4 ms·
The property management company isn't really a company per se; it's more like a conduit for money, an instrument. If that instrument defaults, it's not of so m
by derefr 6y ago
The property management company isn't really a company per se; it's more like a conduit for money, an instrument.
If that instrument defaults, it's not of so much concern that a property management company will die; but rather, that the companies who were on either side of it, relying on it as a conduit for money to flow through, will end up illiquid, unable to exchange through that instrument.
On one side, that's large investors, e.g. mutual funds. So the markets will go down.
On the other side, that's the businesses themselves. Having no access to financially-healthy property management companies to rent from, is a lot like having no access to loans: it limits your choices as a business.
Maybe the valuations of these properties will crash without property-management companies around to compete over them, and businesses will be able to afford to buy them directly. But more likely, as we saw in 2007, the commercial real-estate market will just become illiquid, with everyone who is currently holding empty commercial property (i.e. mostly banks, after a presumed default or bailout of PMCs) refusing to sell it "until things recover", so that they don't have to write down a loss. And that means there won't necessarily be any commercial properties on the market for these businesses to buy into in place of their previous rentals.
- WanderPanda 6y agoAnd yet again the cleanest method would be to not bail out the banks and let the assets be actioned to the highest bidder. Everything else is trading off long term efficient ressource allocation in favor of short term stability.
- rodgerd 6y agoFunny how it's a moral hazard to bail out individuals weighed down by debt, but an economic necessity to bail out millionaires and billionaires who didn't do their risk analysis.
- int_19h 6y agoOr maybe they did do their risk analysis, and incorporated the likelihood of getting bailed out into that?
- munk-a 6y agoAt this point they'd be fiscally irresponsible if they didn't assume a certain level of bailing out - and they're likely "investing" in relations with various senators and representatives to make sure their name is on the list of those eligible for the bailouts.
- simonh 6y agoI agree bailouts should not benefit shareholders, but it can be pragmatic to rescue businesses, including banks, that are systemically important. That may mean the government temporarily assuming equity in, or ownership of the enterprise. The important thing is that it's the interests of the economy that are being safeguarded, not those of investors.
- munk-a 6y agoThat would cause a massive economic disruption that could potentially lead to actually bad economic effects. Right now things aren't all sunny and happy for everyone but they can get a lot worse if infrastructural components of the economy start getting eroded - either by being chopped up for vulture capitalists or by having their lending chain & backers divided up similarly. If Fedex & UPS were to be forced to sell off package delivery in NYC to cover losses while USPS continues to be hamstrung by the administration then things will get bad - and there are a lot of other operators that are a lot less visible but just as essential. Let slip retailers and banks are less stable - let slip banks and companies that are operating through the pandemic on shoe-strings and a whole bunch of backed credits lose the ability to keep the lights on.
- linuxftw 6y ago> If Fedex & UPS were to be forced to sell off package delivery in NYC Then the market will adjust. If you can't get packages delivered in NYC, you will have to get your goods through some other means. Maybe all of NYC is a bubble. Maybe that many people shouldn't live on a handful of tiny islands, importing their food from the mid west and their goods from China. Maybe everyone's in the wrong place.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoMaybe. But if that's true, is the correct solution to crash-and-burn from the current scenario to some version of a "better" one?
- linuxftw 6y agoThe correct thing to do is let the market decide. If it's profitable to do something, people will do it.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoThis seems profoundly naive to me. "If it's profitable do something" is beyond simplistic. Profitable compared to what? Profitable for whom? Profitable based on what assumptions? Profitable by what metric? Dollars accrued to capital? Dollars accrued to GDP? Quality of life index? Happiness index? Life expectancy numbers? Infant mortality? Profitable with what externalities forced to be part of cost-factoring? What is "the market"? What is a "decision" in this context? What is the cost benefit analysis of allowing "the market" to "decide" versus more policy-driven unfolding of the outcome? ... and so on and so on .... i.e. the usual litany of problems with free-market boosterism