5 ms·
How can you possibly believe this is the right thing to do? I just don't understand
by mrguyorama 6y ago
How can you possibly believe this is the right thing to do? I just don't understand
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoIt all comes down to who the people making these decisions are trying to please. The elected officials (assuming they're at least sort of doing their job) are acting on what they think will please the most voters. The net difference in the number of constituents hate this option, the next option, and every other feasible option for the school year is likely very small. This is what the tyranny of the majority looks like. But of course thinking about the incentives and mechanisms that lead to this outcome is uncomfortable and clutching our pearls is comfortable and easy so what we'll do is a forgone conclusion. Edit: I'm personally no fan of the policy the school chose but asinine or not they didn't choose it for no reason and it's worth exploring what lead to the people making the decisions to choose what they chose. Edit2: Some of you would do well to read only the words I am writing here and not assume any unwritten meaning or motivation. I am specifically trying to avoid debating whether this particular instance of public policy is good/bad/right/wrong and some of you seem to be very eager to do just that.
- vkou 6y agoThis is nonsense. If the administration actually made a good-faith effort, they would have re-opened, with a mask mandate. They haven't made a good-faith effort. This isn't what tyrrany of the majority looks like, this is what the end result of a cynical propaganda campaign looks like.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoGood faith for who? To you and me and other people who aren't from there? The fact that a public official felt comfortable calling masks a "personal choice" tells me that this district isn't a big fan of masks.
- vkou 6y agoOr it means that the public official is just virtue signaling that they aren't a big fan of masks. I am positive that this school has a dress code. For some reason, though, they feel that they can prescribe what students can wear, unless it's a mask..?
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>Or it means that the public official is just virtue signaling that they aren't a big fan of masks. If they're virtue signaling then by definition they're showing support for whatever the locally accepted opinion already is.
- vkou 6y agoThat opinion doesn't have to be widely locally accepted. You have no idea how many people support it - whether it's 20% of the population, 40% of the population, or 80% of the population. They could have made this decision the other way, and your arguments, when used in defense of it would be just as sound. It's quite possible to be virtue signaling to a minority. Just because you're an administrator in a public service doesn't mean that you are actually doing what the community wants you to do - especially when there are limited ways of removing you. It's even possible that the minority you are virtue signaling to is politicians and insiders - who actually have ways of removing you. It would be incredibly stupid of you to not do what they want.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>that opinion doesn't have to be widely locally accepted. You're not technically wrong but it would be monumentally stupid to do for this particular opinion. >It's quite possible to be virtue signaling to a minority. And it's moronic for an elected official to do that if the nature of the signal will absolutely enrage a majority or a different larger minority which "a mask is a personal choice" most certainly does.
- threatofrain 6y ago
- DonnyV 6y agoDuring a health crisis popular or unpopular does not matter. You do what is necessary wither you like it or not. What these "leaders" are doing is complete incompetence and negligent.
- zentiggr 6y agoThe problem is that 'necessary' to the people driving the Georgia decisions seems to be 'necessary to support my beliefs and my fiscal policy', not 'necessary for the best good of all'.
- heylook 6y ago> There is no right or wrong when it comes to reopening, only unpopular and even more unpopular and it all comes down to who you're trying to please. Which path forward "pleases" you the most? I can't believe this needs asking but: How many deaths are you willing to tolerate before you are no longer "pleased" by this approach? If one approach "pleases" you but "kills" someone else, how should we balance that tradeoff?
- HumblyTossed 6y ago> There is no right or wrong when it comes to reopening... Which is exactly the view that politicians want to foster with this pandemic. Unfortunately, they're politicians and not infectious disease specialists.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mherdeg 6y agoThe article quotes someone who believes this is the right thing to do and explains their perspective. This isn't the only view (nor the one endorsed by the physicians I know) but it's worth understanding in order to understand the public health trajectory of the next few years: > Steven, a North Paulding student who asked that only his middle name be used, said he felt safe going to school without a mask. Most of the hallways he encountered, he said, were far less crowded than in the one in the photograph. And the virus itself, he said, didn’t seem like “much of a problem” in Paulding County. > “I’ve only known three people to get it, other than the football players, obviously,” Steven said. “If I get it, I get it. I believe that’s what most people in my area's ideology is — if we get it, we get it.” > Steven said he didn’t want to let worries about spreading the virus to his family control his life. > “Most of my family, including my grandparents, think the same as well,” he said. “We just go on about our business and keep it out of our mind.”
- beepboopbeep 6y ago> Ideology
- newacct583 6y agoThe problem with that logic, of course[1], is that "if we get it we get it" is a statement of personal risk assumption. It doesn't address the rights of the people you will then infect, who you didn't involve in the decision. Some of those people don't want to get sick! Realistically, some of them are going to die. [1] Well, in addition to "Football player cases don't count" -- no idea what that's about. Was there a specific outbreak in that county on a team? === Edit to add a grand-response to this comment (because HN's rate limiter has kicked in, sigh) that illustrates exactly the problem with reasoning I'm trying to point out: > this logic [...] assumes somebody has a right to not be infected while in a public area. It absolutely does not. What if some sick kid comes home and unknowingly infects a grandparent who never left the house and never entered a public area? That's a routine kind of spread, in fact. > The responsibility for the risk [...] cannot simply be laid at a different person's feet. No, this is exactly the fallacy at work! There is no "responsibility" in a pandemic. There is no "fault". Those are abstractions dealing with INDIVIDUAL behavior, and we can't beat this with individual decisions, at all.
- untog 6y agoSchools in the US are, as a general rule, chronically underfunded. If they had money they could have erected tents outside in playing fields and car parks to allow teaching while socially distant. But slashing school budgets has been a popular political hobby for decades now and requests for emergency funding have fallen on deaf ears. So here we are.
- jmaygarden 6y agoI have doubts that classes could be effectively conducted outdoors in Georgia. The heat index is 93F/34C with 59% humidity as I’m writing this comment. This isn’t Northern California where people can start companies in a garage year round.
- bazzert 6y ago"The most recent version for 2018 reports that, in 2015, the United States spent approximately $12,800 per student on elementary and secondary education. That is over 35% more than the OECD country average of $9,500. " https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/020915/what-country-spends-most-education.asp#:~:text=The%20most%20recent%20version%20for,OECD%20country%20average%20of%20%249%2C500 https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/020915/what-country....
- mac01021 6y agoThe school in the article is in Georgia, so tents might not even cost. As much as air conditioning...
- jfengel 6y agoBecause American identity is deeply bound up in the idea that you have to work to be virtuous. If you're not at work, you're lazy, and lazy people literally don't deserve to live. Our schools are both warehouses for young people, so that their parents can work, and training grounds so that they can be prepared to work themselves. If the schools are closed, their parents can't work. That causes an enormous ripple effect. If some people can't work, then they don't have money, causing other people to lose their own jobs. That cascades through the system, tearing down not just the economy, but the American sense of self. If we're not at work, who are we? The US sees itself as the hardest-working, most virtuous nation in the world. God literally "shed his grace" on us. We deserve to be the richest because we're the best. Closing the schools not only shuts down our vaunted advantage, but admits that we can be beaten. We imagine ourselves able to solve crises through hard work and superior intellect, and if we can't, we are failures. At this point, it has become a matter of self-division as well. We've divided ourselves along lines that aren't even really ideological any more. The right wing has defined itself as opposed to "leftists", so anything the left proposes must be bad. If they want to wear masks and close down schools, then we will ban masks and open schools. It didn't even pass through a cost-benefit calculation, or at best one defined retroactively to justify the conclusion. Looked at this way, it seems pretty inevitable that opening the schools was going to happen, at least in places like Georgia that fall on the one side of that divide I mentioned.
- politician 6y agoIf we accept your point, doesn’t that imply that these officials and their supporters are incapable of thinking two steps ahead? School enables parents to work (1), but school is also a super spreader event that will sicken parents, preventing work (2). It’s baffling.
- jfengel 6y agoThe number of parents it sickens is relatively small, since many will have minor or no symptoms, and only a very few will die. The way they see it, the economy will soldier on, and we can afford to lose, say, a million random people. It probably won't be them or somebody they care about, and it would just be on a par with, say, cancer or heart disease.
- LocalH 6y agoPoliticians with their heads up their asses, pandering to their voter base. This nation needs some new political thought to really take hold. Both conservatives and liberals are massive echo chambers, and people are so invested in the duality that they will vote for an absolute shitbag just to keep a different absolute shitbag out of office.
- yetihehe 6y agoThat's how you end up with lizards as presidents. /s https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/162557-it-comes-from-a-very-ancient-democracy-you-see-you https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/162557-it-comes-from-a-very...
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago> pandering to their voter base. Isn't that kind of what we want? If GA's politicians pandered to CA's base it would probably turn violent pretty quickly.
- scarface74 6y agoThe problem is that GA Governor is pandering to his base by suing mayors in his own state who want stricter restrictions.
- ba2plus 6y agoWall Street has decreed that capitalism must go on at all costs. That requires workers to show up to work. That requires that workers don't need stay home to watch kids. And that requires that kids not be at home during business hours. Few believe that this is the right thing to do. Powerful businesspeople believe it's the profitable thing to do. So, here we are.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoOf all the “Wall Street” people I know, no one is advocating not wearing masks or opening schools. The only people I’ve seen with an anti mask policy are those very far from Wall St.
- ba2plus 6y agoI'm not talking about mask policies. I'm talking about "get employees back to work at all costs to save profits" policies.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoI don’t hear any Wall St types clamoring for that either. The states far away from Wall St are the ones banging their drums to open.
- scarface74 6y agoWall Street isn’t insisting on that at all. People on Wall Street are quite happy with the current state of affairs. The five largest companies in the US - all tech - are doing great. The other companies that are important are considered “essential”. It’s the small businesses that are struggling. This is a great opportunity for large companies.
- zwerdlds 6y agoElon Musk may not be anti-mask but he is pretty clearly an example of someone who doesn't give a shit about public health policy.
- 6y ago
- doorstar 6y agoOur schools are going virtual when they reopen but there are plenty of parents who object. Several reasons come up - Virtual learning did not work at the end of last year, and most parents think it's unlikely to work this year. I'll wait and see, but I'm also pessimistic about virtual learning for kids 5-18. It's just not engaging in that age range. - Related, families with two working parents are going to be very limited in their ability to work with their kid, e.g., make sure they are attending/paying attention in their zoom meetings, keep track of their assignments and make sure they are getting worked on, really sit and help with challenging projects and assignments. - Along the same lines, families with two parents who are or will be working outside the home are really in a bind. - Finally, there is continuing uncertainty about kids getting/transmitting Covid to the point where some people feel it's worth the risk. There is also a persistent group of parents who think this is all overwrought - they believe otherwise healthy kids and adults under the age of 60 are so are just unlikely to get very sick from Covid, certainly not more than any other virus. There's a wide range of feelings. I don't think the schools should open, but I'm also quietly prepared for this to be a lost educational year for my kids.
- AnimalMuppet 6y ago> I don't think the schools should open, but I'm also quietly prepared for this to be a lost educational year for my kids. "Quietly prepared" as in what? You're just going to accept it? Or you're going do what you have to to fill in the gaps and make it not a lost year for your kids? I'd urge you (and everyone) to go for the second option. They're your kids. They're not the school system's kids; they're yours. If you have to spend time and/or money to make sure that they actually get the education they need (because the school system can't or won't[1]), even if you have to give up some things to do so, do what you can to help your kids. [1] I'm not yelling at the school system here. They're in an impossible situation. They can't function at 100% effectiveness in an impossible situation? No shame in that, and no surprise, either.
- doorstar 6y agoI'm accepting it, make of that what you will. About the only thing I can give up to help this situation is my job. I'm not yet willing to make that trade.