballots). Regardless of what is “acceptable” it is a fact that widespread voter fraud using the mechanisms proposed would be detectable.
- yostrovs 6y agoThat's what the ID cards are used for, and have been for decades... Including for voting all over the world.
- javagram 6y agoThat’s never how voting has worked in the USA though. The entire idea of even having an ID card is relatively modern. We’ve had voting for centuries, and done it without ID requirements. Not sure how ID requirements would work in the several states that have done all-mail-in ballots for decades successfully.
- dunham 6y agoIf the person living there is so inclined and successfully forges the signatures on the ballots. At least in WA state, a signature is required on the exterior of the envelope, and it is validated against the signature on the voter registration form.
- heymijo 6y agoIn Ohio its signature and ID number on your driver's license or last 4 of your social security number. So ballots go to the wrong place, fine. The probability of random person there being interested and then finding any of this information is low.
- benjohnson 6y agoSignatures are a lousy form of validation for voting in my opinion: I'm a Washington state resident and because I sign a lot of checks I have two forms of my signature: My 'fancy' signature that has every letter of my name and my check signing signature that is a scrawl of simple squiggles. I used my fancy signature for voter registration and accidentally used my squiggle signature for my fist mail in ballot and did't get any kickback. I've used it for six years and King County elections still has never questioned it.
- ncallaway 6y agoAs a counterpoint, I also live in Washington. About five years ago I decided to change my signature. The first ballot I mailed in after changing my signature was rejected for having a non-matching signature, and I had to prove my identity and update my signature on file with the King County elections in order for my ballot to be counted.
- breser 6y agoMy signature ended up changing over time and I had to update my signature with the county elections office in Washington to stop my ballots from being rejected. So really not sure how you're slipping by.
- chrisseaton 6y ago
- khuey 6y agoHow is the person living there going to figure out how to correctly forge the signatures of all those previous tenants?
- burfog 6y agoThere is no such thing as large-scale signature verification. If a close match were demanded, people would complain of disenfranchisement. People don't sign the exact same way every time. Realistically, the workers are tired and they don't care. If they do reject anybody, it's probably because the vote comes from an area that tends to vote in the undesired way. In other words, this human element is a problem. It would be especially easy to bias the election by rejecting based on name. An imperfect signature of the desired ethnicity (more likely to be a "correct" vote) gets a pass. An imperfect signature of the undesired ethnicity is a fail. That's all it takes to quietly flip an election, with no evidence trail at all.
- djaque 6y agoThere doesn't need to be. I feel like we're failing to recognize that this is a soft solution, not a tech solution. The signature is there so that you go to jail for felony fraud if you forge it. Then with simple detection schemes the cost of trying compared to the benefit of like one extra vote doesn't make sense.
- burfog 6y agoThat argument is weak, but not insane, for in-person voting. For vote-by-mail though, how could anybody go to jail? The ballot shows up. It is accepted or rejected. If rejected, then what? Are we going to pick fingerprint DNA out of the paper fibers for this? There is no reasonable way to ever determine who attempted to cast the vote. It'll be fraud, but never part of the official statistics. It can't be proven without using the level of resources normally reserved for famous murder cases. There just isn't a deterrent. Severe punishment means nothing if the criminal thinks he has no chance of being caught. The fraud can be done in bulk, and it is, via ballot harvesting. Also, what about the corrupt verifiers? Being prone to rejecting some names more than others can change an election, and there would be no way to prove it. If the signature verifier has a preference between Cohen and Abdul, or between Garcia and Washington, what can anybody do?