4 ms·
Like most Scott Manley videos, it's a great video, but it's out of date. That video basically mentions three things: fairing size, vertical integration and th
by bryanlarsen 6y ago
Like most Scott Manley videos, it's a great video, but it's out of date.
That video basically mentions three things: fairing size, vertical integration and the fact that SpaceX's rockets in reusable mode don't lift as much as competitors. This contract pays SpaceX to fix the first two issues and the third can be solved by using the SpaceX rocket in expendable mode.
- simonh 6y agoAnd of course even reusable rockets are eventually EOL, so that rocket in ‘expendable mode’ might have actually flown half a dozen missions beforehand.
- jccooper 6y agoULA maintains a couple of technological advantages; they have some unique insertion steering and their hydrogen upper stage is particularly well-suited for Earth-escape missions. However, SpaceX insertion is good enough for nearly every mission and they can make up for upper stage efficiency with brute force via Falcon Heavy--at a similar or better price point. They also have a few paperwork advantages. Their vehicles have nuclear ratings, though SpaceX can certainly get that any time they want now. And they have demonstrated high reliability, which is important for uninsured billion-dollar payloads. Though it's getting harder to argue against F9. An of course, they're owned by two major defense contractors with plenty of political clout. But: their main advantage now is that they exist and are in the US and The Customer wants to maintain multiple options. Once Blue Origin comes online ULA's going to lose that one too, and will have to either figure out a way to make Vulcan price competitive, go on a crash course to develop a new competitive rocket (for which they're already too late), or lean on their relationship advantages and existing contracts to hang on for a while until at some point reality finally overcomes politics. There's a lot of moving parts but they're not moving in a direction favorable to ULA, and given how hamstrung they are by their ownership structure I'd lean towards that last one.
- AtlasBarfed 6y agoOr they get bought by another company in another country that wants launch capability. Space force will spark an arms race, be it a sprint or a marathon