4 ms·
Hasn’t this been fought against for ages? There’s a reason it’s a mishmash of state driven solutions instead of one big federal ID database. Not to mention the
by dmix 6y ago
Hasn’t this been fought against for ages? There’s a reason it’s a mishmash of state driven solutions instead of one big federal ID database.
Not to mention the groups who fight against using any form of identification at all during voting.
- behringer 6y agoOf course, and it's also completely unnecessary. We are innocent until proven guilty. If I show up at a polling place (or in this case, requesting or mailing a voting packet), show them some sort of identity and address, then I should be able to vote. If you're caught committing voter fraud, you should go to jail. It's simple, and has always been effective.
- chrisseaton 6y agoDo you apply the same standard to your bank account? Someone with some sort of identity and address should be able to withdraw your bank account until proven guilty?
- behringer 6y agoThat is the standard applied at banks...
- chrisseaton 6y agoNo they also ask for a unique identifier (bank number) and an access code (PIN) and a token (bank card). That's three-auth. Two things you have to know and one thing you have to have. That's pretty good. I think that's what people are suggesting maybe voting should have.
- behringer 6y agoVoting does have something like that...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- chrisseaton 6y agoI'm sorry, what you're describing as the authorisation required for voting or for going to the bank doesn't match my experience of reality. Banks do not just require an address and ID card, and voting does not require anything more than an address. Almost all your comments on everything are downvoted so I'm guessing you're a troll and I'm going to ignore you.
- behringer 6y agoI'm being downvoted because HN is a bastion of white privilege. The reality is, voter fraud isn't really happening, and voter verification is currently perfectly sufficient, and any bank policies about requiring SSNs or state issued ID is entirely know your customer stuff and nothing to do with validating the account owner.
- burfog 6y agoThat makes catching people impossible. We can't even determine the level of fraud, so faith in our voting system is eroded. Even if you believe that there is no fraud, you should be deeply concerned that many other people are losing faith in election integrity. Elections are considered fraudulent until proven otherwise. We certainly could have decently secure elections without ID. Like this: You show up to vote in person, a good photo is taken, and you say who you are. That info is then made public. Political parties and other interested groups can sift through the photos, maybe with an AI, to find any crime. It's almost perfect. The main trouble is that fraud detection happens after the voting, so a person who doesn't fear prison can do as desired.
- behringer 6y agoWe can and we have determined the level of fraud. Hint: It's nearly 0. The right is simply fear mongering to push their racist agenda.
- jones1618 6y agoEveryone is concentrating on the wrong thing. There are two possible kinds of voter fraud (both extremely rare), "retail fraud" (i.e. individual voters) and "wholesale fraud" (i.e. bulk fraud). Voter ID laws mostly "fix" a non-existent problem of individual false votes with the express intent of discouraging votes. The real problem you want to fix is "wholesale fraud" which means securing the whole system from voting machines (which should be open-source and paper-audited) to how votes are tallied. Think about it. If you were going to steal votes would you go to all the trouble to forge or hijack individual votes or would you bribe someone to flip a couple of digits at a county office? Of course, a trustworthy system includes how mail-in votes are tracked and verified but that is a well-understood problem working well for thousands and thousands of absentees, military personnel and whole states full of people who have voted that way regularly for decades.
- slg 6y agoYes, and if you listen to many of the people arguing against it the reason we don't have a national database of citizens is because the one thing stopping the US government from turning into Nazis and committing another genocide is poor record keeping. EDIT: I am being hyperbolic here, but the second reply to my first comment was doing exactly this. We can't have this database because of the Nazis.
- whatshisface 6y agoThere are many abuses for a national database less severe than genocide, and many "apocalypse scenarios" less likely than fascism in the US.
- slg 6y agoI was being hyperbolic much as the people who are against this policy are hyperbolic, but the idea is true at any level of governmental abuse. If we fear government overreach, bad record keeping is never going to offer much protection.
- lehi 6y agoThe US Census has already been used to round up Japanese-Americans into internment camps. Post-9/11, the Census has handed over the locations and countries of origin of Arab-Americans to DHS/CBP.
- slg 6y agoThe point isn't that the US government has never done anything evil or will never do anything evil again. The point is that you aren't going to stop someone determined to commit evil by making it slightly more administratively difficult. If we fear that eventual evil, let's work to prevent it. Let's stop allowing this potential abuse to be the sole deciding factor against us doing good work today. It didn't stop us when we built the interstate highway system, which was largely built to facilitate military transport, so why should it stop us now? Also I'm not asking for a database including every possible detail about a person. I see no reason why something like race, ethnicity, religion, sexuality, or an number of other traits should be recorded. But a simple database with names, DOB, most recent address, a national id, etc would be extremely helpful.