3 ms·
> White is unambiguously the correct answer. OMFG. It most certainly is not. "White" is a very good explanation for the sum of all visible light that reache
by ajross 6y ago
> White is unambiguously the correct answer.
OMFG. It most certainly is not. "White" is a very good explanation for the sum of all visible light that reaches the environment on the ground.
But if you look at (or really towards) the actual bright thing in the sky, you see it as yellow. Preschool kids and amateurs aren't wrong on this. It's yellow. Go look.
I mean, even that's not correct. The disk of the sun itself is too bright for your retina to actually sense, saturates the cells, and leaves weird artifacts (and no small amount of permanent damage, of course) that look like all sorts of colors.
But the glare around the sun that you see before you look away is, for sure, yellow. The shorter wavelengths have been preferentially scattered away on the direct path to your eye. They are the "blue" that someone else sees when they look to that path in the "sky". What's left... is yellow (relative to the general color balance of the non-direct light, that is).
Sure sure, "solar irradiance" is as good a definition for "white" as you'll find. But "the sun" is yellow.
- mjw1007 6y agoNote the question in the article is not the question in the HN title. It's « I'm told the Sun is a big hot ball! Awesome! I love balls! What color is the ball? ». Under « Methods - Question design » in the article: « The "ball" helps clarify intent - 'object, viewed from space', not 'eyeball observation made through atmosphere'. »
- ajross 6y agoThe title is from the article, not the HN submitter. Clearly "What color is the Sun?" reflects the question they want the reader to have in mind, not the specifics of the question they bury down at the end. So... I don't get it. Your point is that the article's interpretation is "right" because they purposefully designed the question to be confusing? Would you react the same way if you were reading an opinion poll that played the same trickery? I mean, if they wanted a "correct" answer, why didn't they just ask "what color is sunlight?"