3 ms·
Government bodies restrict "all possible treatments" all the time, especially when they are unproven and have side-effects. There's a whole FDA for that purpose
by shadowgovt 6y ago
Government bodies restrict "all possible treatments" all the time, especially when they are unproven and have side-effects. There's a whole FDA for that purpose. It came into being, among other reasons, because history taught us that those with a deadly disease are some of the most desperate of our fellow citizens, and are vulnerable to becoming victims of charlatans and snake oil salesmen. It is, perhaps, conservative in its risk estimates, but that conservatism grows from experience paid for in blood and lives.
And it's not just the FDA. As you've observed, multiple standards bodies and professional organizations have cautioned against off-label use of HCQ for this purpose. These bodies don't all have the same incentives, when they agree on a topic, It can be taken as a signal that their consensus is probably correct.
And the larger concern isn't even doctors prescribing it. As citstion 2 indicates, the larger concern is the public deciding (partially based on the words of our president... for all the concern that your first citation expresses about politicians interfering with medical care, she sure seems to give a pass on the most powerful man in the federal executive speaking well beyond his experience and understanding) that this thing is a miracle cure and trying to self-dose with black market acquired medication, which will increase the death toll. Although, I suppose, it may have an unfortunate net positive side effect for the community at large... Not all of those overdoses will make their way to the hospital before they die, So there will be more resources freed up to treat covid cases and other medical conditions.
That is not a solution we should pursue or encourage, of course. Not if our goal is saving lives.
- Fjolsvith 6y agoPerhaps you are right. A drug with 60 years of safe use in humans could be dangerous.
- shadowgovt 6y agoIt's known precisely how it is dangerous (well-understood side-effects) and it's understood, given those side-effects, to be safer than having the diseases it treats. Since it's not proven to treat COVID-19, and it has side-effects that can include an irregular heart rhythm, administering it to treat COVID-19 does harm without proven good and may violate a practitioner's Hippocratic oath (and, for an individual self-dosing, may just make the situation worse).