8 ms·
None of these Chinese companies would have grown to what they are today without intense government-enforced protectionism at home, and until China agrees to com
by paxys 6y ago
None of these Chinese companies would have grown to what they are today without intense government-enforced protectionism at home, and until China agrees to compete on a fair playing field I'm perfectly fine with them all being banned outside of their firewall.
Would China ever agree to let Instagram, Facebook, YouTube, Snapchat, WhatsApp, Messenger etc. or any new startup operate freely and make money there? It should never have had this one-way economic benefit to begin with.
- alexmingoia 6y agoTwo wrongs don’t make a right. US companies don’t have to trade with China. But the US banning trade with China is nothing but an attack on Americans and my freedom to trade and communicate.
- paxys 6y agoTry launching your app in China and see how much freedom you have. Regulating international trade (via agreements) is one of the foremost responsibilities of the federal government, and if this move forces them to open up their economy to fair competition it's a net benefit for everyone.
- alexmingoia 6y agoNobody is forced to do business with China, but you and those who support these policies are forcing me not to do business with China. Leave me alone.
- paxys 6y agoHow does this move affect your ability to do business with China?
- xvector 6y agoYou can absolutely launch your app in China if you follow the law.
- Markoff 6y agothey don't, but WeChat is also huge security risk spying on people abroad with access to photos etc., tool used to tax evasion payments within the app etc. for instance you go to chinese restaurant - you can choose to pay legally with card or cash money they have to tax or undocumented untaxed income through wechat
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> for instance you go to chinese restaurant - you can choose to pay legally with card or cash money they have to tax or undocumented untaxed income through wechat This sounds like the exact opposite of the truth. Payment through wechat generates records. Payment in cash doesn't.
- Markoff 6y agoyeah, records in China inaccessible to IRS, but we are discussing here WeChat ban in US
- xvector 6y agoThose companies are free to operate in China if the comply with Chinese law. The US hasn’t issued any legal barriers for TikTok to jump over, they just straight out banned it.
- shripadk 6y ago> Those companies are free to operate in China if the comply with Chinese law. Which will never happen. The Chinese know that Western companies would never want to comply with the Chinese law because the law was purposefully designed in such a way as to benefit the totalitarian regime. So they were forced to quit China. This is nothing but an indirect ban. This is very common actually. For example: India imposed a 200% tariff on all Pakistani goods instead of banning them after the Pulwama Terror Attack [1]. Why not outright ban them? Because of global trade rules that prohibit taking such measures. So imposing a 200% tariff would effectively mean a ban only. No one in their right mind would import goods/services at 200% import duty. This is what Chinese were doing to US companies the past decade. Which is why US companies left China in the first place. Because staying around and doing business in China became untenable. [1]: https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/economy/policy/india-hikes-customs-duty-to-200-pc-on-all-goods-imported-from-pakistan/articleshow/68026919.cms?from=mdr https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/economy/policy/ind...
- knolax 6y agoMicrosoft complies with those laws just fine. Bing, Windows, Office are all available there.
- chrisco255 6y agoWindows and Office are neutral applications. They're not social communication or information platforms. And hardly anyone uses Bing in China.
- burfog 6y agoThey are not neutral applications. Windows has settings for timezone, language, currency, and more. Using the software sold in China, can you choose Taiwan or is it called Chinese Taipei? What do the maps show for the South China Sea, for the border with India, and for Tibet?
- logicchains 6y ago>None of these Chinese companies would have grown to what they are today without intense government-enforced protectionism at home Ah yes, I remember when the Chinese government killed off Vine to give TikTok a head start.
- gpm 6y agoWas Vine available in China? It seems quite unlikely considering how little western social media is... so while I can't tell from a quick search I'm guessing that you really should remember that.
- fastball 6y agoIronically it seems like you and GC are on the same side (China didn't kill Vine), but you actually have unintentionally made an argument in favor of the opposite stance – maybe Vine would've done better if the CCP had allowed it to exist in China.
- gpm 6y agoHuh? I'm arguing that China probably did kill Vine, or at least substantially contribute to its death.
- beaunative 6y agoThere is no point 'kill' an app that never really took off.
- bleepblorp 6y agoIt's pretty much impossible for lower-income countries to develop economically without protecting their emerging businesses from being slaughtered by established foreign competition. The priority of the Chinese government is the benefit of its citizens (leaving aside that the CCP doesn't consider ethnic minorities in China to be full citizens, as this is a separate issue) and its domestic economy, not the benefit of the American tech sector's senior executives and shareholders. It's not reasonable to expect, much less demand, that the Chinese turn their tech economy over to silicon valley by allowing unrestricted US entry. It's not in their economic interests, nor is it in their security interests, and no amount of US bullying will change this. China is not Europe; it's not going to hand over the keys to its economic future to the United States just because the US asks for them.
- paxys 6y agoI would have agreed with you 20 years ago, but China is now the second largest economy in the world, and on track to becoming the largest. Combine that with its gross domestic human rights violations, censorship, IP theft, and expansionist foreign policy (looking at the South China Sea, NE India, SE Asia, Africa etc.), and they aren't getting any sympathy from me.
- bleepblorp 6y agoThe Chinese government isn't made up of nice people by any stretch but it's vitally important to understand their position so as to avoid escalation, possibly into armed conflict in future decades. They have every reason to view the survival of their tech sector as a vital economic security interest. Confiscating the value of their foreign tech assets without cause, or legitimate due process, will not make the Chinese change their behavior. It will only harden their position and make future conflict more likely because the US has demonstrated that it is not willing to respect the rule of law or act in good faith towards Chinese businesses. Slow-walking into another cold war isn't in anyone's interest and the deplorable behavior of the Chinese government does not change this.
- fastball 6y ago
- fqye 6y agoYou couldn't be wronger. Alibaba wasn't protected by the government at all. Ebay's then CEO bought a local e-biz site eachnet and relocated to Shanghai but still failed at competing with Alibaba. Amazon bought some local e-biz site too and failed at competing with Alibaba too. MSN was a huge player in China with far more users than QQ when it was taking off. ICQ was in China too. At the time IM wans't a big deal for big players. Tencent went IPO as very small startup, far less than Sina, Sohu etc., China's portals. Chinese internet giants could win because they adapted fast to local market.
- ejanus 6y agoWrong! How come same companies you mentioned are doing well every other place except in China? Don't you see this as odd?
- dvcrn 6y agoThis isn't an argument. In most countries you have some local competitors that do better than global brands. Not every app has to be a global success to be highly profitable Korea has KakaoTalk that's undefeated as the defacto chat app (and now search engine and payment provider). It's not doing well in every other place except Korea. Japan has LINE as it's primary messenger, payment app, etc. It has some foot in other south-east asian countries but the strongpoint is still Japan.
- ejanus 6y agoI am not ruling out your points, they are sound and I agree with them. But look at it this way, you have 100 companies and all of them failed woefully in only one particular market. This doesn't look like natural event , it looks more like a biased coin.
- mariojv 6y agoLINE is owned by a South Korean company, so it's not really a good example of a local brand.
- fqye 6y ago
- echevil 6y agoHow so? Google operated in China for more than a decade and never got a major market share, and they already did fairly well compared to others. Facebook was largely unheard of after being available in China for many years before finally got banned in 2010. Amazon has been operating in China forever but is basically irrelevant to most Chinese. Most American companies did terrible job in localization and I see no chance of them winning the competition with their local competitors. If they face strong local competition in any other country, they'd fail too
- dannyw 6y agoAs a Chinese expat, Google China (back when it was operating) was multiple times slower than Baidu and would get blocked by the GFW arbitrarily frequently.
- echevil 6y agoI was able to use Google fine for many years before it was banned. It can get banned when you search for certain keywords, not arbitrary at all. Google was about the only one I can think of that is not worse than their competitors, and their own product actually don't need much localization. However, Google failed the growth part in China. Chinese users won't go ahead and set the default search engine to google.com on their own unless they already know about it, especially those don't know English. The homepage used by most Chinese are local websites like hao123 that would send traffic to Baidu
- est 6y agogoogle.cn is located at its Beijing datacenter. If it's multiple times slower then Google's network optimization was really shit. GFW only works for cross-border connections.
- ejanus 6y agoThe best argument I have read here.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- est 6y ago> None of these Chinese companies would have grown to what they are today without intense government-enforced protectionism at home As others have mentioned, Alibaba, Taobao, Alipay grew the same time as mazon, Paypal and eBay was available in China. Also newegg had a much better headstart than jd.com but still failed. At one time even Yahoo Messenger, MSN Messenger was a serious threat to Tencent QQ. Wordpress was much more popular than QZone.
- jjcc 6y ago's great you mention that. But the biggest reason that why FB, Google were excluded after around 2010 is never mentioned here and even difficult to debate because of political correctness: Is the Chinese government policy from economic reason or something else that has been interpreted as protectionism? The other theory is uncensored social media is perceived as a big threat to national security threat (I'm not saying CPP security threat). The ground situation in China is beyond the understanding of most population even a large portion of intellectuals inside China. That view was enhanced and many Chinese intellectuals changed their mind after color revolution in Ukraine, middle east chaos, etc. Don't get me wrong, most educated people inside China are against censorship like westerners and the sentiment was very strong and still somehow strong today. "Animal Farm" and "1984"[1] are sold openly in China. But normal peaceful life without fear of danger and insecurity from conflicts is evaluated more important than economic development let alone freedom of speech inside China but it is not necessary applied to other part of the world especially liberal Western world. With polarization of recent events in US and consequential censorship on YouTube and Twitter that beyond topic of BLM/Identity politics/etc which result in many normal Chinese YouTube and twitter accounts mistakenly banned (This is not well-known in English audience), even more Chinese changed their view against Chinese government censorship. The real reason is not economical but from a perception of national security. The perception is debatable but it should be at least included as an option of viewpoint as opposed to totally excluded. [1]http://product.dangdang.com/25215594.html http://product.dangdang.com/25215594.html
- baconandeggs 6y agoWhat are you talking about? All countries protect their industries. Are we forgetting about Bombardier? All military contractors are almost part of the US government at this point. And Apple, and now Microsoft apparently are leveraging Trump to gain every bit of advantage they can. The US forces entire countries to give favorable deals to american companies and has for decades.