9 ms·
When Google starts to have any inclination to put a bag over my head if I search the wrong thing, sure. When Google starts having an interest in being able to
by MattGaiser 6y ago
When Google starts to have any inclination to put a bag over my head if I search the wrong thing, sure.
When Google starts having an interest in being able to blackmail people to get them to spy on their country or give up IP, then sure.
When the US Government can unilaterally demand security cooperation from Google in any way, shape, or form like the Chinese government can, then sure.
When the tech companies actually start censoring aggressively and hunting people down(rather than just removing enough to satisfy angry people), then sure.
One problem is the data. The other (larger) problem is how each controlling entity wants to use the data.
Google wants to sell ads. They don’t care about your porn preferences, whether you have a mistress, or whether you do drugs. Maybe the ads approach is obnoxious, but that is all it is. They want to sell stuff, not take over the world.
The Government of China wants power. They want influence. They want information. They want control. And no Chinese company is allowed to refuse its pursuit of those.
And even if both countries required the same absolute cooperation from their tech companies, governments In the West are very limited in their ability to take the kind of actions against their citizens that the Government of China can.
The US Government isn’t even allowed to tax a newspaper excessively, yet alone throw the editor in jail for running critical content.
- xvector 6y agoComments like this demonstrate a severe lack of understanding around how intelligence today in the US works, especially in a post-Snowden world. Our government routinely performs dystopian forced mass-surveillance of citizens accompanied by gag orders. > When Google starts to have any inclination to put a bag over my head if I search the wrong thing, sure. > When Google starts having an interest in being able to blackmail people to get them to spy on their country or give up IP, then sure. The CCP could have all the data they want on you but there is almost nothing they can do about it because an ocean and a military separates you, outside some fringe cases. The NSA, however, can and will use data they collect on you against you. The US government is no stranger to this, where COINTELPRO [1] used the results of domestic spying to try to put an early end to MLK and the Civil Rights Movement. The US has caused demonstrable harm to citizens via surveillance yet you seem to support it compared to the less dangerous alternative out of some misplaced sense of patriotism. > When the US Government can unilaterally demand security cooperation from Google in any way, shape, or form like the Chinese government can, then sure. Have you not heard of PRISM? The NSA? National Security Letters? The US routinely can and does force companies to give up information on citizens in the form of dragnet surveillance. One way to do this is a National Security Letter [2]. > Google wants to sell ads. They don’t care about your porn preferences, whether you have a mistress, or whether you do drugs And neither does the CCP. Neither does the NSA, actually, unless they want something from you and to force you to do something. > The Government of China wants power. They want influence. They want information. They want control. And no Chinese company is allowed to refuse its pursuit of those. Welcome to participating on a global scale. The US isn't the only country allowed to be a superpower. It's probably not good if China surpasses the US, but the US also doesn't have anywhere close to the moral high ground w.r.t. domestic surveillance as you mention. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COINTELPRO https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COINTELPRO [2]: https://www.eff.org/issues/national-security-letters https://www.eff.org/issues/national-security-letters
- diryawish 6y agoThe US absolutely has the moral high ground compared to any communist country and it’s not even fucking close.
- sacredcows 6y agoTake care of the education of your poorest citizens, stop orchestrating coups, stop imprisoning black men en masse, give people single-payer healthcare. Then we can talk about moral high ground.
- sidlls 6y agoWhile bad, not one of these rises to the level of genocide and oppression that form the core of China's tactics to control its population and exert influence abroad, and, yes, that does mean from a moral perspective the US is better. "Terrible" is still better than "inhumane".
- emptysongglass 6y agoI'm really sick of this. The Verge's article [1] is the yardstick for just how far America's own self-hatred will go. To compare the present genocide of an entire culture to America's sins, right now, would be laughable but that so many Americans have bought wholesale into its fantasy. If you were to gather up the prison industrial complex and the tens of thousands failed by privatized healthcare, it would be a drop in the bucket. The CCP's orchestrated intent to scrub out 2 peoples and their religions from the face of the earth on their way to a 3rd complete, divisible nation (Taiwan) has not been seen since Nazi Germany. This is the scale of atrocity and disrespect for the basic right of a human being to say, "I am who I am", we are dealing with at this very moment in human history. Please, please, consider that however tough things are in the US for very many people, it can change with a vote. That is a democracy, however broken and fragile. [1] https://www.theverge.com/21355465/tiktok-us-china-information-nationalism-online-propaganda https://www.theverge.com/21355465/tiktok-us-china-informatio...
- 6y ago
- boomboomsubban 6y ago>When Google starts to have any inclination to put a bag over my head if I search the wrong thing, sure Google based information is probably part of the Disposition Matrix, though that's unlikely to end with just a bag over your head. >When Google starts having an interest in being able to blackmail people to get them to spy on their country or give up IP, then sure. So what do you think of something like Elon Musk openly admitting to furthering a coup to secure resources? Is it only a problem with intellectual property? >When the US Government can unilaterally demand security cooperation from Google in any way, shape, or form like the Chinese government can, then sure. This isn't the case?
- gentleman11 6y agoElon musk furthered a coup? Any references to that?
- longhairedhippy 6y agoNot the op but I'm betting they're referring to this: https://www.newsbreak.com/news/1607170043110/united-tesla-company-widespread-condemnation-of-elon-musks-bolivia-coup-comments https://www.newsbreak.com/news/1607170043110/united-tesla-co...
- sidlls 6y ago> Google based information is probably part of the Disposition Matrix, though that's unlikely to end with just a bag over your head. While bad, this isn't remotely the same either in scope or scale as China's similar issues. In the US you end up in this matrix if you're perceived to be a legitimate, real, prone-to-violent-acts threat. In China you end up in their "disposition matrix" if you say anything negative about anyone in favor. > So what do you think of something like Elon Musk openly admitting to furthering a coup to secure resources? Is it only a problem with intellectual property? What makes you believe Musk? > This isn't the case? No, it isn't. At least nominally some kind of additional oversight, e.g., via a FISA warrant, is required. Now, none of the above is meant to imply that operatives and agencies adhere to the rules 100% of the time. They do serve to mark a distinct, clear difference between the US and China, though, because at least in the US if/when these agencies and operatives are caught there are legal repercussions to face. In China there aren't any because these agencies and operatives' actions would just be standard operating procedure. It makes a difference.
- gentleman11 6y ago> When Google starts to have any inclination to put a bag over my head if I search the wrong thing, sure Google actually did attempt to participate in that via Project Dragonfly. Users searches would be correlated to their ids and sent to the government, which is actively surveilling people in order to decide who to suppress. Many of these are minorities who end up with bags over their heads in those concentration camp drone videos. The employees revolted so strongly the project was cancelled. > When the US Government can unilaterally demand security cooperation from Google in any way, shape, or form like the Chinese government can, then sure Tech companies sometimes sue to be allowed to disclose the secret requests that are made of them. Since 9/11, it’s been a lot harder to say no
- plusCubed 6y ago> The employees revolted so strongly the project was cancelled. Exactly - the buck stopped at company leadership beholden to internal/public reputation, rather than a central authoritarian government with the power to make you disappear.
- skummetmaelk 6y agoIn a non democratic system citizens can revolt peacefully against such policies. A company is hardly better. Google could have decided to let the unhappy employees go. Most of them would probably have stayed and wiped their tears with their comp anyway.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoThe threat in the US is not from the government, it is from the private sector. The issue is not what Google wants to do using access to your personal data (sell ads), it is what Google's customers (not users) want to do with access to your personal data. Government is supposed to keep the private sector honest, so to speak. With weak government, and a private sector with single entities that have more data about citizens than government, the risk is arguably greater. There are reasonable limits placed on government in the US, but those limits do not apply to the private sector. Comparisons of China to the US make some sense when based on size, but if ignoring size, comparing the US to China on the issue of digital privacy and propaganda seems strange assuming one is trying to illustrate that the US is some sort of high benchmark. It is arguable there are other countries where citizens are enjoying greater digital privacy and more freedom from propaganda than in the US. It would seem to make more sense to compare the US to those countries.
- aripickar 6y agoGoogle’s customers want to serve you ads so they could buy your products. There’s nothing that they could do to you that is remotely on the scale of what Data Collection in China is capable of doing to you.
- skummetmaelk 6y agoBeing able to swing public sentiment by showing the right people the right set of "ads" carries a lot of power.
- cromwellian 6y agoHow about being able to swing public sentiment by a) funding a massive 50 cent army b) censoring any information the state does not want you to see c) jailing anyone who say the wrong thing with their data d) controlling pretty much your entire life through the social credit system You guys are drawing lots of false equivalences. Streamers in China have been 'disappeared' for weeks for offenses as harmless as singing the national anthem badly, or saying nice things about Taiwan. When tech companies start doing this, maybe we'll have an equivalence: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rbTXb6bEMfI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rbTXb6bEMfI
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoThat could be because in the US (and even more so in the UK) the biggest newspaper and media owner is more likely to own the government than the government is to own the newspapers and the media. As for demanding security cooperation: https://transparencyreport.google.com/user-data/us-national-security?hl=en https://transparencyreport.google.com/user-data/us-national-...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cblconfederate 6y agoTu quoque type of arguments are useless when you re the world's leading power (and want to keep being so)
- bassman9000 6y agoThey're not when to contender is a totalitarian dictatorship with proven disdain of human rights, and ever extending cyber-aspirations.
- justicezyx 6y ago> The Government of China wants power. They want influence. They want information. They want control. And no Chinese company is allowed to refuse its pursuit of those. I am not sure how this distinguish CCP from any other power nation's government, and warrants unlawful ban on a private company's APP.
- sidlls 6y agoThere is no such thing as a private company in China in this context, except in name only. The government is deeply enmeshed in these tech companies' products, from requiring real verified names to censorship and other draconian policies. The notion that there are big tech companies in China operating outside the CCP's influence is, charitably, naive.
- justicezyx 6y ago> The government is deeply enmeshed in these tech companies' products, from requiring real verified names to censorship and other draconian policies. This simply has no factual evidences, let me give you examples: One claims CCP install party committee in all companies, and those committee controls major personnel appointment, and other critical managerial activities, etc. As we inquired, there is no open report whatsoever about such powerful "committee"... The person then gave a link of a old USSR organization [2]. For all we know CCP is about as different than USSR than US is to USSR... As for the Chinese internet law [3], does not apply to company like TikTok, which explicitly does not allow mainlander to join the network. See [4], "Important: TikTok checks your cell’s SIM card at startup and if you are using a Chinese SIM it will block the access."; there is no way the company voluntarily to bend to a law that it has no obligation to comply... [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24016881 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24016881 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24018111 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24018111 [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/China_Internet_Security_Law#:~:text=This%20law%20was%20enacted%20by,on%20a%20company's%20network%20operations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/China_Internet_Security_Law#:~.... [4] https://www.saporedicina.com/english/access-tiktok-china/ https://www.saporedicina.com/english/access-tiktok-china/
- 6y ago
- notatoad 6y ago>When the US Government can unilaterally demand security cooperation from Google in any way, shape, or form like the Chinese government can, then sure. is this not exactly what a national security letter (NSL) is? the government can demand anything of a tech company, including that the company not tell anybody about it, as long as they claim it's for reasons of national security.
- MattGaiser 6y ago1. The request cannot include content. So your messages need a warrant. 2. The company can challenge it in court and have it reviewed. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_security_letter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_security_letter
- manquer 6y agoIn theory they can challenge in FISA court yes, FISA court has denied less than 0.1% of the warrant requests in 30+ year history. It is rubber stamp court. I am sure such rubber stamp processes exist in China as well. The fact you cannot even mention that you received a NSL forget the scope and nature of actual request, and entire secretive nature of the court proceedings and no plans to every unseal this data, canary declaration being the only way to even tell your customers. If I said this happened anywhere else you will say that country is repressive.
- mnm1 6y agoPlease provide examples of US citizens who have never been to China being abducted by the Chinese for searching the wrong thing. Or is this just your own delusion?
- afpx 6y agoI’ve had too many Chinese business contacts mysteriously “commit suicide” for it to be coincidental.
- mnm1 6y agoChinese contacts who have never been to China. Fascinating.
- fennecfoxen 6y agoSome introductory coverage of China's international kidnapping campaign, which affects foreign citizens, is available here: https://foreignpolicy.com/2018/03/29/the-disappeared-china-renditions-kidnapping/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2018/03/29/the-disappeared-china-r... "Oh," but you might be tempted say, "that wasn't just for a Google search! And many of those who are citizens elsewhere? Like the Chinese government, I don't believe that citizenship is valid." You will of course understand that the parent poster did not phrase the matter in those specific terms, and that in any event this is not a comfort. Google may have more of an opportunity, but Beijing has a stronger motive.
- mnm1 6y agoThese are all Chinese people the article is talking about. It's quite obvious that using Chinese apps as a Chinese person is dangerous. That's not what I asked about and certainly no reason to ban the app in America.
- fennecfoxen 6y agoahem > "OH," BUT YOU MIGHT BE TEMPTED SAY, "THAT WASN'T JUST FOR A GOOGLE SEARCH! AND MANY OF THOSE WHO ARE CITIZENS ELSEWHERE? LIKE THE CHINESE GOVERNMENT, I DON'T BELIEVE THAT CITIZENSHIP IS VALID." YOU WILL OF COURSE UNDERSTAND THAT THE PARENT POSTER DID NOT PHRASE THE MATTER IN THOSE SPECIFIC TERMS, AND THAT IN ANY EVENT THIS IS NOT A COMFORT. thank you
- cscurmudgeon 6y agoI am sure if the Internet were around during the Holocaust, people will fight against bringing it up by bringing up things like segregation, lynchings etc. in the US (definitely huge problems and evil, but nowhere as evil or large scale as the holocaust).
- DarthGhandi 6y agoWhy wouldn't they bring up the war crimes and unrestrained murder of civilians instead? People seem to have a very romanticised view of the allies. We were the victors so we gloss over the horrors committed by our own hands. Civilian causalities in Germany and Japan was about 12 million people. 6 million died in the Holocaust.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 6y agoOk? And America and most of Europe and Russia would have very much liked to not ever have a second world war at all. Russia lost over 16 million of their own people ffs.
- sirmoveon 6y agoMy shit don't stink kinda argument. The majority of the arguments defending the US by comparison, to me comes as propaganda. If you are a patriot American you should be using the Chinesse situation as leverage to get better accountability and transparency from the gov instead of trying to point out how other governmnets are just worst.
- amurthy1 6y agoSure but the title of the article is saying one is worse than the other, so it's fair to refute that. No one is arguing the US situation is perfect and we shouldn't also seek to make that better.
- fennecfoxen 6y agoLook, there's a reason China gets the brunt of our ire, and it's not because US based companies are particularly laudable. It's more that China is notorious for its international campaigns to infiltrate foreign institutions, surveil its diaspora, its dissidents, and its political enemies, and use tools like blackmail and threats to apply pressure, using any means possible, to achieve its policy goals, often on foreign soil. China is also noted for its campaigns of systematic repression. When you are in the business of rounding up an ethnic minority for genocide, it does tends to color the discussion. You can arrange words that make the US and China sound morally equivalent, but when you actually look into it to compare the realities in detail, you see how vapid and empty this approach is.
- sirmoveon 6y agoYes, yes. CCP China very bad. But US bunch of hypocrites, historically speaking. In my opinion, this is a great opportunity for the world to use the situation as leverage to keep them both accountable, rather than defend one over the other.
- newen 6y agoThe US does all of these things. Remember the CIA? One million Iraqis killed by the US. What is that if not genocide. Currently, civilians are being killed by the US every day with their bombings. More civilians being killed every day by their sanctions. It’s genocide.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> When the tech companies actually start censoring aggressively and hunting people down(rather than just removing enough to satisfy angry people), then sure. You don't need the qualifier here. "Just removing enough to satisfy angry people" is mob rule, and is genuinely problematic, even if it's not on the same level as dissidents getting bags over their heads.
- yibg 6y agoI’m less worried about google and the US governments influence on people in the US and more worried about the pervasive data collection combined with us government action in people outside the US and not protected by the same laws. The US government is pretty constrained inside its borders, it’s definitely not constrained outside.
- xg15 6y agoYes, and when any of that happens, you can present your rightful indignation, but this will be rather useless because it will be too late to do anything meaningful to change course.
- dang 6y agoPlease don't post rhetorical rants to HN. They don't fit with curious conversation, which is what we want here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html