4 ms·
A Cold War scenario is far more likely. Remember that the tension with the Soviets was far, far, higher, and that never turned into a full-on war.
by keiferski 6y ago
A Cold War scenario is far more likely. Remember that the tension with the Soviets was far, far, higher, and that never turned into a full-on war.
- peacefulhat 6y agoUSSR was isolated from the American economy. USA is doing everything in its power to destroy top tier Chinese companies and exploit local political situations.
- keiferski 6y agoBoth the US and the Soviets did these things and to a far greater degree. As I said, we will likely see a Cold War scenario of two separate spheres of economic influence. The divestment process is already underway.
- peacefulhat 6y agoTSMC has great potential to degrade into kinetic war.
- bsder 6y agoThat's why TSMC has started the process of putting fabs back into the US. Lack of stability in the Pacific Rim is now more expensive long term than US labor costs.
- whycombagator 6y ago> never turned into a full-on war. But almost did (Cuban Missile Crisis), and there were several wars* by proxy (some with China too). *conflicts technically, as Congress hasn't declared war since WW2
- dis-sys 6y ago> as Congress hasn't declared war since WW2 because they couldn't win in Vietnam or Korea.
- blueblisters 6y agoChina is a lot more stable, both economically and politically, than the Soviet Union. While it's not quite par with the United States yet, China has a population 4x the size of the United States, which gives them unprecedented scale to build out and deploy new tech that can easily leapfrog any edge the United States has right now. In the long term, the only thing going for the US are alliances with other developed countries and democracies. But the current administration doesn't seem to care very much about that.
- keiferski 6y agoI don’t think raw population numbers are as useful as they seem. Most ruling political states have been comprised of a fairly small group of elites. Think Britain in India, or even the Mughals before them. We should also consider that Canada and Mexico have been/can be more integrated into a single economic unit. The more important part is technological innovation, and so far, I remain unconvinced that a closed totalitarian system will have as much innovation as an open one, in the long term. Otherwise, agreed that the US does need its allies, though I don’t necessarily agree that it has alienated them. If you look at the real events, and not merely the media talking heads, there is absolutely a growing sense of unity against China. See: India, Vietnam, Japan, Philippines, increased NATO budget commitments, to name a few.
- blueblisters 6y ago> The more important part is technological innovation, and so far, I remain unconvinced that a closed totalitarian system will have as much innovation as an open one, in the long term. It's better to characterize/qualify Chinese style of governance as a top-down meritocratic totalitarian government. Policymakers in China are theoretically able to make decisions that are optimal to achieve certain policy goals, say x% economic growth. In contrast, democracies set policy goals and make decisions through the messy process of achieving political consensus. IMO, private innovation happens when a combination of factors align: free consumer choice, a large market under a common set of rules and stable political conditions. I don't think the Chinese style of governance prevents any of this. Public innovation happens through well-funded universities and taxpayer-funded research grants. China pushes one step further at times by funding new technology/research directly through state owned/sponsored enterprises. I think there are genuine fears within US policy circles that the stability afforded by economic growth under a meritocratic totalitarian government could give China an edge over countries like the US, which have to work with the overheads of a democracy. I believe observers in the future will agree that these fears were not unfounded.