4 ms·
Is there any reason this couldn't be used for general purpose energy? They work for NASA so perhaps they are just mentioning propulsion to keep their funding.
by colordrops 6y ago
Is there any reason this couldn't be used for general purpose energy? They work for NASA so perhaps they are just mentioning propulsion to keep their funding.
- gh02t 6y agoAs noted by another commenter, this is a significant result but overall still very early. It's still not even clear if it can be used for energy production at all and there is a lot of work to be done before that will even be worth asking seriously. But a simple answer is: if it can be made to power a spacecraft it would probably be suitable elsewhere.
- Qwertious 6y ago>Is there any reason this couldn't be used for general purpose energy? It's possible to get out energy if you put enough energy in, but currently you can't even retrieve all the energy you started with, let alone generate energy efficiently enough to drop the cost below solar et al.
- leephillips 6y agoThe idea is that if you fantasize that this might, one day, have gain > 1 it would be much smaller and lighter than other forms of fusion that you might also fantasize would, one day, have gains > 1. But, in this fantasy world, terrestrial fusion reactors would have much higher fantasy gains, so you are accepting a lower fantasy gain for lower weight. The reality is, fusion energy research has been a major activity since the 1950s, but no device (aside from bombs) has achieved practical break-even, despite occasional breathless but deceptive press releases from national labs. http://progressive.org/op-eds/let-cut-our-losses-on-fusion-energy-180313/ http://progressive.org/op-eds/let-cut-our-losses-on-fusion-e...
- DennisP 6y agoI'm guessing because it'd be expensive and have a low power output. That'd make it uncompetitive for a power plant, but fine for a deep space mission; you'd need very little fuel, so as long as the device itself isn't too massive, it'd be great.
- gh02t 6y agoNot sure about the low power output. With the caveat that I'm a nuclear engineer but not a fusion expert, from what I understand the deuterium density is actually quite high compared to plasma-based systems like tokamaks. NASA's press release says the deuterium density in their lattice confinement process is a billion times more dense than the plasma in a magnetic confinement system (https://www1.grc.nasa.gov/space/science/lattice-confinement-fusion/ https://www1.grc.nasa.gov/space/science/lattice-confinement-...), though I note it's not clear exactly what they mean. So that is promising. If they can figure out how to sustain a chain reaction or otherwise extract a net energy gain it might still be useful as battery even if they end up having to put more energy to fabricate the fuel in than you get out. Something like how current RTGs are used, except I expect it would have much higher energy density. This is all speculation, however, and there is a lot of work left.
- DennisP 6y agoInteresting point. I just guessed at a plausible reason to focus on deep space, I don't know whether that's actually the case. It seems like it couldn't have too much power density though, or the solid lattice would melt.
- gh02t 6y agoThe lattice melting is probably not a major issue, you just have to cool it to remove the heat as it's generated. At a basic level you face the same problem in a fission reactor and the solution is straightforward -- extract the heat into some sort of working fluid (or gas) to keep the fuel from melting. Fission reactor fuel is actually not even terribly dissimilar to the stuff described in the article, most often it's fabricated as a sintered powder. Again, this is super early so this is all wild speculation, but generally engineering challenges are easier to solve than fundamental science problems. Of which there remain a few. That said, most of the problems with MCF are engineering issues and we still don't have that working yet either so...