3 ms·
It seems like changing that would be an easier and less disruptive fix?
by skybrian 6y ago
It seems like changing that would be an easier and less disruptive fix?
- TeMPOraL 6y agoImagine the fun metagames this would cause. If the government took Uber's stick away, the company would be forced to find a rate at which they'd have enough drivers to allow for reasonably short pickup time. Drivers then could, over their local "$city Uber drivers" FB/WhatsApp group, agree to not take any ride below $X, thus forcing Uber to raise their rates to $X (+ Uber's cut). (While dropping drivers from the platform if they refuse too many rides doesn't make such collusion impossible in theory, it introduces enough individual risk to make such coordination unlikely in practice.)
- ClumsyPilot 6y ago> "the company would be forced to find a rate at which they'd have enough drivers to allow for reasonably short pickup time." Oh the humanity, how will they manage? They only have like the entire dataset of all rides ever taken plus a world class data science team plus a ton of market power. Will they be able to negotiate on equal footing rate with cab-drivers?
- xyzzyz 6y agoThere is no stick; they already have to do that. If the drivers don’t like the rates and think they earn too little, they quit. Uber has to ensure that drivers make attractive rates if it wants retain them. And indeed, it offers lots of bonus pay, special deals etc precisely for that reason. > Drivers then could, over their local "$city Uber drivers" FB/WhatsApp group, agree to not take any ride below $X, This is, of course, illegal.
- drusepth 6y ago>> Drivers then could, over their local "$city Uber drivers" FB/WhatsApp group, agree to not take any ride below $X, >This is, of course, illegal. What law does this break?
- poizan42 6y agoIn the US, I think it's Section 1 of the Sherman Antitrust Act. It's referenced from the Wikipedia article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_fixing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_fixing
- abduhl 6y agoThat’s an interesting question actually. Can a third party who technically has no say in setting the actual price of a product be said to be engaging in price fixing by refusing to enter into a market, even if done collectively?
- sudosysgen 6y agoI'm, to say the very least, not sure that the Sherman Anti-trust Act prevents collective bargaining.
- fastball 6y agoGiven that the price in question is put on consumers and Uber only takes a cut, this indeed sounds more like price-fixing than collective bargaining.
- sudosysgen 6y agoCollective bargaining is always price fixing on the price of labour. So is the minimum wage. It also explicitly legal, and generally good for the common person. In general, price fixing of the cost of labour is only found to be illegal price fixing when the people fixing the price are not (or not only) employees/workers. Which isn't the case here.
- fastball 6y agoCollective bargaining applies when you are demanding things from an employer. But in this case, drivers colluding to not accept ride-shares under a certain price would be demanding a price from the consumer (which again, ride-share companies are only taking a fraction of, so it really is a price-fix on the consumer). And under such a scenario where that was allowed by the Ubers/Lyfts of the world, drivers would certainly be private contractors, and therefore business entities in their own right. So price-fixing.
- stale2002 6y ago"> Drivers then could, over their local "$city Uber drivers" FB/WhatsApp group, agree to not take any ride below $X, This is, of course, illegal." Although I am not 100% certain on this, I think that these kinds of anti-trust laws only apply when certain companies have huge amounts of market power. I believe that certain "anti-competitive" behavior would not be illegal, if done by a whole bunch of small contractors. The obvious example would be unions that do this. But it is possible that this is a special exception to the law.
- ummonk 6y agoThe bonus pay and special deals are actually what would make the contractor classification somewhat questionable, even without the California law. Uber is using incentives to try to control its drivers' hours.
- fernandotakai 6y ago>Drivers then could, over their local "$city Uber drivers" FB/WhatsApp group, agree to not take any ride below $X, thus forcing Uber to raise their rates to $X (+ Uber's cut). drivers already have those groups btw. they use to coordinate a LOT of stuff. i've seen a driver on a huge whatsapp group where they basically tried to set some areas to surge so they could earn more money.
- mullingitover 6y agoThey've pulled this stunt at LAX before. I got off the plane and suddenly all the Uber rides were over $100. Googled around and apparently this was a game they were playing to drive up rates. I took a flyaway to Union Station and then got an Uber from there for $15.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]