6 ms·
Last mile for fixed rural wireless broadband seems like the obvious one. Today, this is generally done with either LTE or various proprietary things (or if you’
by rsynnott 6y ago
Last mile for fixed rural wireless broadband seems like the obvious one. Today, this is generally done with either LTE or various proprietary things (or if you’re particularly unlucky, satellite). 5G should allow for greater total bandwidth, reducing the impact of contention.
And on the other side, it should be helpful for very dense urban usage. Try using LTE in a large city’s central train station at a busy time and see how you get on.
But yeah, not revolutionary, but should make existing LTE applications less awful in some scenarios where they struggle.
- CydeWeys 6y agoI wonder how this will fare vs Starlink, which seems like it's trying to solve the same problem.
- magicsmoke 6y agoStarlink will probably do better than 5G for access to rural areas because you don't need to build out a physical cable. In highly dense urban areas with large numbers of simultaneous users, 5G is a better fit.
- dylan604 6y agoHave the 5G towers connect to Starlink rather than running the cabling to them.
- selectodude 6y agoThat doesn't really fix the total bandwidth capacity issue though.
- kalleboo 6y agoI wonder if a tower with a larger array of Starlink antennas could connect to multiple satellites and get more performance than the pizzabox-sized consumer receivers
- thu2111 6y agoIn many cases you can link base stations to other downlink points using lasers or really tight beams though. It's not like they can only go upwards.
- bdamm 6y agoStarlink is going to dominate this. Cellular can't economically scale out to meet the vast rural coverage. There are still plenty of towns that don't have basic coverage even now, and to think that suddenly they're going to get 5G equipment... seems unlikely. Meanwhile, the Starlink satellites are up and base stations are in testing. Once they approve and start building out their ground stations, it's SpaceX's business to lose.
- rudolph9 6y agoIt's worth explicitly noting that Starlink is applicable to rural areas. As OG noted 5G is applicable to both densely populated and rural areas. Further, it's theoretically possible to combine 5G and satellite internet where Starlink or similar serves as the connection to the internet backbone for a device broadcasting a 5G network. Connectivity isn't an all or nothing game and 5G is protocol that the SpaceX internet service business can leverage.
- mikepurvis 6y agoI feel like the viability of that depends a lot on the price point of the service and the user terminal. If it's cheap enough that everyone might as well just have their own then there's no point doing infrastructure for a terrestrial backhaul.
- graerg 6y ago5g and starlink are almost certainly going to be used in tandem in rural areas.
- woah 6y agoIIRC Starlink can handle about 2gbs per 50 sq miles due to frequency bandwidth limitations. That's a few hundred subscribers. It's not going to make an impact in any but the most rural areas.
- semi-extrinsic 6y agoWow, that sounds like a huge limitation, no? The number of people living in places that sparsely populated must be very limited, how does it make economical sense to launch that huge number of satellites?
- elil17 6y agoI don’t really see 5G solving rural broadband issues. You still need to lay backhaul line from the node Bs, and 5G requires more of them, so it’s not orders of magnitude cheaper than running cable to home.
- aaomidi 6y agoA lot of rural areas have backbone just fine. It's the last mile that's the issue. You can find gigabit business internet basically anywhere.
- HeWhoLurksLate 6y agoWoah, that's an enormous sweeping generalization. I have a friend whose parents live in rural Kansas who to this day can't get more than dialup or satellite, even though they've called up every single semi-local ISP (way more than once) and said they'd be willing to pay for installation. At this point, they have more than $20K saved for the chance that some company says maybe. It's simply way more complicated than you're making it out to be.
- dboreham 6y agoNo, parent cited _business_ Gigabit. You're talking about retail consumer connectivity. Totally different things. Based on my deep knowledge of connectivity options here in rural Montana parent is correct: there's lit fiber all over the place (certainly to all cell towers) and various telcos will trench up to 5km from any of those pops, for a price. So a business looking to acquire Gigabit connectivity can readily access it. Ask your parents to call the ILEC business sales guy and see what happens. They'll need $5k/mo budget for transit fees and be willing to sign a 3-5 year contract.
- HeWhoLurksLate 6y agoI shall tell my friend about that. Thank you for the information!
- swebs 6y ago>Try using LTE in a large city’s central train station at a busy time and see how you get on. There was some ad campaign in Helsinki about two or three years ago telling people to do just this to compare carriers. Telia, Dna, and all the others worked just fine at rush hour at the central station with 50mbps+
- tuatoru 6y agoAh, but Finland considers internet access a human right.
- swebs 6y agoThe point is that they were able to meet capacity with 4g towers. I'm not sure how that's related. I guess I should also point out that the population of the city is 600k people, so it may not carry over to something like NYC or Tokyo.
- menybuvico 6y agoAnd most of those towers provide comparably low-bandwidth connectivity (at least outside urban areas). It's not like you have decent speeds up here, but the legally mandated 2mbps is available in most places.
- phkahler 6y ago>> Last mile for fixed rural wireless broadband seems like the obvious one. I was under the impression that 5G has shorter range and requires smaller cells. That's exactly the opposite of being better for rural areas.
- carteloupe 6y ago5G is several things, availability of the new mmwave spectrum is just one of them
- numpad0 6y ago> fixed rural wireless broadband It’s well worth trying but WiMAX tried the same so not novel > Try using LTE in a large city’s central train station at a busy time and see how you get on. uh, um, I thought LTE is already at least okay as it is for Shinjuku morning/Comiket queue problem
- maliker 6y agoThere’s a huge push at the US federal level to get fiber to the home in rural areas. 10s of billions in funding. A lot of times it’s run by the electric companies (coops). They already have the right of way, pole access, and customer relationships. There are dozens of utilities pursuing this, haven’t heard of any working with 5g. There was a recent executive order restricting foreign equipment on the grid, and I suspect that’s going to make things harder for 5g. I’m not saying 5g can’t be used in rural applications, just that it looks like fiber has a big head start. Now that there’s also more LEO satellite internet companies coming in with decent latency and bandwidth, that’s going to be another competitor to 5g in rural areas.
- deelowe 6y agoMost coops aren't able to make use of the funding due to competing regulations getting in the way. My local coop has been sending us updates every few months on the situation and they're just getting ignored. Their recent emails have taken a more cynical tone that the government was doing more than playing lip service.
- bleepblorp 6y agoIs there much evidence that this funding will do anything more than previous rounds of rural internet funding? Previous funding has simply disappeared into the pockets of incumbent players without any hardware being built. Technology isn't a solution for graft.
- packetlost 6y agoI used to work for a telcom, and the thing I'm most excited for is the benefits dense urban areas may see with 5G-based internet service. If it weren't for caps, it would significantly drive down the cost and bureaucracy of installing/updating infrastructure while increasing the speeds in a lot of areas.
- BenjiWiebe 6y agoQuite a bit of rural fixed wireless broadband uses Wifi for the last mile.