4 ms·
There are differences in the ULA and SpaceX launch options. There is far more to spacelaunch than cost per kilo to orbit. One of the big issues is that SpaceX
by sandworm101 6y ago
There are differences in the ULA and SpaceX launch options. There is far more to spacelaunch than cost per kilo to orbit.
One of the big issues is that SpaceX doesn't do vertical payload integration. It's upper stage options are also very different than those of ULA. For many sats that isn't an issue, for some military sats it is a very big deal. When the payload is worth many times as much as the rocket, with incalculable trickledown impacts should its launch not go perfectly, your choice of rocket has to tick absolutely every box.
- Tuna-Fish 6y agoParticipation in the second NSSL requires vertical payload integration. SpaceX had to promise to be able to do it to submit a bid. They have never done it so far, but they will definitely do it in the near future.
- tomatoman 6y agoWhat is vertical payload integration?
- JshWright 6y agoWith rockets like the Atlas 5 (flown by ULA), the rocket is assembled vertically in a tall "hanger", and is then rolled out to the launch pad, remaining in the vertical position. The Falcon 9 is assembled rolled out to the pad horizontally, then it raised into the vertical position in preparation for launch. It can be more complicated to design satellites (esp satellites that have large optics in them) to deal with gravity in two different orientations. Atlas 5 "roll out": https://spaceflightnow.com/2020/07/28/photos-atlas-5-rolled-out-to-launch-pad-with-nasas-perseverance-mars-rover/ https://spaceflightnow.com/2020/07/28/photos-atlas-5-rolled-... Falcon 9: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TYJuHuhPxGU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TYJuHuhPxGU Bonus video, Smarter Every Day chatting w/ the CEO of ULA while watching a Delta IV Heavy roll out to the launch pad: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OdPoVi_h0r0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OdPoVi_h0r0
- sandworm101 6y agoComplicated and less weight-efficient. Designing a structure for gravity/g/force in one axis is wasteful enough. That strength is useless once in space. Horizontal integration means the structure must be strong in two axis: double waste. It might not matter when you are launching cubesats, but in a spy satellite the size/weight of a bus that extra reinforcement means sacrifices in many other areas.
- avmich 6y agoBut it's more economical, money-wise, as Russian launchers history shows. In general, American rocket school tends to have better mass efficiency but less economical efficiency that Russian rocket school. "When he wants more thrust, Ivan doesn't look for a fancy propellant with a higher specific impulse. He just builds himself a bigger rocket. Maybe he's got something there." - J. Clark, Ignition! https://library.sciencemadness.org/library/books/ignition.pdf https://library.sciencemadness.org/library/books/ignition.pd...
- dnautics 6y ago> When he wants more thrust, Ivan doesn't look for a fancy propellant with a higher specific impulse. He just builds himself a bigger rocket On the other hand the Soviet Union did develop syntin... (also from Ignition!)
- avmich 6y agoOf course the point was that one can use simple and crude solutions, or effective and sophisticated ones. Another example would be that in Russian rocket engines pumps tend to be put on the same axis as the turbine, so frequencies of turbine and pumps are the same and some of them can be non-optimal. In American tradition one uses gears, which makes both turbine and pumps (more) optimal, for the cost of gear mechanism. Practice shows that both approaches can work, but, just as with vertical assembly, which requires a tall building or a vertical transportation of a rocket, some ways look simpler than others. Simpler not necessarily better - but in rocket assembly it's probably cheaper to do it horizontally.
- wwwwwwwww 6y agoULA basically built a portable clean room around the tip of the vertical rocket, to put the payload on top. Because the rover has to be free of earth organisms.
- thinkcontext 6y agoSpaceX is getting money to do vertical integration for this contract.
- sandworm101 6y agoYa, but they haven't done it yet. When you are organizing launch contracts for billion-dollar spy satellites you only ever go with people who have done things a few times before.
- thinkcontext 6y agoLike the Vulcan rocket which has never flown?
- valuearb 6y agoHas ULA ever designed a new rocket?
- simonh 6y agoULA is just a consortium of Lockheed and a Boeing, so ‘technically’ no, but in practice the actual people and facilities have, yes.
- valuearb 6y agoThe Delta IV and Atlas V were developed twenty years ago. Given turnover and the new management structure, lots of those people are gone or not in the same roles.
- jccooper 6y agoULA has designed and is building the Vulkan rocket now. Presumably they have some staff that were involved with the Atlas V and Delta IV back when they were with their parent companies.
- valuearb 6y ago