3 ms·
It's an interesting question. Rowling doesn't "need" to be so prominently wrong on trans matters. She's got nothing to defend. Harry Potter isn't an especially
by jfengel 6y ago
It's an interesting question. Rowling doesn't "need" to be so prominently wrong on trans matters. She's got nothing to defend. Harry Potter isn't an especially enlightened work when it comes to gender, but I've always imagined that she thought of it as reasonably progressive for its time and audience.
As a feminist of roughly Rowling's age, I do see the way the visibility of trans issues have called into question some of the things I used to believe. There seems to be an essential aspect of gender that I had dismissed as purely socially constructed -- only it's somewhere in the brain, not in the genitals. It's important to acknowledge people's true gender, rather than trying to dismiss it as a mere artifact of society.
I could imagine that being a difficult shift to make. That comes from a different place as old-school patriarchy. The article is absolutely right that, having staked out a position, people will prominently "weaponize ignorance" to defend it.
But I'm still unclear on exactly where Rowling is coming from. She seems to be fighting something that just doesn't benefit her. If she thinks she's still working for feminism along 1970s principles, she's alienating a lot of allies. Even if she were right, she would clearly need to listen more if so many people she admires are opposed.