3 ms·
Real name policies may (or may not) foster civil discourse, but they do so in a way that favors the already privileged. It's a burden for marginalized people a
by DoreenMichele 6y ago
Real name policies may (or may not) foster civil discourse, but they do so in a way that favors the already privileged.
It's a burden for marginalized people and a barrier to them resolving their issues.
I was molested as a child and women generally tend to have less agency over their lives than men. When I first got online, I used my real first name and last name. I eventually moved to middle name and place as my default semi anonymous handle for privacy reasons because my first name plus last name is so distinctive. I'm back to using my full name online, though my handle in most places is first name plus middle name.
It was a long journey of getting there. It included a divorce, figuring out how to talk publicly -- which I think men tend to get inculcated with early and women don't -- and assorted other factors.
The perfect is the enemy of the good. If you only want civil discourse in your space and that's all that matters to you, you can achieve that by limiting it to very privileged people with no serious personal problems. Insisting on real names is a polite means to exclude anyone for whom speaking publicly under their real name might be a problem, so I'm sure it can help keep things superficially civil in your little corner of the universe.
I am also sure it helps further narrow the lives of people with already narrow existences by ever so politely silencing them online in ways they are already silenced offline. Which isn't actually all that kind, imo.
- tachyonbeam 6y agoI think that boys are encouraged to express their opinion from a younger age as a "show of strength". As a young man, you're supposed to be strong enough to withstand disagreement and occasional social shaming. The pressure for girls is the opposite, be more like the others, don't stand out. No doubt that people make assumptions about you if you make it known you are a woman online, but, I it's not necessarily just about privilege in the social justice sense. I am a minority, and I am very uncomfortable with identity politics, but I know I have to be careful with that I say online, because my current and future employers might be watching. Forcing people to use their real names will favor discourse that's more mainstream, that fits in the overton window[0]. Anyone can be bullied online if they disagree with the mainstream, whether they use a nickname or their real name, but if your real-world identity is known, that bullying can translate into the real world, you could lose your job, etc. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overton_window https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overton_window
- DoreenMichele 6y agoI'm plenty opinionated and I've always been comfortable expressing my opinion. It gets perceived differently than when men do the same and people react differently to a woman doing it. I had other issues rooted in being female. I've concluded that the world typically teaches boys from an early age how to have a public reputation and public relations and girls generally don't get the same info to the same degree. It becomes a self reinforcing problem because a woman behaving "normally" is behaving in a way that is more appropriate for private spaces and personal relationships and the rest of the world will expect that of her. I've had a really hard time figuring out why I had such an extremely hard time interacting with the public. It took a long time to get any kind of handle on that.
- tachyonbeam 6y ago> I've concluded that the world typically teaches boys from an early age how to have a public reputation and public relations and girls generally don't get the same info to the same degree. That would be contrary to popular wisdom, which says that girls are taught to be much more social from an earlier age, and as such, they generally have a better understanding of social dynamics, whereas boys tend to be more socially obtuse. > I've had a really hard time figuring out why I had such an extremely hard time interacting with the public. It took a long time to get any kind of handle on that. Just my two cents but: just being different from the norm will often get you weird, unfriendly looks. From what I read in your discourse, I get the impression that it seems to you like boys have it easy/better, socially, but I can tell you, having been on the other side of the fence, that when boys are "out of line", they literally get beat up, repeatedly... And society somehow accepts this, "boys will be boys". Being opinionated is not always well-received, both for men and women. Generally, people like opinionated if those opinions are just reinforcing their own... I do agree that men can get away with being more opinionated in some situations, but I don't think it's just a free pass. It only works if you're at the top of the social hierarchy. Maybe this is where we are in agreement. Society has difficulty accepting women being opinionated because it has difficulty accepting women being at the top of the social hierarchy. To fix that, it helps to fix gender norms, but we should also strive to live in a society where everyone can express their opinion, not just those at the top of the hierarchy.
- andrei_says_ 6y agoThank you for this perspective. I’ve been reading Mike Monteiro’s Ruined by Design. In one of the chapters he points out how tech companies’ policies for the communities they create are set by “tech bros” - predominantly white privileged males, who have never experienced life as a poor person, or as a woman or as a person of color, or as a non-heteronormative person or a combination of the above. He quotes a conversation with a female designer friend of his, discussing twitter’s anti-abuse policies added a few years ago. She said that if there were any women on the team, Twitter would’ve never had launched without tools to solve abuse. But that problem never existed in the universe of the original decision makers.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- raywu 6y agoI am interested to hear more about Ruined by Design. I read the sample chapter on Uber on the website [0] after reading your comment. The author seems very biased against any sort of good that might come out of Uber. Is the entire narrative anti-VC and anti-SV and deems the issue a systemic problem, or does the author provide counterpoints and examples where good decisions are made and can be made? [0] https://www.ruinedby.design/sample-chapter https://www.ruinedby.design/sample-chapter