5 ms·
A giant corporation buys a Silicon Valley company, the result is generally carnage. The old-boy marketing-driven process-heavy big company will roll out decisio
by JoeAltmaier 6y ago
A giant corporation buys a Silicon Valley company, the result is generally carnage. The old-boy marketing-driven process-heavy big company will roll out decisions like a bowling ball careening across a cafeteria, knocking over tables and chairs and sending people running for cover.
Since big companies are driven by managers not engineers, and the managers are always, always from the bigger company, the decisions are perceived as clueless. They are generally about optimizing or cannibalizing the small-company product for fit with the big company product space. With superficial understanding of the product itself, generally confined to marketing descriptions.
Thus, carnage. Been through it twice.
- jariel 6y ago"driven by managers not engineers" Yeah, uh to assume that Engineers have some special managerial ability that 'managers' do not is the wrong take. Management is management. Some good, some bad. We can be cynical, but without knowing the details of these layoffs, we shouldn't assume anything. One of the advantages of M&A is ostensible synergy across many groups, for example, RedHat is unlikely going to need maintainers of its HR Portal, which will likely be rolled into the one from HQ. And probably some execs will be without jobs. It's possible that the layoff was in the works otherwise, or that they were literally made at the recommendation of outgoing people who were unable/unwilling to do a re-structure at the time. Right from the article: "The tricky thing is, IBM and Red Hat both have NC-based operations and a rather large number of workers there. It’s somewhat of a business hub. But we also know that IBM does not need two HR departments, two marketing departments, etc. Managers are sort of converging in duties, conflicting in terms of roles, overlapping in the workflow sense and so on."
- tyingq 6y agoI agree about the carnage part, but it happens regardless of the type of companies involved. There's a push to not have duplicate functions, products, etc. And people making decisions without having all the information.
- FanaHOVA 6y ago> old-boy marketing-driven process-heavy big company You mean Red Hat?
- ebg13 6y ago> A giant corporation buys a Silicon Valley company Redhat is not a Silicon Valley company.
- riffic 6y agoI think they're referring to "Silicon Valley" in the cultural sense, not the geographic one.
- _msw_ 6y agoDisclosure: I worked at Red Hat from 1998 until 2004 I never experienced a "Silicon Valley" culture at Red Hat, not pre-IPO as a scrappy startup, or post-IPO as a growing company. Red Hat these days is an enterprise software company, and I think it retains a unique culture that I'm (mostly) proud to have been a part of cultivating in the early days even as a division of IBM today.
- chrisseaton 6y agoBut what does that even mean? Oracle is a traditional Silicon Valley company. But presumably that's not what they mean either?
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoEnough with the digressions! An open-source-foundational company with roots in the microcomputer revolution, vs IBM? Is there anybody who doesn't see the difference? And no, IBM did not invent the microcomputer revolution - far, far from it. They put out an expensive iron boat anchor using other people's chips and designs that saddled the industry with obsolete choices for a decade. Just like you'd expect from a giant corporation.
- rdiddly 6y agoYou tryin' to say open source? Just say that. You created the digression. You: Oh you got a pet! Is it a dog or an apple? Him: Apples aren't really house pets. You: Oh brother, are you going to pretend nobody knows the difference between dogs & cats?
- chrisseaton 6y ago> A giant corporation buys a Silicon Valley company I don't know what you mean by 'giant corporation' and 'Silicon Valley company' - do you think these groups are distinct? RedHat isn't a 'Silicon Valley company' as far as I know. It's from the east coast - North Carolina isn't it? The Carolinas seem as far as you can get from Silicon Valley, culturally and geographically. And many Silicon Valley companies are traditional giant corporations - Oracle, Intel, etc.
- marmaduke 6y agoNorth Carolina in general is spectrum opposite from Silicon Valley save a few islands of prosperity such as the so called triangle of which Raleigh, where red hat was based, is a corner.
- philsnow 6y agoYeah, doesn't make sense to compare SV to "the Carolinas" any more than it makes sense to compare the research triangle in NC to "California". Both states contain proverbial multitudes.
- allencoin 6y ago> The Carolinas seem as far as you can get from Silicon Valley, culturally Why do you think that?
- chrisseaton 6y agoThe Carolinas are very Republican. California is very Democrat. That's just one measure. They're also geographically literally the other side of the country.
- allencoin 6y agoI was referring specifically to the "culturally" part. The geographic difference between Silicon Valley and North Carolina is indisputable, but I'm curious about your take on the culture. I see a lot of similarities between Republicans and Silicon Valley entrepreneurs, e.g. anti-regulation stances, anti-labor stances, etc.
- hinkley 6y agoI have yet to be in a buyout where I didn't end up feeling like livestock. The sale is good for people owning enough stock so that the only reason they show up tomorrow is because the new owners put conditions on the sale. For everyone else it's not good news. Even the hope that they will fix things that have been bothering you? Those will all be open for debate. As will all of the things you've already gotten resolved. You'll be lucky if they fix as many things as they break.
- jayd16 6y ago>Since big companies are driven by managers not engineers, and the managers are always, always from the bigger company, the decisions are perceived as clueless. Not only that. If they had a clue they wouldn't have needed to acquire the company in the first place.
- RhysU 6y agoLouis V. Gerstner, Jr. was IBM CEO when Red Hat was founded in 1993 (plus or minus 6 months because I am lazy and I don't want to look up specific dates). Having a clue and having a time machine are very different things.