6 ms·
I’ve been wondering what would happen if enough people and companies simply ignored Twitter, entirely. Pretended that it didn’t exist, that tweets are on the sa
by keiferski 6y ago
I’ve been wondering what would happen if enough people and companies simply ignored Twitter, entirely. Pretended that it didn’t exist, that tweets are on the same level of relevance as graffiti messages scribbled on sidewalks or the headlines on grocery store checkout conspiracy magazines. As in, nonsense.
I have a feeling that essentially nothing would change, and that in the long run, totally disengaging from Twitter would make sense from a cost-benefit point of view for most people and organizations. It really seems like it isn’t an accurate indicator of anything except a very tiny percentage of the population.
- marcus_holmes 6y agoI found this to be true. I was involved in selling a newspaper, and Twitter speculation from the journalists involved was rife and, frankly, full of bullshit. I decided there was no way to rationally deal with this. So I stopped looking at Twitter. That turned out to be the best thing to do. People still said things, but as I wasn't listening it didn't matter. The gossip and malicious slander reached a crescendo as the sale went though, but ultimately had zero impact on what actually happened. As far as I can work out, what happens on Twitter stays on Twitter, and if you don't pay it any attention it really doesn't matter. However, the caveat to that is that journalists are on Twitter, pay a lot of attention to Twitter, and report it as reality. Getting dogpiled on Twitter may not matter, but having it reported in newspapers may make it matter.
- sumtechguy 6y agoI have a few tech people I want to follow as they use it as a blog. But I do not want an account on twitter as it is too easy for me to get dragged into conversations that are unproductive for everyone involved. So I picked a method where I link about 5 people created a folder in firefox and linked to their pages. Then if I am wanting to 'see what is going on'. I open all links in that folder. I do that maybe once a month. Twitter is an attention machine. It feeds on getting your attention. Outrage does that quite nicely so they boderline openly encourage it.
- keiferski 6y agoThis is a good idea. Unfortunately other social media sites have started to force logging in to see content (Instagram, for example) so I worry that Twitter will do something similar soon.
- sumtechguy 6y agoDo they let you log in and 'remember' or is it every time?
- keiferski 6y agoI don't think Instagram lets you view any pages without logging in.
- snowwrestler 6y agoMy solution to this was to set my Twitter account to private and kick out almost all my followers. So if I do get tempted to tweet a reply to something, no one will see it anyway.
- searchableguy 6y agoI unfollowed everything on twitter and few other sites yesterday. I got tired of manufactured content on my timeline. (I found some newsletters and trend sites that happened to be the cause of everyone doing the same things at the same time)
- zachware 6y agoI do this using Feedbin for Twitter follows and (gasp) RSS. I find it useful.
- raybb 6y agoYou may want to try rss-bridge so you can just get tweets from those people into a feed reader
- schemy 6y ago>However, the caveat to that is that journalists are on Twitter, pay a lot of attention to Twitter, and report it as reality. Getting dogpiled on Twitter may not matter, but having it reported in newspapers may make it matter. And how many people read newspapers? The only thing that matters to a business is when people show up with placards in front of the business, or the CEOs house. The cases where that happens are so few and far between that by ignoring everything a newspaper writes you improve your business's performance by the simple fact you're not paying someone to waste time. The rest of it can be summed up as "don't get caught putting babies in blenders".
- marcus_holmes 6y agoWell, investors get jittery if there's a lot of noise. Deals have failed because of controversy started by Twitter dogpiles. And you really don't need to go as far as a baby-blender interaction to generate a Twitter storm. Just hint at anything that might be construed as limiting a journalist's right to publish wtf they feel like publishing ;)
- neuland 6y agoI am a person not a company, but I do often forget that twitter exists. And when I'm reminded it does exist, I have about as low an opinion of it as you describe.
- bootcampwhere 6y agoI'm convinced 80% of people essentially never "open their eyes" so for them Twitter blends into the background. For most, source does not matter, hearing/seeing something 5-7 times for these people is sufficient to convince them it is real, they don't consider anything else.
- whywhywhywhy 6y ago> if enough people and companies simply ignored Twitter, entirely They already do, it's only journalists who have convinced themselves it's actually relevant. The people who keep Twitter turning are actually a tiny fraction of it's userbase who are so embarrassingly addicted to it that Twitter had to hide tweet counts because if you divided hours since start date / total tweets far too many were encroaching on horrifying figures like nearly a tweet an hour for 8+ years solid and it just made it's most engaged users look bad.
- oneplane 6y agoDepends on the product and on the people. If a twitter mob is large enough to influence your bottom line it matters.
- raffraffraff 6y agoBut... "if enough people and companies simply ignored Twitter, entirely" ... then that mob is just a bunch off assholes screaming into a void. So the only difference is the void.
- _AzMoo 6y agoThe void is not nothing though, it's other people, who may be influenced and then in many cases influence others on other platforms. I think ignoring a platform of 330 million users when a good chunk of those are on a witch hunt for your product or brand would be asking for trouble.
- Retric 6y agoAssuming those numbers are accurate 4.2% of the global population is on Twitter. Which seems highly suspect. But for the sake of argument, if 4% of your customers are on the platform it’s highly unlikely for those users to be influenced about your product. Aka, how much does Twitter inform people choice of paper towels etc. Now, that possibly changes for hype or fad based industries. If you’re creating buzz around a new movie sure Twitter might be relevant.
- shuntress 6y agoIf your customers make up almost 100% of the population of the earth then yeah you can probably ignore anything said anywhere including twitter. But for the sake of argument, if your customers overlap significantly with that 4% of earth's population that use twitter, then it is highly likely for those users to be influenced about your product. Aka, how much does Twitter inform people's of choice of news website, blockbuster movie, tech blog, etc.
- 6y ago
- shuntress 6y agoThe thing is though, I want accessible, rapid, widespread, index-able-ish (tagging), extra-short form communication. I really want what twitter is promising but I hate what twitter is currently providing.
- Reedx 6y agoWe might see what happens over the coming years. I think there's probably going to be a mass exodus from Twitter and social media generally, unless the platforms change at a very fundamental level. But currently they're so profoundly unhealthy for both individuals and society at large that they'll end up with the same kind of fate as cigarettes.
- Nasrudith 6y agoSame fate as cigarettes how? Getting lawyers addicted to chasing dragons of large class action lawsuits regardless of any harm or wrongdoing actually existing? (Hello physics-illiterate cell phone cancer lawsuits.) Used as a way for organized crime to generate profits due to exploiting disparate tax codes? Used as a cliche when they are a vastly stretched metaphor at best? Twitter is a dumpster fire of user interface (their only remotely right features are infinite scroll and hashtags) and dynamics but calling it is trivializing literal cancer and externalized deaths because idiots make asses of themselves. The problem with society at large has always been society at large.