5 ms·
What I find so crazy about America's response is that it's been totally all over the place with half-measures. America shut down 50% of the economy instead of 9
by arcticbull 6y ago
What I find so crazy about America's response is that it's been totally all over the place with half-measures. America shut down 50% of the economy instead of 90% like European countries -- enough to devastate the economy, but leave COVID unscathed. Then, many people started to go outside anyways, giving COVID more gas, which then triggered them to go back into the 50% lockdown state that wasn't doing anything anyways.
This meant the end result was a devastated economy AND full-on COVID, worse than anywhere on Earth other than Brazil.
You can make a case for a full-on economic shutdown, like the Europeans, Australians, New Zealanders and even to a lesser extent Canadians. It seemed to work out there.
You can make a case for leaving the economy open like Sweden did, knowing they'd potentially have to pay a penalty in lives greater than countries that got a vaccine before everyone caught it -- and they are down to zero deaths now too. Sweden didn't shut down and COVID is done for them now. A total of 6,000 deaths for a population of 10,000,000.
But what you can't make a case for is HALF shutting down the economy -- not enough to let people make money, and not enough to stop the virus, and not really paying people enough to stay home, but somehow more than they were making anyways. That's literally the worst of all worlds. Devastated economy. Many dead people. It's a global embarrassment.
- danans 6y ago> Sweden didn't shut down and COVID is done for them now, too. Whoa, I don't think it's safe to say that it's done anywhere. Just look at Melbourne, for an example of an outbreak in a country that supposedly had COVID19 under control. Otherwise though, yes, the half measures in the US - and the limited compliance with even those half measures in many states/regions, has set up the US for a worst of all worlds scenario.
- arcticbull 6y ago> Whoa, I don't think it's safe to say that it's done anywhere. Just look at Melbourne, for an example of an outbreak in a country that supposedly had COVID19 under control. In Melbourne, they shut down in an attempt to stamp out COVID, keeping people from catching it, leaving a large population still prone to infection. In Sweden, they did not. Their goal was not to stop people from catching COVID in Sweden, it was to let it happen at a rate they could manage, and treat people who caught it to the best of their abilities. That's why they aren't at risk of a second wave, but countries that shut down are at risk of one until a vaccine can be deployed to a herd-immunity level of the population. Sweden is there already. Sweden is likely the only place on Earth it is safe to say it's done.
- danans 6y ago> herd-immunity level of the population. Sweden is there already. The claim that Sweden has reached herd immunity is far too strong to be taken at face value without any supporting evidence ... evidence that simply doesn't exist at this time. However, their daily death rate is much higher then their neighbors: https://thehill.com/changing-america/well-being/prevention-cures/510922-the-problem-with-holding-up-sweden-as-an-example https://thehill.com/changing-america/well-being/prevention-c... The jury is far from being out on Sweden's approach, and unless they lock down their borders in perpetuity (unlikely for a country so dependent on international trade and commerce), they will still have incoming cases from elsewhere in the world.
- arcticbull 6y agoTheir death rate is now zero, and daily confirmed cases is zero. [0] It's been ~1 per day since July 25th. At this point in time their death rates are the same as their neighbors. Sweden doesn't have to lock down their borders because they didn't lock down their interior. It's all the other countries that need to lock down their borders. If it's not spreading inside the country, that's because it can't, due to herd immunity. Bars and restaurants are open, people are going to work. Life is approximately normal there now. It has been approximately normal there the whole time. A few key points from your article: > "There’s a lot to indicate that SARS-CoV-2 is a virus that needs to be controlled and not passively waited out." And yet. > "It’s still unknown whether they have short term immunity for about a year like with other coronaviruses, or any immunity at all." Obviously people develop an immunity, their immune systems are responsible for clearing the virus out. If the immune system wasn't able to clear the virus out, they'd be dead. It's also fair to say that the more serious coronaviridae like SARS convey antibody-based immunity for >3 years [1] and T-cell immunity for 17 years and counting [2] so it's not exactly a shot in the dark. [0] https://ourworldindata.org/coronavirus/country/sweden?country=~SWE https://ourworldindata.org/coronavirus/country/sweden?countr... [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2851497/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2851497/ [2] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-020-2550-z https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-020-2550-z
- 6y ago
- jandrese 6y agoThe Swedish approach sadly wouldn't work for the US. Our heathcare system is too inefficient to support it.
- redm 6y ago"You can make a case for a full-on economic shutdown, like the Europeans, Australians, New Zealanders and even to a lesser extent Canadians." The US is a Federal Republic so it's not a fair comparison with our Federal Government. I think the equivalent would be the EU mandating member countries shutdown. (I'm not that familiar with the EU charter but this is my understanding). "worse than anywhere on Earth other than Brazil." That seems to be subjective based on the metrics of comparison. If you want to make a claim like this, please be more specific and account for key variables such as population densities, count criteria, and ability to count/likely undercount (which applies to the US as well).
- pintxo 6y agoThe EU - as political body - had nearly no say in the measure in Europe. Germany - a EU member - is itself a federal republic. Here, it's not the federal government but the state and local country/city governments who managed the crisis (e.g. the government agencies tasked with ensuring public health as largely organized on the city/council level). This sometimes results in diverging rules, but at the height of the crisis, everyone (even across party lines) sat together under the moderation of the federal government and came up with common rules to minimize irritation by differing rules. To summon up, I don't think its fundamentally a problem of the political organization but of the political climate. The US seems to be far beyond the point where anyone would expect the people in power to actually come to a consensus across party lines.
- OminousWeapons 6y ago> What I find so crazy about America's response is that it's been totally all over the place with half-measures There also appear to be profound misunderstandings of how the world works among large swaths of people, from the idea that people will voluntarily do as they are told en masse (downright hilarious to anyone who has any understanding of compliance in healthcare at least in this country); to the notion that falling case rates ~= we have beaten the virus and can resume normal behavior (this all started from a handful of cases); to the notion that messaging doesn't matter (why parrot "masks protect other people from you" when you can truthfully say "masks protect you and others", and why say "young people should be concerned about putting old people at risk" when you can truthfully say "everyone is at risk of life altering complications"?); to the notion that it's acceptable to flip flop on facts for political expendiency without losing credibility; to the idea that concealing data about risk makes people more risk tolerant (it's the opposite); to the idea that John Doe consumer is somehow responsible for global supply chain management instead of governments, manufacturers, vendors, militaries, et al (how is it my responsibility to not buy masks through consumer channels instead of politicians' responsibility to order masks redirected to hospitals?); etc
- greedo 6y agoSaying that for Sweden "Covid is done for them now" is extremely disingenuous. They have an incredible high CFR, and are averaging 400 new cases a day, with 72K still infected.
- arcticbull 6y agoAnd roughly zero deaths in the last 3 weeks, and low double digit new cases daily.
- greedo 6y agoHow is 400 average cases per day "low double digit"?
- arcticbull 6y agoI was off in my math however, I'm seeing 250/day since 8/1 [1]. Yeah, I do consider that to be negligible, since it's going down or staying flat, not moving up, and the death rate remains zero. [1] https://www.coronatracker.com/country/sweden/ https://www.coronatracker.com/country/sweden/
- greedo 6y agoThere have been 23 deaths so far this month, a death rate of 2.3/day. Which aligns CFR of 10%. And I'm sure the families of the dying consider all of this "negligible." I'm sure you'll come back with more "stats" that you misinterpret or perform bad maths on. Normally I don't engage in ad-hominem, but your entire comment history on COVID has been one of denial/dismissal/diminishment that one can't help to assume you're commenting in bad faith. https://studylib.net/coronavirus#country-se https://studylib.net/coronavirus#country-se
- arcticbull 6y agoWe disagree on a few key points. 1. I don’t believe CFR is at all a useful metric. It’s not comparable across countries or across time. What is it capturing? If Sweden isn’t testing anyone who isn’t deathly ill of course it has a 10% CFR. If Singapore tests everyone of course it has a 0.05% CFR (both numbers from your link). Same disease, equally fatal in both places, yet you’re looking at a metric with a range of 3 orders of magnitude. If at this point those numbers haven’t started converging worldwide it’s a bad metric. 2. Of course how the disease affects families matters. The conversation isn’t about that, though. Public health decisions impact people one way or the other. People die one way or the other. The goal is to minimize deaths and suffering. This is the kind of thinking that prevents prison reform: “but what if we let someone out and they hurt someone else! Let’s just lock them up forever instead, problem solved.” 3. 1-2 deaths per day in a country of 10,000,000 is not a lot. By any measure. It will never be zero. 1-2 deaths per day is similar to their road fatalities (200-400 per year). It’s in line with their flu fatalities (500 per year). If 1-2 daily flu and 1-2 daily road fatalities don’t represent a catastrophe, why does this? 4. 200 cases per day in a country of 10,000,000 is not a lot when they’re not trying to contain it. Like CFR though it’s not a useful metric for comparison across countries because it doesn’t factor in testing methodology. I cite this metric at all because of it’s pronounced exponential downtrend. Factual inaccuracies in my posts preceding are my having looked at a graph wrong, or a poor graph, not bad faith. Yes, I think it's a serious disease. Yes, I wear a mask whenever I'm outside. Yes, I think masking should be mandatory. Yes, I'll take the vaccine when it's available. I do also think there's been an awful lot of sensationalism at play.