3 ms·
> The solar array and battery storage (all of which can be recycled today with existing recycling techniques) will be built on time, begin generating on time...
by roenxi 6y ago
> The solar array and battery storage (all of which can be recycled today with existing recycling techniques) will be built on time, begin generating on time...
Steady on, that is a prediction for a project where data is light. The most comparable experience Australia has to this stuff is the Basslink which broke in 2015-16 and triggered a major energy crisis in Tasmania. And I think technically means that 50% of Australia's major undersea cables have been involved in an energy crisis.
This is a major project. It is not yet clear it will be delivered on time and on budget. It is very a very exciting project nonetheless.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoMaintenance and redundancy of HVDC transmission capacity is a more tractable problem than cost efficient storage & reprocessing of nuclear waste and nuclear generator decommissioning at end of service life. Basslink was mismanaged, and that's a tractable problem as well. Could this project be late? Of course. "Nuclear generator late and over budget"? No.
- roenxi 6y agoThis cable is 3,700 km; the current longest undersea cable is ~600 km [0]. This is nearly an order of magnitude longer than any undersea cable previously run. You've got no data this one. It has never been done before and even the people directly involved in the project can't be sure what surprises may or may not be in store as they push the boundaries of engineering practice. > Could this project be late? Of course. "Nuclear generator late and over budget"? No. This is bald-faced fabrication. I've never been confronted with quite so blatant a guess presented as a confident fact. Even arguing that "nuclear projects can't be completed to plan" is in itself a bit much - planning standards can change. Bad planning isn't a property of nuclear electricity and good planning isn't a property of undersea cables. This could easily be $50 billion down the drain and the project is still never completed. The risk is there. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Submarine_power_cable https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Submarine_power_cable
- toomuchtodo 6y agoYou're correct I might be overly optimistic (although I believe my reasoning is sound based on the historical track record of nuclear vs transmission construction). I've reached out to an academic with numerous papers authored on the topic of HVDC submarine cables, and inquired as to the feasibility and challenges a 3700km HVDC submarine link might face (to provide a comparison to those faced by the construction of nuclear generators). I'll report back with my findings.