3 ms·
The Space Shuttle was considered a reasonably conservative design using a lot of existing technology. Despite this, it had cost overruns north of a billion doll
by adolph 6y ago
The Space Shuttle was considered a reasonably conservative design using a lot of existing technology. Despite this, it had cost overruns north of a billion dollars, and it was late by several years. Chrysler's more unconventional layout would've probably cost even more, and been delayed even longer.
This counterfactual is directly related to the mindset that led to the “conservative” option going upside down value-wise. Instead of viewing the difficulties as being opportunity, the nation chose to play it safe. It lost the attitude towards doing things “. . . not because they are easy, but because they are hard, because that goal will serve to organize and measure the best of our energies and skills, because that challenge is one that we are willing to accept, one we are unwilling to postpone, and one which we intend to win. . .”
https://spacecenter.org/exhibits-and-experiences/starship-gallery/kennedy-podium/ https://spacecenter.org/exhibits-and-experiences/starship-ga...
- cameldrv 6y agoI think that this is the right answer. Apollo had a very young, smart, energetic workforce. There are a limited number of these people in the country, and certain projects attract them. Apollo's ambition was very attractive to these people in a way that the shuttle wasn't, and SpaceX is. IMO SpaceX's workforce is the key to their extreme success, and they are able to get that workforce because of their ambition.
- valuearb 6y agoI’d argue the Shuttle failed because it wasn’t conservative enough. What we needed was more cost effective versions of the Saturn rockets. Instead they got infected with the SSTO fantasy, which can never work well. But it boxed them in a corner with the wrong fuel, wrong engines and forced-them to add super expensive SSRBs, which required putting the Shuttle on the side, which led to two disasters and a “reusable” launch system that had to be totally rebuilt between launches. We’d still have Skylab if they had focused on manufacturing efficiencies for Saturn rockets instead.
- pfdietz 6y agoIn an alternate universe, the Saturn IB could have been evolved to something like the Falcon 9. The H1 engines are in a similar thrust class as the Merlin, although with lower performance.
- Breza 6y agoI've thought about this as I've read the book Coming Home: Reentry and Recovery from Space. The fixation on a space plane probably set back the US space program by decades whereas a more boring evolutionary tree descended from the Saturn program would have been interesting.
- pfdietz 6y agoShuttle failed because the question it was answering was "how can we employ engineers to help Nixon's reelection", not "how to we cheaply get to LEO".