3 ms·
They are the same. Suppose you're the founder of your company. You sold a 40% stake to investors to raise capital to get started, but it's still 60% yours, so
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
They are the same.
Suppose you're the founder of your company. You sold a 40% stake to investors to raise capital to get started, but it's still 60% yours, so you have control of the company.
If you're required to liquidate your shares to pay the tax on them, you lose control of the company -- which in turn could cause the stock to crash because investors trust the founder more than the random MBA they can expect mutual funds to install.
And stocks can be volatile. If the company is worth $50B in June, $100B in December and then $50B again in January, did the owner ever really have that much wealth? Do they get the money back from the government next year? Do they get the shares back?
Meanwhile nobody is even bothering to do the math on this from the perspective of the government. Because the government can borrow money at close to 0% interest, while index funds have been giving >4% average annual returns, which means taking the money today instead of borrowing it today and taking it whenever they actually sell the shares (including the share appreciation in the meantime) would require the other taxpayers to pay more to make up for the loss of government revenue that would cause.