4 ms·
Can nuclear war be morally justified?
- nabla9 6y agoI don't see how nuclear war is fundamentally different from conventional war in this respect. The real difference is between counterforce targeting vs. countervalue targeting. Counterforce strike is strike against enemy forces. Countervalue strike is strike against enemy’s cities and civilian population with nuclear weapons.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoI would make a huge difference between "nuclear war" and using a nuclear weapon. Nuclear war is often understood (at least I think) as a total annihilation of all parties through extensive use of nuclear weapons. This is the boogeyman of the nuclear dissuasion strategy and not meant to happen. On the other hand, the use of nuclear weapons as they were used in Hiroshima and Nagasaki is not very different from the use of conventional weapons as they were used at the time: Whole cities were obliterated through carpet bombing with comparable damage. A nuclear bomb was 'just' more efficient. In my opinion the moral dilemma was not the use of a nuclear weapon but rather the total destruction of a city, and that choice had been made before nuclear weapons were used (see Dresden, Tokyo). This might not have been considered at the beginning of the war, but with time and the toll on people and society the limits of what was previously acceptable or not start to fade. I think in 1945 the mindset of people was "do whatever it takes."