4 ms·
> A giant corporation buys a Silicon Valley company I don't know what you mean by 'giant corporation' and 'Silicon Valley company' - do you think these groups
by chrisseaton 6y ago
> A giant corporation buys a Silicon Valley company
I don't know what you mean by 'giant corporation' and 'Silicon Valley company' - do you think these groups are distinct?
RedHat isn't a 'Silicon Valley company' as far as I know. It's from the east coast - North Carolina isn't it? The Carolinas seem as far as you can get from Silicon Valley, culturally and geographically.
And many Silicon Valley companies are traditional giant corporations - Oracle, Intel, etc.
- marmaduke 6y agoNorth Carolina in general is spectrum opposite from Silicon Valley save a few islands of prosperity such as the so called triangle of which Raleigh, where red hat was based, is a corner.
- philsnow 6y agoYeah, doesn't make sense to compare SV to "the Carolinas" any more than it makes sense to compare the research triangle in NC to "California". Both states contain proverbial multitudes.
- allencoin 6y ago> The Carolinas seem as far as you can get from Silicon Valley, culturally Why do you think that?
- chrisseaton 6y agoThe Carolinas are very Republican. California is very Democrat. That's just one measure. They're also geographically literally the other side of the country.
- allencoin 6y agoI was referring specifically to the "culturally" part. The geographic difference between Silicon Valley and North Carolina is indisputable, but I'm curious about your take on the culture. I see a lot of similarities between Republicans and Silicon Valley entrepreneurs, e.g. anti-regulation stances, anti-labor stances, etc.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> I see a lot of similarities between Republicans and Silicon Valley entrepreneurs, e.g. anti-regulation stances, anti-labor stances, etc. I don't know any companies, anywhere in the world, that compensate, pamper, and accomodate their labor as much as Silicon Valley.
- allencoin 6y agoAh, yes, the people that make Apple's iPhones are very pampered.
- chrisseaton 6y agoThat's an argument reducing to absurdity. Every company has an long chain of transitive contractors, and for every company you can work all your way down to the poorest person on Earth, so it's meaningless. I could similarly blame you for the labor conditions of these people - you paid Apple or whoever to make your phone so are you responsible for their conditions? The people that Apple employs are extraordinarily well treated and compensated, and that's a credit to Apple and their labor relations.
- allencoin 6y ago> you paid Apple or whoever to make your phone so are you responsible for their conditions? Yes, absolutely, to some degree — do you think I'm not? Even if you don't think so, do you think Apple isn't to some degree responsible for the working conditions of nearly a million employees within the company that it knowingly contracts out to to produce about 200 million iPhones a year? Follow up question: Which American political party do you think would be more likely to condone the above practice, Democrats or Republicans? Basically I'm trying to figure out why you think there's a big cultural difference between Silicon Valley (50 square miles) and "The Carolinas" (85,839 square miles) and why that's meaningful to the wider discussion. Your original comment perplexed me as someone who is familiar with both regions. I agree that they are dissimilar but I definitely don't think they are "as far as you can get ... culturally." Happy to get back to that original subject if you are.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoSo, we don't think the linux community and companies are much different from century-old business-process company with 1/3 million employees? Is this really a question, or just pedantry?
- foolmeonce 6y agoI find connection redhat has with the Linux community about the same as Intel's since at least as far back as 2008. I also know people who were as likely to get jobs at redhat as and of the other big Corp techs, I.e. Dell, Cisco. Is there really something distinct about red hat beyond the trademark and distant memories?
- chrisseaton 6y agoYeah, but 'Silicon Valley' isn't the term to use for that. I don't know why you think it would be? Silicon Valley is also huge old companies built with massive defence contracts. If you think Silicon Valley is mostly small startups you're mistaken.
- willcipriano 6y agoI use management focused vs technology focused when talking about this distinction. For me it boils down to is the organization more concerned about choices in regards to process/organizational structures or technology.
- woodandsteel 6y agoThat's technically true, but it doesn't do anything to advance the discussion of the issues the article raises. In particular, I really doubt that anyone who read the article was mislead by its use of the technically incorrect term "Silicon Valley."
- stale2002 6y agoI think that the most people reading that comment understand that this that is shorthand for "startupy tech company". When people refer to silicon valley, it is partially a reference to a place, but also partial a reference to simply culture. Most people understand this, and quibbling over the exact physical location is just valueless pedantry, when the meaning was fully understandable.