3 ms·
Honestly, my best bet is that Musk, who needs at least fission or even better fusion for Mars (space is the only business case for any plausible peaceful fusion
by CamperBob2 6y ago
Honestly, my best bet is that Musk, who needs at least fission or even better fusion for Mars (space is the only business case for any plausible peaceful fusion)
An interesting assertion. What are some of the reasons why you're certain that fusion will not be a useful source of energy in peacetime/civilian applications? Is it likely to be "too cheap to meter," as we were promised fission power would be, or do you think it'll always be too expensive to be practical?
- trhway 6y agoCheapest electricity is natural gas one. Imagine a natural gas plant with free natural gas. That would decrease the electricity price by about 1/3 (fuel price is up to 2/3 of natural gas based generation, and the generation is between half and 2/3 of electricity price). The fusion power plant ideally is equivalent of that free natural gas power plant. Though it can't be further from it on practice. Any feasible in the observable future fusion involves neutrons. That in addition to affecting reactor design - cost and complexity of building, operating and maintenance - brings in the whole regulatory regime just a notch lighter than fission. Taken together we'd be lucky to match the current natural gas - I personally think no chance in hell. Carbon emission of natural gas isn't an issue because nobody [who matter] cares about it today, and then, when the issue is finally forced for resolution, adding carbon sequestration would still be a comparatively minor expense. And that not even talking about already free fusion used in solar and wind based generation - hard to beat economics of that fusion reactor.
- DennisP 6y agoWhether fusion is expensive depends on the reactor design. There are a lot of possibilities. On one end of the scale is ITER, the giant tokamak they're building in France for tens of billions of dollars. At the other end is the petawatt laser boron fusion idea being pursued by HB11 Energy and various other researchers around the world. The main expense would be the laser at tens of millions of dollars.