5 ms·
This fails because we only have one formal kind of payment - money - and in a monetised economy, nothing compares with it. Money solves one problem - how to ge
by TheOtherHobbes 6y ago
This fails because we only have one formal kind of payment - money - and in a monetised economy, nothing compares with it.
Money solves one problem - how to get people to do things that may be useful to others which they wouldn't otherwise do - but causes much worse problems in return.
The most obvious is money is such a riotously inefficient way to decide what is and isn't genuinely useful, especially collectively.
OSS doesn't really solve the usefulness problem. It's good at producing software that's appealing to people who like using and tinkering with OSS software - but no one else really cares unless it's handed to them inside a product which has been assembled to be useful. And even then it's about the product, not about a largely imaginary "freedom" which is inaccessible to most users because it specialised skills, advanced knowledge, and plenty of free time.
This doesn't make it useless, it just gives it a different domain to operate in. There's some overlap, but there are many potentially useful projects that don't happen because they don't appear inside either the commercial or the OSS circles.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoI need a goat and have chickens for trade. What's your exchange rate?
- rolph 6y agofreewheelin' franklin says .... "Dope will get you through times of no money, better than money will get you through times of no dope." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Fabulous_Furry_Freak_Brothers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Fabulous_Furry_Freak_Broth... generally - things and stuff get you through times of no money better than money gets you through times of no things and no stuff. money is really a roundabout way of convincing someone to give you things and stuff, and offering shiny things and stuff is a way to get money. in the end money is for making landlords and bankers happy, its the things and stuff that help to mantle over the hard problems of real life.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoYou seem to be dismissing FOSS, despite that it has taken over the world when it comes to servers and smartphones. > OSS doesn't really solve the usefulness problem. Most Linux kernel devs are paid professionals, making improvements that have value to their employer, and making the improvements available to all (a triumph of copyleft). It's not just hobbyists tinkering in ways they find interesting. Hasn't been that way for decades. > It's good at producing software that's appealing to people who like using and tinkering with OSS software - but no one else really cares unless it's handed to them inside a product which has been assembled to be useful. I have the choice of several different FOSS browsers, text-editors, C++ compilers. FOSS is quite capable of producing a 'finished product' that just works. > even then it's about the product, not about a largely imaginary "freedom" which is inaccessible to most users because it specialised skills, advanced knowledge, and plenty of free time It's not just developers who are affected by issues like tracking, intrusive telemetry, and even just unskippable ads in DVDs. It's true that developers are more aware of these issues.
- quanticle 6y agoYou seem to be dismissing FOSS, despite that it has taken over the world when it comes to servers and smartphones. I think that dismissal is correct. While both may be open-source, neither is "free" in the sense of the term that Stallman is using. Cloud services may run on Linux, but it's a very TiVo-ized form, where the free core is wrapped in many layers of proprietary code that serve to negate the freedoms that Stallman is pushing for. Similarly, Android, while it is open-source, is nowadays so dependent on Google Play Services (which is proprietary) that it seems hardly fair to call it free software in the same way that one would call a Linux desktop free software.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoYou have a point about smartphones, but I'm not convinced about cloud virtual servers. You can use proprietary managed services from AWS, or whoever, but if you just want a GNU/Linux server, you still have that option. Indeed, there's never been a better time for it.
- elviejo 6y agoFree software in this essay means software that respects your freedom. Not "Gratis". So every company has the right to charge you for their software but once you acquire it you can use it however you wish.
- Osiris 6y agoDon't most FOSS licenses explicitly allow for redistribution though? So once one person gets itm they can then redistribute it for free or a cost with the original developer not benefiting (directly).
- drwiggly 6y agoSure but the end user of this product doesn't know or care about the parts. This matters to those of us in the plumbing business and those businesses that would hire us to do their plumbing.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- stjohnswarts 6y agoI suppose that money does bring a lot of problems along with it. However, in human history there has never been a better means to trade or provide almost universally desired fiat. Since there has never been a nation state collective government that has survived over the long haul or a massive project on a national scale completed without either money or an authoritarian government forcing it, I think we'll just have to live with it for now until someone figures out a way to make the world collectively completely altruistic.
- jarpadat 6y agoWe do have a secondary form of capital: what we charitably call ethics/guidelines, or uncharitably - peer pressure. This is the currency that dominates FSF language like the “harm done” by proprietary software, the free software “manifesto” and so on. It is in this currency that developers are given a “perk” of occasionally working on open code at their otherwise closed day job, or are compensated in in exchange of a more lucrative proprietary model for their side project. I don’t have anything against those who take their free software views seriously. But I am very annoyed that the currency of “ethical behavior” is one that burdens the individual and benefits the corporation. Only individuals can feel guilty that their software is not free, can agonize over copyleft vs permissive, can feel obligated to pass up compensation in exchange for ethical currency, can feel drained by an internet argument, etc. Corporations meanwhile can mostly ignore this secondary currency and operate entirely within the system of money.
- crocko 6y agoPressuring developers to use your license (when it is their work and their choice) is disgusting and people shouldn't be doing it at all.