3 ms·
Exactly. I was talking to people at the IETF about this last year. One person said the ideal use of the IETF (and RFC process) is to take situations when multi
by josephg 6y ago
Exactly.
I was talking to people at the IETF about this last year. One person said the ideal use of the IETF (and RFC process) is to take situations when multiple companies have solved the same problem. The IETF puts everyone in a room (/mailing list) together and lets us collectively figure out a single interoperable protocol that all the members can implement in order to make their systems compatible.
The golden path isn't "Joe blogs needs a protocol for something so he writes an RFC". Its "Joe need a protocol. He writes his own and iterates on it. Later he meets Sarah and Dave who've all written similar protocols to solve the same problem at their own organizations. Together they approach the IETF and form a working group to discuss a standard."
Reality is usually much more messy than this; but generally the IETF should never be a bottleneck for people who want to write code and try things out. Racing ahead of whats written in RFCs doesn't stand in opposition to the RFC process. The opposite - racing ahead is a necessary part of the process, because we need collective experience in how to solve a problem in order to write good standards.