4 ms·
PDFs for printing are great, and they make a nice portable envelope for my vector originals, but I despise them as online or eBook formats. For eBooks, I've se
by ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago
PDFs for printing are great, and they make a nice portable envelope for my vector originals, but I despise them as online or eBook formats.
For eBooks, I've settled on reflowable EPUB. I guess, in some cases, we may want fixed format, where PDFs might be useful.
For online, I prefer HTML, usually as a continuous page, and with "pretty print" (@media print) CSS. I find it annoying that the page-break-% CSS rule seems to be ignored by just about every browser, or at least, interpreted badly.
I really have gotten a lot out of the NNG folks; in particular, Don Norman, but they do like to kick anthills.
- benrbray 6y agoEPUB is a non-starter for me as most e-readers haven't bothered to implement decent math support. We've had LaTeX math for decades now, come on people! Any HTML-based format like EPUB should be using KaTeX at a bare minimum, but instead I often see an ungodly mess of poorly-spaced notation in an inappropriate font, much like those old manuscripts from the 1960s produced on typewriters. Until these issues are fixed, I'll keep enjoying my beautiful LaTeX PDFs, thank you!
- specialist 6y agoReflowable PDFs were the Correct Answer. Since the beginning. IMHO Adobe has been a terrible steward of PDF. I have no idea why. (Source: Used to write print production software in the 90s. Some of my team went to Adobe. One was bored so banged out a PostScript clone hooked up to the newer image library in a few weeks. They all said the PDF libraries were garbage, everyone was afraid to breathe on them, no one was motivated to do anything better.) Re NNG: Agree. +1 Don Norman, whereas Nielsen and Tog haven't said anything interesting in ages.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI didn't even know there was such a thing as reflowable PDF. Agree. EPUB is a fairly half-baked solution. Reflowable PDF might have been good, but, I guess there was never any support for it.
- specialist 6y agoYa. One needful use case was (is?) variable data printing, allowing mass customization, like direct mail. Pretty much the same technical progression that happened in user interfaces going from absolute coords and static layout to dynamic layout managers. The fix was so easy. Just retain some of the source document's meta data, eg this group of glyphs are a "paragraph". The PDF object model was explicitly designed for exactly this kind of extension. IIRC Some specialty vendors had some goofy work-arounds, like a post process tool for manually marking paragraphs. But Adobe could never be bothered.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Joker_vD 6y agoI've yet to find an EPUB reader that would give me scrolling without page breaks. So far, it seems all of them believe that if I scroll past the end of the chapter it's because I've read it all and want to see the new one, not because I want the chapter's last lines to be in the middle of the screen, for easier reading. Argh! And every single PDF viewer, even the shitty built-in mobile ones, have continuous scrolling!
- layoutIfNeeded 6y ago>I've yet to find an EPUB reader that would give me scrolling without page breaks. The Books app on iOS can do this.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoThat's why I prefer Books. It's kinda "meh," otherwise, but I have come to rely on it for an eBook reader.
- epakai 6y agoEPUB is mostly a zip of HTML files and they're often split by chapter. I know Foliate does continuous scrolling, but it's only on *nix platforms.
- neilpanchal 6y agoI disagree, PDFs provide a consistent, as intended layout from the author/publisher/editor. EPUBs are great for novels and text-heavy literature, but they're awful for anything that has pictures, code snippets, etc. I usually prefer to buy O'Reilly books in PDF format because they're extremely well formatted and designed - just as if you're reading a physical book. In addition, typography and style are poorly adapted in EPUB format whereas with PDF - it can be read instantly on any device, any where and usually without installing a reader or fonts. There is so much inconsistency between Windows/Linux and Mac, iPhone, Android when reading an EPUB book. EPUB = Great for text only literature. PDF = Great for pretty much everything else.
- crazygringo 6y agoThe problem with EPUB is you can't annotate them. I do a ton of academic research, and whenever I find a source in EPUB I have to convert it to PDF first, just so I can do highlighting, circling, etc. True, EPUB applications generally allow you to highlight, but those highlights are stored in the application. They don't live in the file. You can't export them to import them in another reader program. With PDF, all my annotations stay in the PDF itself, and appear in all fully-featured PDF software.
- m463 6y agoIf you don't need formatting, then yes pdfs may be forcing a burden on you you don't need - especially on small screens that cannot display a full page without microscopic fonts. But when you need the formatting, PDF is wonderful. The problem with HTML is that it's a moving target.
- powersnail 6y agoFor PDF vs Epub, I have recently seen the combination of traits of both, in a very devastating way. The characters were overlapping, no matter which reader I use, what margin/line/character spacing I set, until I adjusted the font size to two points smaller, and everything was right. It turns out that whoever made the epub, turned every word into a single html element, with a fixed position! So, it was like PDF in a sense that every thing has a position on the page. But it was like epub in the sense that everything's size can be changed (albeit within the "div" element). And the default size doesn't event work for the book. I cringed so fiercely that I nearly deleted the book.