6 ms·
What perverse incentive is that? We are at ridiculously high unemployment numbers, so whether people are "incentivized" to work or not doesn't mean much.
by epistasis 6y ago
What perverse incentive is that?
We are at ridiculously high unemployment numbers, so whether people are "incentivized" to work or not doesn't mean much.
- pwinnski 6y agoThere seem to be perverse incentives at play in several states, pushing them to re-open even as cases and weekly deaths rise, seemingly with the primary purpose to getting people off state unemployment rolls. Not sure it's the right term to use for people, since as you say, the jobs aren't there. But for state governments, for sure.
- slg 6y agoI think a lot of people envision workers being given a choice to go back to work or stay on unemployment, but that is seldom a choice. You can't legally turn down your old job and stay on unemployment (at least in every state of which I'm aware, but every state's unemployment system is slightly different). Certainly there will be some people who do it, but you would basically have to commit fraud to do it. This causes the states' perverse incentives that you mentioned. Many people believe a big push to reopen has been motivated by states trying to get people off unemployment as they know some workers would rather stay safe at home and lose unemployment benefits than return to work in an unsafe environment.
- abfan1127 6y agoI know a ton of employees who have declined employment because of unemployment paying better. If Employers rat out these employees, then they come back angry. its a nasty spot to be in.
- slg 6y agoLike I said: >Certainly there will be some people who do it, but you would basically have to commit fraud to do it. Also the extra unemployment benefits expired so anyone still doing this is not making more than they would at their job. Their only incentive to continue this fraud is for their own personal safety. You can't call a preference for one's own personal safety "perverse".
- abfan1127 6y agoWhile it wasn't my statement, I think its perverse as the "free money" distorted those employees from making "normal decisions". For those employees, its a perfectly reasonable (short term) decision to prefer the larger payout. I'd argue its a bad long term decision.
- slg 6y agoThe money isn't "free" if you have to commit fraud to get it. I get that the temporary boost in benefits skewed the incentives a little bit more towards committing unemployment fraud and that might have been enough to sway some people who wouldn't do it under "normal" circumstances, but unemployment fraud is not a new option and this incentive to commit fraud has always existed.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- adamsea 6y agoI wonder if that says more about the employer than anything else.
- abfan1127 6y agowhat would it say about employers? They don't want to jeopardize relations, but they need employees back... I personally know small mom/pop restaurants, a small private security (rent-a-cop) firm, and a large casino that can't get people to come back because the $600/week bonus. These aren't 6 figure engineering jobs. these are low skill jobs where the most important skill is showing up on time consistently.
- adamsea 6y agoWell, cry me a river for the casino, which could afford to pay a living / more competitive wage, but I see your point about the other ones. Maybe then it says more about our current economic system as a whole. But my point was it seems like if $600 / week is enough for folks to choose not to work, that says more about the work not being meaningful or the employer being unable to (or choosing not to) pay the worker well.
- abfan1127 6y agowhile I can't speak for other casinos. This particular one paid them full wages for the 6 weeks they were originally shut down. it wasn't $600/wk. It was $600/wk plus UI. If $600/wk is enough not to work, then it can also speak to the quality of the worker and their lack of skills. Spending time complaining about how hard life is, rather than doing something about it. Not everyone is like that, and not no-one is like that either.
- smileysteve 6y ago> it wasn't $600/wk. It was $600/wk plus UI Severance is counted against eligibility for unemployment in most states. Source; had a friend not understand this, to wonder where their unemployment was, to get their first check after their severance ran out.
- hogFeast 6y agoNot your point but I think there is a definite issue here with perceptions around workplace safety. The US has a very good level of testing/mask usage. And, to be blunt, just wear a mask and wash your hands...you will be okay. I understand why some groups of people are very worried: if you are obese, if you are over 60, if you work in a hospital/care home...but if you work in an office, it isn't a "Hunger Games" situation. I don't think furlough/unemployment schemes necessarily created that incentive though. People in some places are clearly being very cautious (I am in the UK, people aren't wearing masks and not being cautious at all...I have seen larger crowds at pubs than ever...no masks) anyway. So I think the solution to the unemployment problem is a change in message from govt. If you take precautions, you will be okay (again, where I am the message was very urgent and serious...this worked at first but some people are ignoring totally and others are staying at home terrified of their own shadow...so who knows? But I think it would have success generally).
- slg 6y ago>The US has a very good level of testing/mask usage. And, to be blunt, just wear a mask and wash your hands...you will be okay. If this is true, why is the outbreak here so much worse than basically any of our peer countries?
- refurb 6y agoHow do you define worse? Number of deaths? If so, the US is doing better than many countries. https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2020/08/05/899365887/charts-how-the-u-s-ranks-on-covid-19-deaths-per-capita-and-by-case-count https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2020/08/05/8993658...
- slg 6y agoTotals are misleading due to each countries varied handling of the initial pandemic. Our peers are not still struggling with this the way we continue to struggle. I did some quick math based off the numbers here as an example[1][2]. The UK has had 3.0 COVID-19 deaths over the last three days per million people. The US has had nearly four times that many deaths with 11.8 per million people in that same 3 day time frame. [1] - https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/uk/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/uk/ [2] - https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/us/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/us/
- Nasrudith 6y agoReally the "avoiding work" is fundamentally a motivated lie because they don't want to pay period but especially not during the retail and tourist apocalypse that is covid-19. It is as usual incredibly short sighted and stupid as the impatient reopeners think if they ignore the fire it will just fizzle out and people will continue shopping like normal.
- djsumdog 6y agoThere are some people who don't want to go back to work even when their jobs are returning. There might legit safety concerns in places like meat packing plants, but they can be addresses by those places spending the money on PPE and small modifications the plants. Musk has done it with his own companies. Politicians like Ocasio-Cortez actively told people they shouldn't go back to work even as places open back up. This is problematic because if enough people believe that, there is a risk of shortages for things like food. We over produce quite a bit in America, farms are heavily subsidized, and it's mostly school/restaurant food chain products that are being dumped right now (and many Americans are realizing for the first time we get totally different qualities of products than restaurants do), so it's not affecting us too badly yet. Hopefully it won't, but there needs to be a balance between any proposal for UBI or continued unemployment and restarting production systems that produce domestic goods we need to survive.
- jakogut 6y ago> and many Americans are realizing for the first time we get totally different qualities of products than restaurants do This is interesting, can you clarify what you mean?
- hogFeast 6y agoThe only way that UBI can work is if you have a very strong labour market with high levels of flexibility. This is one of the tricky things about economic policy. If you are proposing UBI, you are likely to be the worst person possible to implement it. All the proponents see are upsides without the deep understanding of the downsides. A country which manages this well is Denmark. They have high levels of union membership, they have a true contributory unemployment insurance scheme that functions like UBI but they are also very savvy about capitalism/markets, and have one of the most flexible labour markets in the world (one of the few places on par with the US, maybe even ahead of). They understand that capitalism is the way you pay for all this stuff, it is the solution, not the problem. Very few political systems can make this leap. The same applies to the discussion around restarting. Lots of countries went hard on the lockdown rhetoric...and now, it is pretty hard to roll back. It is very concerning though. I don't think this is going to be some huge decade long disaster, things will get better. But there is a real possibility that a lot of supply gets destroyed in the meantime as the middle-class cocoons themselves at home out of fear.
- cortesoft 6y agoI think the perverse incentive they are talking about is that all benefits are cut once someone gets a job, even if the job doesn't make as much as the benefits gave. If the benefits were instead given to everyone, then you wouldn't lose money by getting a job.
- newacct583 6y agoYes, but that only matters when the worker in question is faced with the choice of whether to work or not. Right now unemployment is through the roof because effectively all the service jobs have evaporated. There are no jobs. No one is sitting home savoring their cushy $600 benefits bonus instead of working, because there is nowhere to work anyway. The argument against generous "unemployment insurance" vs. "UBI" is valid enough. But it's based on an assumption of near-full employment that doesn't hold right now. Basically: this is not the time to have that argument.
- jchrisa 6y agoI hear from multiple of my small business owner friends, that they are unable to get people to come back to work due to this. It's hard to know what the overall distortion is, but it's definitely a good illustration of the welfare trap where most jobs offer negative marginal utility.
- newacct583 6y ago$600/week unemployment, even when including state benefits, is well under minimum wage in almost all urban areas. I don't know which small businesses your friends own, nor where they are, but jobs that pay that low aren't representative of a significant fraction of the real economy (and, let's be honest: the ones that really sit in this realm tend to be staffed by undocumented workers anyway who wouldn't qualify for these benefits). Broadly: I think this is mostly spin, and would want to see a real study instead of anecdotes from friends.
- ponker 6y agoThe fact that the benefits are more than some people’s pay shows how low the pay was.
- matthewaveryusa 6y agoRidiculously high? It's a _bit_ high. 10% is not the end of the world, but it does put the US at european levels.
- save_ferris 6y agoIt plays into the argument that people will be lazy and refuse to do any kind of work if they have an alternate source of income, when the market doesn’t actually see as much of that. People like to have multiple sources of income (hello, passive income.)
- abarringer 6y agoI know six people that lost their jobs and were not looking for new ones because they were making more money on unemployment than employed. That is a perverse incentive.
- bobthepanda 6y agoin this scenario is unemployment what demands a correction, or low wage levels?
- voldacar 6y agoThe perverse incentive is that people are forced to choose between the benefit and going back go a job that might not pay much more, thus distorting the supply curve for labor. If the benefit were unconditional like UBI, the supply curve would remain smoothly continuous.