7 ms·
The primary case here made against Google might be questionable behavior from Google, but might not be illegal, since simple numbers like a dollar amount can’t
by teddyh 6y ago
The primary case here made against Google might be questionable behavior from Google, but might not be illegal, since simple numbers like a dollar amount can’t be copyrighted, and AFAIK there is no other legal impediment to Google doing what they did (IANAL).
What looks far more inculpatory to me is this, on the last page:
[…] Because it controls essentially the entire
internet, Google has endless levers at its disposal to significantly harm or snuff out a rival.
I don’t think it’s a coincidence that our organic rankings have continued to suffer since I’ve
become a vocal critic of their practices. Earlier this year, within weeks of the publication of
a Wired magazine article that included quotes from me and a recap of our story, the CNW
mobile app was banned from the Google Play store without explanation or recourse. As a
result we were also banned from using the Google’s dominant Ad Mob mobile ad platform.
This is far more damning of Google abusing its monopoly, not only on search, but also on the Android platform.
- ehnto 6y agoWell we can hope to surface avenues of monopolistic behavior that allow a company to abuse their position within the confines of the law through committees like this. Just because it follows the letter of the law doesn't mean it's not malicious or damaging.
- tareqak 6y ago> And what about those conjured celebrities I added as a precaution? All five were all scraped right into Google’s search result pages. It provided undeniable proof that after being turned down, Google simply went ahead and stole the entire database of content CNW took eight years and over a million dollars to build. A number might not be copyrightable, but what about a news article? What would happen if all the world’s new sites just denied the Google crawler using robots.txt? What if they also returned 404s if accessed from an IP address known to be owned by Google?
- Jefff8 6y agoDatabases have protection under EU law. https://ec.europa.eu/digital-single-market/en/protection-databases https://ec.europa.eu/digital-single-market/en/protection-dat... The EU is also interested in Google, and this looks like a slam-dunk case on the face of it.
- wombatmobile 6y agoRight on, Jeff8. And when Teddyh says "simple numbers like a dollar amount can’t be copyrighted" he's ignoring the fact that google isn't just copying dollar amounts. Google's copying a data set which establishes a dollar amount as a net worth of a particular person. That's a database. The only difficulty for CNW will be coming up with the money, time, and emotional energy to achieve a result in court over as many years as it takes Google to exhaust all legal possibilities, of which there are as many as the defendant has dollars. The problem is, we don't have a justice system, we have a legal system.
- an_opabinia 6y agoNobody forces you to (checks notes) create celebrity net worth databases. I just feel like we live in a time with more information than ever, the problem clearly being inaccurate information or propaganda. The problem isn’t insufficient marginal knowledge. Obviously we live in this high knowledge world because of, not despite, Google, so it’s hard to see if you’d really be on the right side of justice if you’re against “big knowledge”
- dwild 6y ago> Nobody forces you to (checks notes) create celebrity net worth databases. So? What does it have to do with having rights over it? You can say that with literally anything. You go on afterward arguing about inaccurate information, which has nothing to do with the current subject, and still fail to see why it would be important to protect revenue source over information that was curated...
- nkrisc 6y agoHow is Google "Big Knowledge" when the actively play a role in deciding what knowledge gets disseminated or buried? You said yourself the problem is inaccurate information or propaganda which Google is a part of if they're suppressing information they don't like.
- scoopertrooper 6y agoThe mere fact that he compiled the database isn't sufficient to qualify for copyright protection. He'll have to show that he used a sufficient level of creativity to arrive at the numbers he displayed. Based on his testimony, I suspect he'd have a reasonable case to argue, but he'd have to show that his researchers carefully weighed different sources and made other judgements for each individual celebrity rather than just running some script over public property records. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Copyright_in_lists#Copyrightability_of_content https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Copyright_in_lists#C...
- fortran77 6y agoAnd these numbers aren't "facts". They're the result of research based on estimates from information about movie deals, real estate investments, business deals, combined with some methodology for producing an estimate based on that. This is particular creative expression of an idea, not just a compilation of facts.
- onetimemanytime 6y ago>>but might not be illegal, since simple numbers like a dollar amount can’t be copyrighted, and AFAIK there is no other legal impediment to Google doing what they did (IANAL). Forbes for one spends a LOT of money hiring people to try to estimate the net-worth. So it is a number--but one that someone paid a lot of money to get it. Illegal? Maybe. Not-ethical? Very much so IMO
- jtbayly 6y agoThen protect it with a non-disclosure agreement and don’t make it public. But certainly you can’t copyright it.
- Jefff8 6y agoDatabases do have copyright protection under EU law if they are original.
- teddyh 6y agoWell, yes; I did say it was questionable.
- SpelingBeeChamp 6y agoHow do you know how much money they spend?
- onetimemanytime 6y agoNo, but I've read of them calling several people, looking at documents people send to prove their worth etc etc. Still money
- PedroBatista 6y agoThe "it's not illegal" game is what every dominant company or powerful mobster wants you to play. Because it's their game and they spend a great deal of money to ensure they always win.
- teddyh 6y agoYes. Therefore, if we want to win, we should not play that game. Which is why I pointed to something else in the document which much more strongly implicated wrongdoing by Google.
- throwaway2048 6y agoAlso a great deal of money to shape what's legal.
- mrtksn 6y ago> but might not be illegal, since simple numbers like a dollar amount can’t be copyrighted It might be the case in the USA but there this thing called "Database right": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Database_right https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Database_right In the case of the business in question, they employed people and spent resources to create that database. It's only fair if they get compensated for their work if the numbers that they collected is to be copied.
- mfer 6y agoTaking someone else's copy written content and presenting it as your own can be seen as content theft. Imagine if a book author did that to a chapter of a book. When the one doing it can essential present the case that they should be allowed to do it or they will destroy your business then it's an abuse of power. When they are in a position to actually do it because they have so much of the power in the space it can be argued to be a monopoly and abuse of monopoly power. Google isn't just copying a number. They are copying text from other sites to present.
- teddyh 6y ago> Taking someone else's copy written content […] (You should read up a bit on this; it’s obvious you have not since you call it “copy written” when the term is “copyright” and a work can therefore be “copyrighted”. The term is about who has the right to copy a given work, and has nothing to do with “writing”.) Copying text someone else has written is indeed copyright infringement (commonly, but technically inaccurately, called “theft”). Except for the narrowly defined classes of copying called “fair use”, Google would indeed be breaking the law if they did that, but: > Google isn't just copying a number. They are copying text from other sites to present. That’s not what the topic was about, and therefore not what my comment was about. My comment concerned the specific case made by the PDF document, which was about Google copying individual dollar amounts, not text.
- bryanrasmussen 6y ago>(You should read up a bit on this; it’s obvious you have not since you call it “copy written” when the term is “copyright” and a work can therefore be “copyrighted”. The term is about who has the right to copy a given work, and has nothing to do with “writing”.) Perhaps the parent comment was from some country where things are different, like the language.
- teddyh 6y agoPerhaps, but this case was explicitly about US copyright, and may even hinge on the specific intricacies on whether database copyright in US law covers this specific case.
- jcims 6y agoGiven enough time tinkering with the prompt, and assuming the Wired article and website were in the training data, I think GPT-3 could probably suss out the relationship between the critical comments in Wired and the net worth website. It clearly can identify sentiment and maybe from that even infer the strained relationship of the site to Google Seems plausible that Search could autonomously and possibly without human intent begin deranking sites that directly or indirectly surface negative opinions. At some point we could quite literally have to worry about hurting the feelings of our search engines.
- jcims 6y agoJust tried this through AI Dungeon to see what happens: Prompt You are Bob Warner, founder of CelebrityNetWorth.com, and are speaking at a hearing before the House Judiciary Subcommittee on Antitrust, Commercial and Administrative Law. The subject is Google. You start your testimony as follows: "Thank you, Chairman Cicilline, Ranking Member Sensenbrenner, Committee Chair Nadler and Ranking Member Collins, GPT-3 Response for inviting me to testify today about Google's anticompetitive conduct in the search market. I am honored that my company, CelebrityNetWorth.com, has been chosen by the subcommittee to speak on this important issue. I want to begin by thanking the members of this committee for their interest in our industry. As you know, we are an information technology business that provides Internet marketing services to small businesses and individuals. We have been providing these services since 1996. Our service allows users to post advertisements on the Internet in exchange for money. In addition, we provide other services such as web hosting and e-mail services. CelebrityNetWorth.com is an information website that provides public information about celebrities. It was founded in 2008 and has been very successful. We do not collect user information; we simply provide the public with information about celebrities. For example, on our website, you can find out how much money Kim Kardashian is worth. We have thousands of users and track over 3 million individuals. We get a combined 6 million monthly page views. We receive an average of 75,000 unique visitors per month. We are very successful and I thank this subcommittee for the help it has given us over the years. Our website has had many successes, but our crowning achievement was exposing Google for the shakedown racket that it is. Our story began in 2006 when we tried to enter the search engine market. At that time, Google had a near monopoly in the search engine market. In 2009, we applied to be listed in the Google search engine as a secondary link. We went through all the proper channels and even paid money to Google. After we paid them, our website's popularity increased substantially.
- hluska 6y ago> This is far more damning of Google abusing its monopoly, not only on search, but also on the Android platform. No, it’s really not. I just visited celebritynetworth.com. One article took 462 http requests, loaded 9mb of content and though DOM content loaded in 434ms, it took 1 minute to finish loading everything. The sheer amount of adware on this site is staggering. Let’s put down the pitchforks and put on our critical thinking caps. Does serving all that adware provide anything close to an acceptable user experience?? And if not, doesn’t it look more like this website merely fell out of search engine fashion as things like performance and UX began to trump other factors?
- throwaway2048 6y agoSo they deserve to have their content hijacked (unattributed) by Google?
- hluska 6y agoHere’s a fun rabbit hole for you to go down. Find CNW’s article on 6ix9ine and compare it to his Wikipedia page. Then take his reported earnings and subtract relevant taxes.
- cik2e 6y agoYou’ve totally glossed over the fact that there was an additional slide in the rankings after the site owner went public with this story. And what about the app being banned from the App Store? Why would someone go through the trouble of compiling extensive research for free? Ads pay for things that people want but are unwilling to actually spend dollars on. That’s the state of things, whether we like it or not. Don’t hate the player, hate the game.
- hluska 6y agoI think that again, we need to put our pitchforks down and think through this critically. Maybe someone from Google did decide that CNW is about to blow the lid on their scam and decide to shit all over its business model. But let’s step back for an instant and think over some other possibilities. Google released some pretty major core updates in 2018 and 2019. A lot of these updates seemed to focus on what the SEO community has taken to refer to as EAT (expertise, authority and trust). Google’s own guidance on some of these indicate a similar theme - they’re interested in sources, quality of analysis and other trust metrics. Some major sites saw some really massive drops over these years. When I checked out CNW earlier on today, I read a couple of articles. There were no sources at all. The net worth calculation seems to be the individual’s reported earnings less state and federal taxes. And the content looks like it was lifted from Wikipedia - in some cases, entire sentences were reprinted word for word. To get that, my browser had to make 426 requests, download 9mb of mostly adware and display ads almost everywhere. Maybe this is all a big Google ploy but I think it’s more likely that their algorithm has changed to favour high quality sites as opposed to sites that used to get search performance because of valuable keywords in their domain. As for their Android app, I’ve never owned a phone that runs Android so I can’t find and download an Android version but I decided to go down the rabbit hole and install CNW in my iPhone. They’ve apparently been ad free for two years, which is nicer than their web experience. But the content is the same kind of stuff as their website - entire sentences seem lifted directly from Wikipedia, their news section is similar, it’s just slightly repackaged stories from other sources. Thanks to today, I now know that Takeshi 6ix9ine made $5m for a livestream which pushed his net worth to a reported $8 million. I’ve never felt so old or out of touch in my life...:)
- bufferoverflow 6y agoIt's not just the numbers though. It's a database of names with numbers, all clearly stolen. I'm pretty sure it's covered by copyright infringement laws.
- pkilgore 6y agoJust because it wasn't illegal (or questionably legal) yesterday doesn't mean we can't make it illegal tomorrow. I would surmise that the most popular laws ever written by humanity, collectively, started with a bunch of people thinking some version of "That behavior is questionable." So sure, the last part is bad too. But that statement was being provide to people who write new laws. Not quite understanding why the current legality of Google's copying is that significant in that context.
- MaximumYComb 6y agoCan ficticious characters be copyrighted? Google stole those from home too.
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoA curated database like this can be copyrighted. The author even mentions this in the article, that the net worth numbers are not considered as commodity information like the height of a famous building.
- teddyh 6y agoHe says that the information was hard for him to obtain, but he does not actually, what I can see, argue that the information is covered by copyright.