6 ms·
I am always amazed that Brave New World is taught as dystopic. Maybe it's over the top in its anti-reactionary elements, but considering that everyone except fo
by 082349872349872 6y ago
I am always amazed that Brave New World is taught as dystopic. Maybe it's over the top in its anti-reactionary elements, but considering that everyone except for a single suicidal (not saying it's because he was viviparous, some of my best friends have been born viviparously...) misfit has a pleasant life, one would think utilitarians should be as fond of Huxley as others are of Rand.
- nxc18 6y agoI strongly agree with you. Brave New World is a utopian novel desperately trying to appear dystopic. With just a few small changes, to account for the existence of automation/robots/computers, the darker aspects (e.g. the population of deltas) stop being plausible within the universe. The TV show had to invent a lot of extra nonsense to introduce conflict. Perhaps the most troubling aspect of Brave New World is that things are so stable, human needs are met so consistently, that life ceases to be a struggle; without a struggle, life becomes meaningless. That interpretation is alluded to in the TV show, but I won't spoil it. We should be working as hard as possible to move society closer to brave new world and further from 1984.
- Oricle 6y agoShould be removing the puppet masters off their perch is all so all gentiles can live free from their unempathetic evil ways. Judah as always been the enemy to gentiles
- enriquto 6y ago> We should be working as hard as possible to move society closer to brave new world and further from 1984. I never thought that this idea was even conceivable. Brave new world is orders of magnitude more terrifying than 1984. It describes a complete dead end, the last throes just before the thermal death of mankind. Heck, even the novel "Atomised", that describes the disappearance of homo sapiens, is not as grim as brave new world. How can you seriously read brave new world as utopian?
- 082349872349872 6y agoVery easily. Taking utilitarianism to be maximisation of happiness and well-being, how many people in Brave New World are happy? unhappy? Is there any lack of well-being, outside of the savage reservations? As to "more terrifying", 1984 features actual repression (albeit mostly operative only for ~13% of the population). On the other hand, the Brave New World achieves stability voluntarily, via consumerism. What are three dead ends in the Brave New World?
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoStasis, loss of personal and collective initiative and creativity, and a dishonest mythology of consumerism as the limit of free choice. There are probably more, but those are the obvious ones.
- 082349872349872 6y agoStasis is interesting. First, it makes sense that if they are in a local utilitarian optimum, they won't be changing much. Secondly, IIRC, Mond states they have plenty of inventions they haven't deployed, based on A/B testing. Not only does that imply people doing creative work inventing, but also that the status quo is not a static quo, and they'll happily introduce, say, new technically-complex pasttimes, as long as they clearly improve the metrics they're measuring. (I'll reread the book later today or tomorrow to see if memory serves. I don't think I've read it in this century.) For personal and collective initiative and creativity, not only does someone have to write the feelies in the orthodox world, there are always the islands for people with too much initiative: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23513002 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23513002 (Island life sounds a bit like Dante's first circle. The savage deliberately chooses not to go there. I think it a poor choice, but then again, if I had been Zhivago, I would emigrated to Paris with Tonya, saving a good deal of trouble.) As far as consumerism goes, I will just remind you that we are discussing in the clear on an anglophone forum. Aren't we all supposed to line up behind the Washington Consensus that consumerism is the key to prosperity?
- 6y ago
- yyyk 6y ago>Brave New World is a utopian novel desperately trying to appear dystopic. With just a few small changes, to account for the existence of automation/robots/computers, the darker aspects (e.g. the population of deltas) stop being plausible within the universe. Others commented on the 'utopia' part, I'll just note that your observation was accounted for. Already in the novel it was noted that reducing working hours was trivial, well within the capacity of the powers that be. It wasn't done because deltas did not want it. The speaker might have been biased on that last part* , but should be well-informed on the first given his high-ranking position. * It could be that the speaker did not asses delta desires correctly, or that the actual reason involved social stability.
- 082349872349872 6y agoCh. 16 > "Technically, it would be perfectly simple to reduce all lower-caste working hours to three or four a day. But would they be any the happier for that? No, they wouldn't. The experiment was tried, more than a century and a half ago. The whole of Ireland was put on to the four-hour day. What was the result? Unrest and a large increase in the consumption of soma; that was all. Those three and a half hours of extra leisure were so far from being a source of happiness, that people felt constrained to take a holiday from them." (Note the implicit english attitude to ireland, or compare some of our current deltas' attitudes to quarantine.)
- msla 6y agoI like Adam Cadre's review of Brave New World because he broadly agrees with you: The book is by a grouchy reactionary trying to paint the great big social movements of the 1920s as being utterly horrible, and who never realizes that a good number of the things he's describing are desirable. http://adamcadre.ac/calendar/14/14432.html http://adamcadre.ac/calendar/14/14432.html It's of some interest that both Nineteen Eighty-Four (the novel uses the spelled-out version) and Brave New World are fairly transparent takes on the USSR, just at different periods: Brave New World was the socially revolutionary USSR of the 1920s, whereas Nineteen Eighty-Four was the USSR of the 1930s and 1940s, once Stalin had consolidated power and begun the Terror. (Yes, Brave New World is also about the utter horrors of consumerism. Books can be about more than one thing, especially if the author has a lot to say and a whole novel's worth of didactic authorial mouthpieces to use to to beat it into your skull.)
- scottlocklin 6y agoHumans as soulless automatons, grown in test tubes, segmented into castes, given happy pills and sex0rz for social control was specifically meant as a parody of the "utopian" views of assclowns like HG Wells and the other 19th century socialist weirdos in the Bloomsbury group. It is, of course, the dystopia we most obviously inhabit in the West. Fear not; tiring of it, it appears we're going to try Orwell's dystopia next.
- perl4ever 6y agoFrom "War-time Diary, 1942" by Orwell: "[27 March] Crocuses now full out. One seems to catch glimpses of them dimly through a haze of war news. Abusive letter from H.G. Wells, who addresses me as 'you shit', among other things. The Vatican is exchanging diplomatic representatives with Tokyo. The Vatican now has diplomatic relations with all the Axis powers and - I think - with none of the Allies. A bad sign and yet in a sense a good one, in that this last step means they have now definitely decided that the Axis and not we stands for the more reactionary policy."