2 ms·
Methane’s global warming impact is front loaded, it breaks down in the atmosphere so in a steady state future leaks only maintain but don’t increase the amount
by Retric 6y ago
Methane’s global warming impact is front loaded, it breaks down in the atmosphere so in a steady state future leaks only maintain but don’t increase the amount of methane in the atmosphere. In other words there are significant benefits from eventually moving to something else, but little long term advantage due to methane from doing so sooner.
“technically recoverable resources“ is what’s possible to extract at any price making it a very poor measurement of economically viable reserves. Considering natural gas is already more than twice as expensive as solar power it’s primary benefit is flexibility and the limited amount of solar manufacturing currently available.
Further the absolute worst case from known reserves of 92 years worth of natural gas is the equivalent of less than 28 years worth of coal production at those rates. Which means any coal offset with natural gas is at worst equivalent to zero coal in 2048 and very likely significantly better than that.
PS: 1998 methane levels are 5% lower than current levels because we have significantly increased output over the last 20 years. But looking at the graph it’s nothing like a linear increase.
- opo 6y ago>Methane’s global warming impact is front loaded, Methane is 34 times stronger a heat-trapping gas than CO2 over a 100-year time scale. This is the timeframe we need to worry about right now to avoid the worst affects of climate change. >...“technically recoverable resources“ is what’s possible to extract at any price making it a very poor measurement of economically viable reserves. Yes, but technology improves and all of sudden they are viable. People knew of those big oil deposits in North Dakota for decades and then with fracking it became feasible to extract it. As I pointed out, even today China is going forward with making synthetic natural gas from coal (which is even worse for climate change than just burning methane.) >...Considering natural gas is already more than twice as expensive as solar power it’s primary benefit is flexibility and the limited amount of solar manufacturing currently available. The major weakness of solar is that having 100% capacity at noon in July on a sunny day in Arizona, doesn't help at midnight when you want to run medical equipment. It is possible grid storage will become feasible in the future to cover the daily and seasonal variations of capacity for wind/solar, but if we end up having the grid rely on natural gas will make it very difficult to avoid the worst problems associated with climate change.
- Retric 6y ago“Methane is 34 times stronger a heat-trapping gas than CO2 over a 100-year time scale.“ That’s intentionally deceptive. Over 20 years it’s 86 times more powerful than CO2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_warming_potential https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_warming_potential 34 = (86/5) + 4x/5 so Average from years 20 to 100 = 21. You can graph it based on in initial GWP and final GWP. CH4 = 16.04246 g/mol and CO2 = 44.0095 g/mol. So after breaking down it’s 2.75x the global warming potential of CO2 which is almost exactly the GWP from years 60 to 100. PS: Now sure that’s greater than 1, but compared to the scale of CO2 released vs accidental methane releases it might as well be.
- opo 6y ago>...That’s intentionally deceptive. Part of the Hacker News guidelines is to assume good faith. As the IPCC says: >..There is no scientific argument for selecting 100 years compared with other choices (Fuglestvedt et al., 2003; Shine, 2009). The choice of time horizon is a value judgement since it depends on the relative weight assigned to effects at different times. I chose 100 years since you seemed to imply that since methane was "front loaded" then "...there are significant benefits from eventually moving to something else, but little long term advantage due to methane from doing so sooner." Trying to ignore the problems of methane in the atmosphere is not helpful. As the Think Progress article says >...The IPCC reports that, over a 20-year time frame, methane has a global warming potential of 86 compared to CO2, up from its previous estimate of 72. Given that we are approaching real, irreversible tipping points in the climate system, climate studies should, at the very least, include analyses that use this 20-year time horizon. >...If we are to avoid catastrophic warming, our natural gas consumption has to peak sometime in the next 10 to 15 years, according to studies by both the Center for American Progress and the Union of Concerned Scientists.
- Retric 6y agoI chose 100 years since you seemed to imply that since methane was "front loaded" then "...there are significant benefits from eventually moving to something else, but little long term advantage due to methane from doing so sooner. Ahh, ok I genuinely assumed you understood what that number meant and chose to use it incorrectly. As to 86 for 20 years still being important. These methane leaks from natural gas are nowhere near 1/86th of global CO2 production. They are not even 1/86th of the displaced CO2 from reduced coal use age. Compare ~10 megatonnes of methane leaks worldwide from all sources of natural gas with global Fossil CO2 emissions at ~37,000 megatons per year and 740,000 over 20. Except your natural gas emissions don’t stack linearly for 20 years with past emissions. So natural gas power plants are easily a net reduction in global warming over your 20 year timetable.