3 ms·
I think his point is you can't compare the impact of the flu because 1) it hits every year (versus a quick outbreak) and 2) many people are vaccinated. Don't f
by refurb 6y ago
I think his point is you can't compare the impact of the flu because 1) it hits every year (versus a quick outbreak) and 2) many people are vaccinated.
Don't forget the '17 flu seasons was 65k deaths in the US. So we're at a little under 3x right now. So yes, Covid is worse, but we don't bat an eye at 65k deaths due to the flu.
- HarryHirsch 6y agoConsider that recovery from coronaplague is lengthy and that a good amount of those discharged form hospital are looking at permanently reduced lung function. Death isn't the best metric here.
- Marsymars 6y agoI hear this a lot, but I've never seen this claim put in context of a comparison to lung function following viral pneumonia from viruses other than SARS-CoV-2.
- 8note 6y agoYeah, I've only hear about it as a typical result of pneumonia
- HarryHirsch 6y agoYes, but severe pneumonia is what sends COVID patients to hospital. It's a frequent complication, much more frequent than in the annual flu.
- giantDinosaur 6y agoHow many? I'm all for some variant of the precautionary principle, but we should be getting better data about long(er) term effects now that this has been ongoing for 6+ months. Can you put some actual concrete numbers to this?
- _-___________-_ 6y ago> recovery from coronaplague is lengthy This is simply not true in general. The vast majority of people who come down with covid have a minor illness, and many of them do not even realise what it was. I have three friends who had positive tests and no symptoms beyond those of the common cold. All of the available data supports this being the normal case, and serious complications being either a rare case of bad luck, or a result of underlying illnesses. > a good amount of those discharged form hospital are looking at permanently reduced lung function If you have any respiratory infection serious enough to put you in the hospital, you're probably looking at a longer recovery and possibly at long-term reduced lung function. But the relatively young & healthy mostly don't end up in hospital with covid, just as they don't end up in hospital when they get the flu. Selecting only the most serious cases (hospital admissions) and talking about their outcomes is not useful for drawing general conclusions about the pandemic or the way countries have chosen to respond to it.
- bsder 6y ago> So yes, Covid is worse, but we don't bat an eye at 65k deaths due to the flu. 1) Only as long as they are old people. The moment flu kills even a couple children, everybody goes apoplectic. 2) I suspect that one of the takeaways from Covid is going to be that viruses (even flu) cause a lot more long-term damage than we give them credit for. Nobody was funding brain or circulatory scans for flu patients--we're going to get some of that data as a side benefit of all the Covid analysis.
- refurb 6y agoDuring the 2017-2018 flu season, an estimated 115 children under 4 years old died. And almost 700 if you count those under 18.[1] That's more than I've seen reported for Covid so far. And the flu certainly can cause long-term damage. "Other possible serious complications triggered by flu can include inflammation of the heart (myocarditis), brain (encephalitis) or muscle (myositis, rhabdomyolysis) tissues, and multi-organ failure (for example, respiratory and kidney failure). Flu virus infection of the respiratory tract can trigger an extreme inflammatory response in the body and can lead to sepsis, the body’s life-threatening response to infection."[2] [1]https://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/burden/2017-2018.htm https://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/burden/2017-2018.htm [2]https://www.cdc.gov/flu/symptoms/symptoms.htm#complications https://www.cdc.gov/flu/symptoms/symptoms.htm#complications
- xvilka 6y agoThey are not only bad. Viruses are also an important part of our evolution, way more important than bacteria. So it's bad and good at the same time.
- foogazi 6y ago> Don't forget the '17 flu seasons was 65k deaths in the US. So we're at a little under 3x right now. So yes, Covid is worse, but we don't bat an eye at 65k deaths due to the flu. How can we compare Covid numbers to the flu when the US has gone into lockdown, schools closed, everyone that can is WFH. No concerts or sporting events totally different circumstances Sweden might be a more accurate comparison since they didn’t go into full lockdown and it’s at 10x
- hombre_fatal 6y agoThe other thing to consider about influenza is that it ravaged us for millennia until fairly recently.
- alyx 6y agoPull the flu/influenza death numbers from the CDC for the last decade. I dare you. In the last ten years we (in the US) have lost +500,000 people to the flu. For some reason the people that died from the flu must be lesser in value because nobody did anything about it. You would think that a single year of 65k deaths would be enough for everybody to wear masks the following flu season. And yet? No economic shutdowns. No masks. No restrictions on schools. Literally nothing other than vaccines that mostly don’t work.
- evan_ 6y agoWith shutdowns, masks, and closed schools, COVID has killed in six months about a quarter of the people who die from the flu in a decade How is that an argument for less-drastic measures?
- _-___________-_ 6y agoThe comparison is fraught with problems due to the lack of immunity for COVID. The "with shutdowns, masks and closed schools" line also assumes the effectiveness of all those measures, and ignores the glaring problem that they simply kick the can down the road -- there is no appetite for shutdowns and closed schools until the end of 2021, but a vaccine could easily take that long (if not longer) to be generally available -- assuming any of the current vaccine candidates work well. So what, exactly, is the plan?
- DanBC 6y agoYou're counting flu and covid-19 deaths differently. For flu you're using sophisticated statistical modelling of excess death combined with community surveillance of use of primary and secondary care. This will tend to overcount. For covid-19 you're using "died after testing positive for covid, or with covid mentioned as the cause on the death certificate". This will tend to undercount (even when taking into account the slight overcount involved in people who die from other things after a +ve test).
- firecall 6y agoIf you read to the end, he claims Covid-19 isn't worse. I think this so called Doctor is just trying to push a narrative and links to no research or sources for any of his assumptions or data. This article has no credibility.