5 ms·
Maybe I'm missing a subtlety of your meaning here (how appropriate) but I know that philosophers have discussed such things for centuries; e.g. 2 grains of sand
by aidenn0 6y ago
Maybe I'm missing a subtlety of your meaning here (how appropriate) but I know that philosophers have discussed such things for centuries; e.g. 2 grains of sand is not a pile, 1000 grains is, but where is the transition?
- dragonwriter 6y agoFuzzy logic in the broad sense (not necessarily the logic of the Zadeh operators, for instance) seems to provide the best answer: there is no crisp transition; membership is real-valued, not binary.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- skybrian 6y agoMost of it isn't new, but David Chapman is better at explaining nebulosity and putting it into perspective than anyone I know, so I recommend reading more of his stuff.
- FeepingCreature 6y agoSo much effort wasted based on trying to derive fundamental meaning from coincident attributes of our brains' neurological implementation of abstract concepts. "The transition is wherever your 'pile' classifier neuron fires."
- wizzwizz4 6y agoI think that's a little too reductionist – in that I'm not sure that there is one neuron responsible for pile classification in that way. But as a metaphor, it's a very good sentiment.
- FeepingCreature 6y agoRight, yeah. Not saying this is literally an actual single neuron, but the point holds.
- aidenn0 6y agoI think you are selling at least some of the philosophers short. What is a pile and isn't a pile is not entirely subjective (i.e. we all agree that 1 grain of sand is not a pile), nor is it entirely objective (in the sense that different people will probably draw the line at different places). On top of that, the transition even for a single individual is not abrupt. Understanding and dissecting these sorts of ambiguities with something as inoffensive as piles of sand can be useful for better understanding disagreement that stems from ambiguity when things are more contentious.
- FeepingCreature 6y agoYeah but those properties are exactly what you would expect from imitation learned fuzzy neuronal classifiers. As such, they have no deeper meaning than saying "does the fact that the deep learning model thinks this traffic cone is a penguin reveal to us a deep truth about traffic cones and penguins?" No.. It just used some shortcut feature that's not universally applicable. Just like us. The heap classifier works to tell that obvious heaps are heaps. It works to tell that single items are not heaps. In between, there is no meaning but noise.