3 ms·
In the US, there is a thing called The California Effect. California has a history of passing laws for California which end up getting adopted at the federal le
by DoreenMichele 6y ago
In the US, there is a thing called The California Effect. California has a history of passing laws for California which end up getting adopted at the federal level.
This is the origin story for environmental protection in this country.
So probably that's a factor here. If you are in the federal government and you know California has the power to de facto dictate federal policy by passing a law at the state level, the only good defense is a proactive offense.
- grawprog 6y agoI've witnessed the California effect outside of California and America. I've seen the warnings on more than one thing 'this product contains substances known to be harmful in the state of California'. On things as innocuous as a crescent wrench...
- gumby 6y agoThis is no different from Europe’s ROHS rules which have helped people worldwide.
- zdragnar 6y ago"Helped" is a bit of a stretch. One could (and many have) argue that the universal presence of the warnings mean that they are universally ignored. Wood and stone dust cause cancer. Coffee and alcohol may cause cancer. None of those things are on the same level as tobacco, tanning beds etc. There is a massive spectrum, and the labels themselves don't offer that information. As such, people depending on the labels may incorrectly assume that using a crescent wrench is as dangerous as smoking tobacco, or vice versa.
- supernova87a 6y agoThat's a good example. Even with that case, you will find people who, even if supporting California on its right to promulgate its own air regulations, then turn around and object to other states doing something they don't like, using that same principle. It seems principles are principles to the extent we agree with them.
- nooyurrsdey 6y agoI think that's a fair counterbalance to the amount of power smaller states have at a federal level. Small rural states with similar ideals can form voting blocks and have the benefit of 2 Gauranteed Senators. That plus the electoral college method of presidential elections puts a ton of power in their hands. I'd call this a feature of the system. Ironically it's "states rights" and the pressure of adopting an existing system ("free market") that's serving the left instead of the right in this case.