3 ms·
That would be consistent with it originating somewhere now submerged, then carried by the refugees to wherever they fetched up. I was astonished to learn that
by ncmncm 6y ago
That would be consistent with it originating somewhere now submerged, then carried by the refugees to wherever they fetched up.
I was astonished to learn that wheat was farmed in China for thousands of years before they took up rice.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoNope. The date of origination in all these places and the very different type of agriculture in each location argues strongly against "carried by refugees". Just consider the rather immense period of time between whenever the Americas were settled (currently looking like at least 30k years ago) and the emergence of agriculture.
- ncmncm 6y agoThat period without actually argues for a common origin. The places we know started around 10-12 thousand years ago. The idea of doing it at all, like the idea of writing language at all, is more important than the local details. But the New Guinea highlands do appear to have invented agriculture, in isolation, 7000 years ago. We don't know when agriculture in the Amazon basin started, just that it was much, much longer ago than anyone had imagined. The entire Amazon was a manicured garden when the Spanish got there. Then smallpox wiped it off the map.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoMaybe I'm being dense, but given that you had effectively isolated populations in the Americas by the time agriculture was discovered/invented/developed there, and it wasn't a generation or two since they were last "connected" to any possible common origin, I don't see how this supports the idea of a common origin. Unless you're arguing that they actually were not isolated, and there was already cultural exchange going on between other continent's populations and those in the Americas.
- ncmncm 6y agoJust that you can't rule out things you don't know anything about. Archaeologists nowadays enforce a rule where anything they don't have firm evidence about must be absolutely assumed not to exist. But that's not science, and we have no need to toe that line. 12,000 years ago there were very different kinds of technology at different places. We are certain that Australia and New Guinea (at the time, a continent joined by the now submerged Sahul region) was settled by boat across open sea. The entire Pacific rim, from New Guinea to Chile, could have been connected by boat traffic operated by a now-vanished seafaring culture, with any remaining evidence now deep under water. Thousands of years is enough time for a very great deal to happen, and then the artifacts rot. Absent evidence, there is no certainty. Maybe ideas arose independently all around the same time period entirely by accident, and maybe they didn't. But generally it is unwise to insist that simultaneous parallel events are entirely independent when there is possibility of contact.